Why does firing management mean tearing it all down? Fans are frustrated because the Mariners have an amazing foundation to win a WS but have gotten progressively worse and worse offensively.So if we win the AL West and make it to the ALDS and lose you would fire all management and tear this entire thing apart and start from scratch again and erase all the hard work done to this point because we didn't make it to the world series? Everybody wants the mariners to be this great 100 win team full of all these players. I am telling you with my own two eyes that doesn't matter. I watched a 90 win Rangers team literally SWEEP Tampa and Baltimore in the playoffs. I watched Arizona SWEEP the LA Dodgers. I don't care what the team looks like because in the end its simple. Where are we at the all star break in the standings and where are we in the standings when the season is over. When the playoffs all those numbers are erased and its a brand new ball game buddy.
Why does firing management mean tearing it all down? Fans are frustrated because the Mariners have an amazing foundation to win a WS but have gotten progressively worse and worse offensively.
So you are scared of change. That is all you had to stay instead of all of your weird arguments.Because it essentially is a tear down. This team is built on the vision of JD if you bring in new management they are going to come in with their own vision of how to manage a franchise. They will most likely get rid of the manager Servais and the coaching staff and that alone will change the entire chemistry of the locker room because as he has been the manager going on 8 years so we don't know the possible negative or positive response players would have to that because guys like Kirby, Gilbert, and J Rod have known him their professional career. We don't know the effects of new coaches, management and players coming to the team changing chemistry. Could things get better? Possibly yes, to me is it worth the risk as we are in first place in the West on the majors level with a very good farm system put together? To me I wouldn't pull that plug until we make major leaps backwards and start finishing below .500 at the end of the season.
So you are scared of change. That is all you had to stay instead of all of your weird arguments.
Dipoto’s “vision”. Dude it’s baseball, it’s not football or basketball where you get guys to fit a certain offense or defense. If they overhaul the FO and coaching staff the players will be fine. They traded for team leaders in the offseason, traded clubhouse leaders two times in the years previous.
If they bring in a whole new group to lead the team it is only because the team underperformed during a championship window, not because they were a dog crap overall team.
Can you point to an example in baseball? Baseball is not basketball or football where the players have a lot more control. The players have been fine when the clubhouse leaders were traded, why would a manager be any different? Especially for this ball club that has a crap load of guys that can’t afford to dog it.I think you really underestimate the optics of management in sports especially at the professional level. I absolutely promise you if a manager is liked by the players and there is an understanding of the culture around the locker room. If the players felt the firing of their manager was unjust or premature that can cause a rift in the chemistry which is more important in baseball then in basketball and football where you can out talent the opposing team for wins. There is a reason why the Seahawks management fired Pete Caroll after his prime team disintegrated and the new core didn't respond to his leadership. You can't just trade away whatever player you want and expect nobody to care, people are not robots.
So stay at the see if you can get lucky and limp into a WC slot every year only actually making it once a decade or so to avoid your fears that a change at the top could make them slide back even more.Because it essentially is a tear down. This team is built on the vision of JD if you bring in new management they are going to come in with their own vision of how to manage a franchise. They will most likely get rid of the manager Servais and the coaching staff and that alone will change the entire chemistry of the locker room because as he has been the manager going on 8 years so we don't know the possible negative or positive response players would have to that because guys like Kirby, Gilbert, and J Rod have known him their professional career. We don't know the effects of new coaches, management and players coming to the team changing chemistry. Could things get better? Possibly yes, to me is it worth the risk as we are in first place in the West on the majors level with a very good farm system put together? To me I wouldn't pull that plug until we make major leaps backwards and start finishing below .500 at the end of the season.
So stay at the see if you can get lucky and limp into a WC slot every year only actually making it once a decade or so to avoid your fears that a change at the top could make them slide back even more.
We've reached the ceiling for Dipoto and Servais as a pair. Their philosophy and approach doesn't win championships.
We have seen this team go from bad to worse on regime changes in the past. I get the fear. Lou was the only change in franchise history that put you on a track to winning. He ended up leaving here because he didn't get the support of the front office that he wanted and they were never the same after.
I've said this before many times. The problem isn't just Servais or Dipoto. We do not have an ownership group with a focus on winning championships. They are here purely for profits and if they happen to get lucky and reach a championship that's a nice little bonus on their bottom line.
Still, some of us are not satisfied with the status quo. We are not good with the idea that this is all the team is ever going to be under this group.
They are toxic to hitting and that's a major problem. If they would adjust their system instead of changing out one mediocre player after another year after year and watching it do nothing I'd retain hope for them. Dipoto was a pitcher and Servais a catcher. That side of the game they know. Hitting and fielding they don't. And it shows.
Dipoto could replace Servais with a manger that focused on all parts of the team, but I fear it wouldn't lead to a major run because again it isn't just him. I'd still be in favor of at least trying because you have less to lose than gain.
You keep making every post about firing those guys when most of us have resigned ourselves to accepting that we won't get what we want under this ownership group. Changing out Dipoto and Servais won't mean anything if an ownership group focused entirely on money is the group replacing them. You could get lucky and find another Lou, but I wouldn't hold my breath.
We heard from Dipoto last year enough to know he's never going to change or grow. He's doing is a favor to tell us to be patient about reaching the WS. Building up a program focused on winning 54% will pay off. Some day. He says.
Unless Jerry trades for a bat or two, there isn't any matchup I would say is an easy sweep or easy 2-1 series win.Two things can absolutely be true at the same time. I can say hey from this date to this date its going to be a rough go because the majority of the teams we are playing are over .500 trying to make the playoffs. Even with the rough patch (which by the way every team in the MLB goes through a rough patch) we are going into favorable match ups and yes I still believe my Mariners can make the playoffs.