MLB One Player Per Team Championship : Milk - UK - Nos

[Nosferatu]

MILK

LINEUP
1. Rickey Henderson - LF - Yankees (R)
2. Eddie Collins - 2B - White Sox (L)
3. Miguel Cabrera - DH - Marlins (R)
4. Eddie Mathews - 3B - Braves (L)
5. Roberto Clemente - RF - Pirates (R)
6. Johnny Mize - 1B - Giants (L)
7. Gary Carter - C - Nationals (R)
8. Ozzie Smith - SS - Cardinals (B)
9. Carlos Beltran - CF - Royals (B)


BENCH
Sammy Sosa - RF - Cubs (R)
Richie Ashburn - CF - Phillies (L)
Adam Dunn - LF/1B - Reds (L)
Maury Wills - SS/3B - Dodgers (B)
Jonathan Lucroy - C - Brewers

ROTATION
1. Cy Young - Indians (R)
2. Lefty Grove - Red Sox (L)
3. Eddie Plank - A's (L)
4. Fergie Jenkins - Rangers (R)
5. David Price - Rays (L)

BULLPEN
Hoyt Wilhelm - Orioles (R)
Billy Wagner - Astros (L)
John Hiller - Tigers (L)
Joe Nathan - Twins (R)
Armando Benitez - Mets (R)

VS

UK

LINEUP
1. Tris Speaker - CF - Indians (L)
2. Nap Lajoie - 2B - Phillies (R)
3. George Brett - 3B - Royals (L)
4. Ralph Kiner - DH - Pirates (L)
5. Al Kaline - RF - Tigers (R)
6. Carl Yastrzemski - LF - Red Sox (L)
7. Yadier Molina - C - Cardinals (R)
8. Todd Helton - 1B - Rockies (L)
9. Robin Yount - SS - Brewers (R)


BENCH
Dave Winfield - RF - Padres (R)
Craig Biggio - 2B/C - Astros (R)
Juan Gonzalez - OF - Rangers (R)
Jose Reyes - SS - Mets (B)
Brooks Robinson - 3B - Orioles (R)

ROTATION
1. Walter Johnson - Twins (R)
2. Christy Mathewson - Giants (R)
3. Clayton Kershaw - Dodgers (L)
4. Mordecai Brown - Cubs (R)
5. Felix Hernandez - Mariners (R)

BULLPEN
Mariano Rivera - Yankees (R)
Bobby Shantz - A's (L)
Wilbur Wood - White Sox (L)
Rob Dibble - Reds (R)
Gene Garber - Braves (R)

VS

NOS

LINEUP
1. Rod Carew - 2B - Twins (L)
2. Shoeless Joe Jackson - LF - White Sox (L)
3. Mickey Mantle - CF - Yankees (B)
4. Stan Musial - 1B - Cardinals (L)
5. Hank Greenberg - DH - Tigers (R)
6. Mel Ott - RF - Giants (L)
7. Dick Allen - 3B - Phillies (R)
8. Carlton Fisk - C - Red Sox (R)
9. Arky Vaughan - SS - Pirates (L)

BENCH
Lance Berkman - LF/RF/1B - Astros (B)
Joe Torre - C/1B/3B - Braves (R)
Fred McGriff - 1B/DH/PH - Rays (L)
Marquis Grissom - CF/PR - Nationals (R)
Bobby Grich - 2B/SS - Angels (R)

ROTATION
1. Sandy Koufax - Dodgers (L)
2. Luis Tiant - Indians (R)
3. David Cone - Mets (R)
4. Mike Cuellar - Orioles (L)
5. Catfish Hunter - A's (R)

BULLPEN
Tom Henke - Blue Jays (R)
Aroldis Chapman - Reds (L)
Bruce Sutter - Cubs (R)
Dan Quisenberry - Royals (R)
Dan Plesac - Brewers (L)

 

[Nosferatu]

Milk = 16
UK = 19
Nos = 24

Voted = UK. Nos. Gold. 500. Smitty. WLK. EHB. Ritz. Milk. Hockey

LOWEST SCORE WINS

Please when voting list 1st - 2nd - 3rd


CONGRATS MILK

 

