POLL Is Eli worthy of the Hall of Fame

[megalodon30]

The Manning goon squad will force him into the HOF just like they forced the chargers to trade him to the Giants.

The entire manning family personifies everything that is wrong with the NFL today. Every one of them should be ashamed of themselves.

Except Peyton. Peyton is the GOAT.

Go Broncos!

 

[dbldwn711]

Except Peyton. Peyton is the GOAT.

Go Broncos!

sexually assaulting, steroid taking, cheater.

 

[PhilSimms11]

If you vote no, you must be retarded.

7th in passing touchdowns
7th in passing yards

That's what a QB does. Passes the ball.

Then he also has two Super Bowl wins.

I'll be one of these fucktards...Um..yeah, but he gots good coaches, run backs, seevers and stuff so that taint just cuzza him. Game dun changed. Hee...hee not hall famer. Hiz naym beein Mannin gon get him inn tho.

 

[megalodon30]

sexually assaulting, steroid taking, cheater.

 

[dbldwn711]

you’ve got a point.

 

[broncosmitty]

People are dumb.


Dudes a lock.

 

[megalodon30]

you’ve got a point.

And to be fair...

The entire manning family personifies everything that is wrong with the NFL today.

I think Taryn Manning should get a pass too.

 

[megalodon30]

People are dumb.


Dudes a lock.

That isn't what the question is asking.

 

[broncosmitty]

That isn't what the question is asking.

I'm letting people know, they're dumb.

 

[megalodon30]

I'm letting people know, they're dumb.

Saying he's a lock doesn't answer if he is worthy or not.

 

[broncosmitty]

Saying he's a lock doesn't answer if he is worthy or not.

Don't fucking care.

 

[wazzu31]

The Manning goon squad will force him into the HOF just like they forced the chargers to trade him to the Giants.

The entire manning family personifies everything that is wrong with the NFL today. Every one of them should be ashamed of themselves.

Eli > Peyton

 

[PhilSimms11]

Is Troy Aikman a HOF worthy QB? 94-71 record, 2,898-4,715 passing (61.5%), 28.5 PA/G, 32,942 yards passing, 165 TD, 141 INT, 81.6 passer rating, 3 Super Bowl titles (1 MVP)

Eli Manning--117-117 record, 4,895-8,119 passing (60.3%), 34.6 PA/G, 57,023 yards passing, 366 TD, 244 INT, 84.1 passer rating, 2 Super Bowl titles (2 MVPs)

Super Bowls:
Troy Aikman-
22-30, 273 yards, 4 TD, 0 INT
19-27, 207 yards, 0 TD, 1 INT
15-23, 209 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT

Eli Manning:
19-34, 255 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT
30-40, 296 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT

The popular responses seem to be:
Is Troy Aikman a Hall-of-Famer? Oh yeah. No question. First ballot.
Is Eli Manning a Hall-of-Famer? FUCK NO. HE SUCKS.

I'm not suggesting that Troy Aikman isn't HOF worthy, but he did hand the ball to Emmitt Smith for 11 years behind that awesome offensive line. Did Eli have an Emmitt Smith and an awesome offensive line throughout his career?

 

[Robotech]

Is Troy Aikman a HOF worthy QB? 94-71 record, 2,898-4,715 passing (61.5%), 28.5 PA/G, 32,942 yards passing, 165 TD, 141 INT, 81.6 passer rating, 3 Super Bowl titles (1 MVP)

Eli Manning--117-117 record, 4,895-8,119 passing (60.3%), 34.6 PA/G, 57,023 yards passing, 366 TD, 244 INT, 84.1 passer rating, 2 Super Bowl titles (2 MVPs)

Super Bowls:
Troy Aikman-
22-30, 273 yards, 4 TD, 0 INT
19-27, 207 yards, 0 TD, 1 INT
15-23, 209 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT

Eli Manning:
19-34, 255 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT
30-40, 296 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT

The popular responses seem to be:
Is Troy Aikman a Hall-of-Famer? Oh yeah. No question. First ballot.
Is Eli Manning a Hall-of-Famer? FUCK NO. HE SUCKS.

I'm not suggesting that Troy Aikman isn't HOF worthy, but he did hand the ball to Emmitt Smith for 11 years behind that awesome offensive line. Did Eli have an Emmitt Smith and an awesome offensive line throughout his career?

I don't think Aikman belongs in the HOF. Borderline at best. I think you'd have to go back to at least the 1970s to find another QB who was on stacked teams who had stats like Aikman. And of course, passing was a lot harder back in the '70s.

What's funny is that Aikman's supporters say that having Emmitt and that running game actually hurt his stats because he would have more passing TD's if he didn't have Emmitt. I don't believe that, though.

 

[fastforward]

Not scientific but...

Pro Bowl = 1 point.
1st-team All-Pro = 1 point.
2nd-team All-Pro = ½ point.
All Decade 1st-team = 1 point.
All Decade 2nd-team = ½ point.

I don't think a post 1990 player gets in without at least 6 points. Aikman got in with a minimum 6 points. E.Manning has 4 points. For reference Andy Dalton has 3 and Flacco has 0.

 

[Breed]

It's great for him that he won 2 Super Bowls, where his offense averaged 18 points per game, but it shouldn't mean that he is a Hall of Famer.

No doubt with his looking like the Great Gazoo from the Flintstones with his extra large helmet wearin ass. And he wasn't deserving of that first Super Bowl MVP. Maybe the only worse Super Bowl MVP was Brady in the Rams/Pats SB.

 

[SU Nittany Tide]

sexually assaulting, steroid taking, cheater.

When did anybody bring up Brady?

 

[BigKen]

Manning's 2 SB MVPs should have gone to the two receivers that gave him the hardware. Both catches were extraordinary and extraordinarily lucky. 99.99% of the time both of those catches are dropped. Seriously, how many helmet catches have you seen in your life?? How many times have you seen a defender keep a receiver in bounds? That being said, Eli got the MNPs as much because he was Peyton's little brother than for his performance.

No question, he'll get in. His stats are comparable to some of the slugs that have a bronze bust in Canton and he has as many or more championships than many. It is what it is. I don't have an problem with it because he's better than more than a few of those before him.

 

[eaglesnut]

With the 6th most pass attempts. Whoopity do. He'll be out of the top 10 in both soon enough. He has a horrible career passer rating for this day and age. Those numbers you mention have everything to do with longevity and nothing to do with quality.

So you're saying he was so good they let him throw a lot. Yup, hall of famer for this league.

 

[SU Nittany Tide]

So you're saying he was so good they let him throw a lot. Yup, hall of famer for this league.

No. His average throw was garbage. Nice try though.