QB Rankings: Who's the 30th best QB in football?

[Rock Strongo]

Who sucks the most? (by rating)

 

[Rock Strongo]

vote and discuss

 

[Wolverine830872]

Flawed Poll, no Kaepernick

 

[cdumler7]

Flawed Poll, no Kaepernick

Well I would say the bigger flaw in all of this is the fact that Rock Strongo seems to think there are only 30 teams in the league?

 

[sonnyblack65]

Not sure about 30th but Brady is the 32 worst starting QB. Hammer instilled this into me and showed me the errors of my way, for that I will be eternally grateful

 

[Rock Strongo]

Flawed Poll, no Kaepernick

its by rating and i had to include elis penchant for 20 picks seasons.

kaep DOES suck. im proud to say i said he would be figured out fast.

2014 NFL Player Passing Stats - National Football League - ESPN

 

[Clayton]

Its Geno Smith or Bortles. Ill go with Geno Smith because he is erratic and more experienced so he has fewer excuses.

 

[ducky]

If I had to bet on the worst QB for this coming year, my money would be on Mariota.

Off of the list provided, I would say Carr.

 

[HammerDown]

Including Blake Bortles is nonsense but I know what you're doing Rock. You're determining that QBR is bullshit so you can throw it in our face when Brady trainwrecks upon his return.

But good try. I guess?

 

[Rock Strongo]

Including Blake Bortles is nonsense but I know what you're doing Rock. You're determining that QBR is bullshit so you can throw it in our face when Brady trainwrecks upon his return.

But good try. I guess?

no, someone is doing a daily "whos #1, whos #2" etc...so i jumped to the end.

shouldnt you be in manhattan with your cheater tshirt on?

 

[HammerDown]

no, someone is doing a daily "whos #1, whos #2" etc...so i jumped to the end.

shouldnt you be in manhattan with your cheater tshirt on?

Yeah, what he's doing is legit. Your's? Not so much.

Unless a woman drags me back to NYC, a tow truck will never be able to. Not even Tom Terrible.

 

[cdumler7]

If I had to bet on the worst QB for this coming year, my money would be on Mariota.

Off of the list provided, I would say Carr.

Carr is one that I have this funny feeling that he is going to be one of those very injury prone players like Sam Bradford. In his first year he suffered about 3 different injuries with them requiring him to miss some game time then he missed quite a bit of the OTA's this summer because of a finger injury. While I do think the Raiders have upgraded their offense around Carr I don't think they have done enough OL wise to protect him from taking a ton of hits this year so I just see him once again struggling through some nagging injuries.

 

[Rock Strongo]

Yeah, what he's doing is legit. Your's? Not so much.

Unless a woman drags me back to NYC, a tow truck will never be able to. Not even Tom Terrible.

mines legit. its based on the bottom feeders in QBR last year.

why isnt it legit if i am using a valid metric?

 

[cdumler7]

mines legit. its based on the bottom feeders in QBR last year.

why isnt it legit if i am using a valid metric?

Well considering we already have a football poll going on determining QB's in the league shouldn't we just wait for that one to get to the end? This feels like we are skipping to the last chapter of the book to find out who the killer is when we haven't read any of the rest of the book. Just kind of ruins the surprise.

 

[Rock Strongo]

Well considering we already have a football poll going on determining QB's in the league shouldn't we just wait for that one to get to the end? This feels like we are skipping to the last chapter of the book to find out who the killer is when we haven't read any of the rest of the book. Just kind of ruins the surprise.

im impatient.

 

[HammerDown]

mines legit. its based on the bottom feeders in QBR last year.

why isnt it legit if i am using a valid metric?

You listed Blake Bortles. Not by any measure would experts consider him a bottom feeder.

It's legit because everyone is voting for the best. Then that QB is removed and we drop to the next best.

 

[cdumler7]

im impatient.

Couldn't tell...How are you going to be able to wait for the ruling on Tom Brady? It could be close to the beginning of the season before we actually know what Goodell decides on that matter.

 

[Rock Strongo]

You listed Blake Bortles. Not by any measure would experts consider him a bottom feeder.

It's legit because everyone is voting for the best. Then that QB is removed and we drop to the next best.

now, im no fancy N- F-LLL expert...i just uses them there links on the espn.

2014 NFL Player Passing Stats - National Football League - ESPN

statistically, he was terrible last year.

statistically.

 

[Rock Strongo]

Couldn't tell...How are you going to be able to wait for the ruling on Tom Brady? It could be close to the beginning of the season before we actually know what Goodell decides on that matter.

no, about 1-2 weeks.

 

[HammerDown]

now, im no fancy N- F-LLL expert...i just uses them there links on the espn.

2014 NFL Player Passing Stats - National Football League - ESPN

statistically, he was terrible last year.

statistically.

I know what you're doing, rock. And it's not going to make the sting of the Brady trainwreck any easier when it happens.

When it does, I'm going to make you miserable.