[UK Cowboy]

I'm voting for myself. I think I have the best rotation, best pen, a great lineup and the best bench. Can't go wrong voting for Nos or Milk, I've already tied Milks outstanding team and Nos team is excellent as well. Good Luck

UK
Milk
Nos

 

[Nosferatu]

I'll be voting for myself I have to disagree with my buddy who says he has the best pen and bench I think his pen and bench are both 3rd here. Winfield and Gonzalez don't make sense for me. No question he has he strongest rotation but I believe his lineup is also 3rd. As great as his rotation is I just think Milk and my "teams" are both better.

I must also say I wouldn't blame anyone for voting for any of these teams as they are all excellent, you just gotta get really nitpicky when dealing with teams this good.

If I had to rank all 4 components of our teams

Lineup
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

Bench
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

Rotation
1. UK
2. Milk
3. Nos

Pen
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

SO MY VOTE IS
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

 

[UK Cowboy]

I'll be voting for myself I have to disagree with my buddy who says he has the best pen and bench I think his pen and bench are both 3rd here. Winfield and Gonzalez don't make sense for me. No question he has he strongest rotation but I believe his lineup is also 3rd. As great as his rotation is I just think Milk and my "teams" are both better.

I must also say I wouldn't blame anyone for voting for any of these teams as they are all excellent, you just gotta get really nitpicky when dealing with teams this good.

If I had to rank all 4 components of our teams

Lineup
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

Bench
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

Rotation
1. UK
2. Milk
3. Nos

Pen
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

SO MY VOTE IS
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

HaHa, as often as you have called folks out for the way they vote(via rankings, whatever), I gotta call you out too. I've got no problem with anyone voting for any of these teams, they could all win on a given day. But after voting yourself #1(all 3 of us will do that), you voted Milk 2 and me 3. No problem there either, EXCEPT that you voted for me against Milk head to head LMAO. Could it be because I voted you 3? It reminds of the old Eddie Murphy skit when his wife caught him in bed with another woman...."Now Baby.....are you gonna believe what you see....or what I tell you??? Ok you want to hear me say it, I F''''d her. We F''''d......But I make love to you"

 

[Gold Rush 86]

1. Milky 2. UK 3. Nos

 

[mr.hockey4242]

well this sucks ass I voted UK in a squeaker over Milk already. At same time I like Nos over UK but Milk over Nos if the match ups happened that way.

Can my votes count as a tie???? Lol

 

[UK Cowboy]

I'll be voting for myself I have to disagree with my buddy who says he has the best pen and bench I think his pen and bench are both 3rd here. Winfield and Gonzalez don't make sense for me. No question he has he strongest rotation but I believe his lineup is also 3rd. As great as his rotation is I just think Milk and my "teams" are both better.

I must also say I wouldn't blame anyone for voting for any of these teams as they are all excellent, you just gotta get really nitpicky when dealing with teams this good.

If I had to rank all 4 components of our teams

Lineup
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

Bench
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

Rotation
1. UK
2. Milk
3. Nos

Pen
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

SO MY VOTE IS
1. Nos
2. Milk
3. UK

On the Bench. Winfield played CF and RF, Gonzalez LF and RF. Robinson played 3B, I don't need a backup 1st baseman because Brett could play 1B. Biggio played 2nd, C and OF and Reyes played SS. That's all positions covered, not sure where you are confused. Honestly, I'd say

Winfield over Berkman(HOF agrees)
Biggio over Grich(HOF agrees)
Gonzalez over McGriff(2 MVP's)
Robinson over Torre(HOF player over induction as Manager)
Reyes over Grissom(all day)

How again is your bench better lol

 

[Pack 500]

1. Milk 2. UK 3. Nos

 

[broncosmitty]

2%, UK, Nos

This team of Milks might be my favorite from a baseball Mock. His bullpen definitely is. As usual UKs rotation is disgusting and I like Nos' team overall a lot. The lineup more than the staff though.

