I tend to agree with that, though he did have a pretty nice year. I definitely favor Bumgarner. Still, the Pirates have some dangerous bats, particularly from the right side of the plate. As illustrated by last night's game, so tough to say what might happen in just one game.
CF Blanco
2B Panik
3B Sandoval
C Posey
RF Pence
1B Belt
LF Ishikawa
SS Crawford
P Bum (silver slugger winner - he is a beast with the bat - 4 HRs, 2 Grand Slams this year)