Is Aaron Judge the best (righty) hitter we've ever seen?

[BostonBeans]

No

 

[Wamu]

No

You got any brains?

Well look at that, you already answered.

 

[msgkings322]

No

He'd need to do this a lot more years to be in the conversation but in terms of peak years he's already had a few that are as good as Mays or Pujols or Thomas or Aaron or even old timers like Wagner and Hornsby

 

[molsaniceman]

He'd need to do this a lot more years to be in the conversation but in terms of peak years he's already had a few that are as good as Mays or Pujols or Thomas or Aaron or even old timers like Wagner and Hornsby

hornsby 1924

led 15 catagories

 

[msgkings322]

hornsby 1924
View attachment 397651
led 15 catagories

Another great year, definitely compares to the ones Judge has had lately

The game was a little different then (.424 averages are not happening anymore). Judge's 2024 OPS+ is the same as Hornsby's 100 years ago that you linked. One tick higher actually, so compared to his peers Judge had a similar year.

 

[black francis]

.768 playoff ops with strikeouts in 40% of his at bats.

Not clutch

 

[navamind]

You got any brains?

Well look at that, you already answered.

Gee, I wonder whose alt that is.

 

[navamind]

Judge currently owns the all-time best OPS+ among RHH, edging out Hornsby 177 to 175. Of course, Hornsby also has more than double the PA. Mule Suttles and Mike Trout are tied for 3rd at 172. Mantle was a switch hitter, but about 2/3 of his PA were as a lefty

Career Leaders &amp Records for Adjusted OPS+ | Baseball-Reference.com

Career OPS+ Leaders:1.Babe Ruth+/206/10628, 2.Ted Williams+/191/9792, 3.Oscar Charleston+/184/3885, 4.Barry Bonds/182/12606, 5.Lou Gehrig+/179/9665, 6.<strong>Aaron Judge</strong>/177/4518, Turkey Stearnes+/177/4279, 8.Rogers Hornsby+/175/9481, 9.Mickey Mantle+/172/9910, Mul

www.baseball-reference.com

 

[BostonBeans]

You got any brains?

Well look at that, you already answered.

He needs to do it longer like Mays, Aaron and Robinson

He'd need to do this a lot more years to be in the conversation but in terms of peak years he's already had a few that are as good as Mays or Pujols or Thomas or Aaron or even old timers like Wagner and Hornsby

agreed. That’s why I answered “No” to the question

 

[broncosmitty]

Gee, I wonder whose alt that is.

I want it to be Rock.

 

[BostonBeans]

hes got a long ways to go
judge

View attachment 397132

Williams who missed 5 years in the service

View attachment 397133

Williams was probably the most complete hitter in MLB history