Excellent teams all around fellas. Good drafting by everyone.

 

[Nosferatu]

Actually since you are being a dick and calling me out. Am I not allowed to change my mind after having looked at the teams a little closer? I voted for your team in the first round because of your rotation I thought the teams were so close I gave you the edge because of the rotation but after looking at a 3rd team in the mix and looking closer at bench and pen I think Milks lineup, bench and pen are all slightly better than yours and the fact your rotation is a bit better doesn't make up for the lineups, benches and pens.

Also FUCK YOU for saying it had to do with you voting me 3rd, I don't give two shits if I win, if you notice I haven't said a single word when anyone voted for EHB or 500 against me, I just don't care anymore about winning the fun is in the drafting. Funny thing you bring that up being you have gone out of your way to make sure I never win a baseball draft, I wonder if that's part of the reason you voted me 3rd. Hmmmm

Let's remember we are suppose to be having fun... I just spent the last what seems like an hour looking back at our drafts for MLB, I have found that I have voted for you far more than you have voted for me in fact in your last 5 MLB Championship games I have voted for you twice against you twice and for myself once. All the while you have spent time reminding me and everyone else how I've never won a MLB draft... Sure seems like you'd like to keep it that way...

 

[Nosferatu]

On the Bench. Winfield played CF and RF, Gonzalez LF and RF. Robinson played 3B, I don't need a backup 1st baseman because Brett could play 1B. Biggio played 2nd, C and OF and Reyes played SS. That's all positions covered, not sure where you are confused. Honestly, I'd say

Winfield over Berkman(HOF agrees)
Biggio over Grich(HOF agrees)
Gonzalez over McGriff(2 MVP's)
Robinson over Torre(HOF player over induction as Manager)
Reyes over Grissom(all day)

How again is your bench better lol

Winfield and Gonzalez are both power rightys why do you need two? McGriff gives me a lefty power bat something you don't have. Robinson was not good with the bat Torre was. Reyes over Grissom all day huh? Grissom better power numbers Grissom stole more than 70 twice Reyes once, Grissom better with the glove! All Day LMAO... So now HOF decides whos better? Grich OPS+ 125 Biggio OPS+ 112 Keep making shit up as you go... You do understand what a bench is for right? You have no lefty power bat that eliminates you from any talk about best bench

 

[Nosferatu]

Looks like i'm finishing 3rd in this one, ugh! LOLZZZ

Remember I had a good staff in the draft that we don't talk about...

 

[ehb5]

1. UK
2. Nos
3. Milk

 

[UK Cowboy]

Actually since you are being a dick and calling me out. Am I not allowed to change my mind after having looked at the teams a little closer? I voted for your team in the first round because of your rotation I thought the teams were so close I gave you the edge because of the rotation but after looking at a 3rd team in the mix and looking closer at bench and pen I think Milks lineup, bench and pen are all slightly better than yours and the fact your rotation is a bit better doesn't make up for the lineups, benches and pens.

Also FUCK YOU for saying it had to do with you voting me 3rd, I don't give two shits if I win, if you notice I haven't said a single word when anyone voted for EHB or 500 against me, I just don't care anymore about winning the fun is in the drafting. Funny thing you bring that up being you have gone out of your way to make sure I never win a baseball draft, I wonder if that's part of the reason you voted me 3rd. Hmmmm

Let's remember we are suppose to be having fun... I just spent the last what seems like an hour looking back at our drafts for MLB, I have found that I have voted for you far more than you have voted for me in fact in your last 5 MLB Championship games I have voted for you twice against you twice and for myself once. All the while you have spent time reminding me and everyone else how I've never won a MLB draft... Sure seems like you'd like to keep it that way...

Fuck You back dude. Being your pissy self after getting your ass kicked for the hundredth time in a row in your favorite sport. You talk real big behind your keyboard son. You've already ran Ritz off, I'm out to. Maybe if you play alone you can win one

 

[wlk3]

1. UK
2. Nos
3. Milk

I'm a little confused by what Smitty is seeing in Milks team... I don't dispute it, in fact I respect your opinion a ton... That's what's confusing, you are completely clear and I'm sure it's just good... Not trying to tear you down Milk, in fact you've made me part of the OBP police... I will add the I got a ton of help from Best Of lists, which it looks like you don't follow, which I also respect... I guess what I'm saying is I've got a lot to learn... Good job you 3...

 

[Nosferatu]

Fuck You back dude. Being your pissy self after getting your ass kicked for the hundredth time in a row in your favorite sport. You talk real big behind your keyboard son. You've already ran Ritz off, I'm out to. Maybe if you play alone you can win one

How am I being pissy? You came after me! Yeah I did lose again in baseball did you see me attacking anyone for it? This post did make me chuckle I gotta admit, like somehow you've never gotten angry or said anything when you lost, you went on about Oscar Schmidt for a week and called people morons! Also, i'm trying to remember a time where I attacked you personally in front of everyone, I can't seem to remember a time! Talk big behind my keyboard son? Pot have you met Kettle... Im curious, if the reason you're quitting is it because I ranked you 3rd? Is it because you could lose to Milk? Is it because your streak could be over? Or is it because you attacked me personally and I defended myself?

I really did enjoy the maybe if I play alone I could win, do I need to again remind you who's won more Championships between the two of us?

I ran Ritz off? Well he explained to me he's tired of not winning with good teams, which can be said about everyone honestly, WLK didn't win for a long time but he finally did and twice now. Unless of course you mean I ran him off by him calling me names and threatening me here for everyone to see and then me apologizing to him for the entire misunderstanding regarding the draft that will not be mentioned. Unless of course you are calling him a liar and he really quit because of me, i'm curious as to what the reason was now, were he and I fighting? Not that I know of...

I think some people have lost sight of what these were intended for, to have some fun talk smack with some people and draft some teams, I myself may have got to a point where I forgot what this was about but what happened to the entire situation with the draft we restarted made me realize this isn't fun anymore, I didn't attack anyone who voted for EHB or 500 against me, I honestly didn't say a word. I also did not attack anyone when it became obvious I wasn't winning this draft, only when attacked did I respond. So honestly Troy if you are out you'll be missed but we will move on...

 

[UK Cowboy]

Actually since you are being a dick and calling me out. Am I not allowed to change my mind after having looked at the teams a little closer? I voted for your team in the first round because of your rotation I thought the teams were so close I gave you the edge because of the rotation but after looking at a 3rd team in the mix and looking closer at bench and pen I think Milks lineup, bench and pen are all slightly better than yours and the fact your rotation is a bit better doesn't make up for the lineups, benches and pens.

Also FUCK YOU for saying it had to do with you voting me 3rd, I don't give two shits if I win, if you notice I haven't said a single word when anyone voted for EHB or 500 against me, I just don't care anymore about winning the fun is in the drafting. Funny thing you bring that up being you have gone out of your way to make sure I never win a baseball draft, I wonder if that's part of the reason you voted me 3rd. Hmmmm

Let's remember we are suppose to be having fun... I just spent the last what seems like an hour looking back at our drafts for MLB, I have found that I have voted for you far more than you have voted for me in fact in your last 5 MLB Championship games I have voted for you twice against you twice and for myself once. All the while you have spent time reminding me and everyone else how I've never won a MLB draft... Sure seems like you'd like to keep it that way...

Bump. That's fine dude. Move on. I'm not advocating anyone quit, it's a good bunch of guys having fun, yourself included. I'm just sick of BS like this post every time we play. Peace and havefun

 

[Nosferatu]

Bump. That's fine dude. Move on. I'm not advocating anyone quit, it's a good bunch of guys having fun, yourself included. I'm just sick of BS like this post every time we play. Peace and havefun

Once again, had you not called me out there would have been no such post. Not sure how I can be more clear on that. Let's also not forget the Oscar Schmidt incident, are you saying only you can post anything when upset or challenged? Come on...

 

[Gold Rush 86]

All this fighting is making Hockey rock hard!