Im sorry Mussina isnt deserving of HOF.

[Montalban]

Seems to me the problem is that you have a bad memory.

I seriously doubt any layman remembers Mussina's contribution to baseball without a reminder. You are a stubborn one, I'll give you that.

 

[Montalban]

Is there a minimum number of billboards/commercials that the player needs to be featured on to be HOF worthy?

The standard provided by the HoF that I gave you earlier in this thread tells you all you need to know.

 

[Yanks23242]

Good lord you are an obstinate one. Your opinion is valid, misguided though it may be. But thank you for allowing me to feel about the Hall the way I do, I appreciate that. I'll use the standard from the HoF that I posted in this thread.

Please, the “standard” you quoted is vague as shit and you’re not even following it when it comes to Mussina. There’s been around 8000 pitchers to pitch in the major leagues and Moose has been better than all but 25-30 of them. So he’s performed better than 99.7% of everyone who’s ever played his position and that’s not “legendary” enough for your ass. Get the fuck out of here.

 

[Yanks23242]

I seriously doubt any layman remembers Mussina's contribution to baseball without a reminder. You are a stubborn one, I'll give you that.

When all else fails lay out a ridiculous hypothetical

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

The standard provided by the HoF that I gave you earlier in this thread tells you all you need to know.

Yeah, that you're a fucking dipshit.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Please, the “standard” you quoted is vague as shit and you’re not even following it when it comes to Mussina. There’s been around 8000 pitchers to pitch in the major leagues and Moose has been better than all but 25-30 of them. So he’s performed better than 99.7% of everyone who’s ever played his position and that’s not “legendary” enough for your ass. Get the fuck out of here.

I understand in WAR he is 23rd EVER... But in no way does that mean he is a top 25 pitcher... In no way is he even top 50...

Even with my arguments against him on this thread, I will admit, he was always on my fence, and I really don't mind him being in... As I agree, he is better than a bunch of SP already in it...

But I just think it is a huge injustice to call him a top 25 pitcher of all time...

 

[Montalban]

Please, the “standard” you quoted is vague as shit and you’re not even following it when it comes to Mussina. There’s been around 8000 pitchers to pitch in the major leagues and Moose has been better than all but 25-30 of them. So he’s performed better than 99.7% of everyone who’s ever played his position and that’s not “legendary” enough for your ass. Get the fuck out of here.

LOL! The surety of a defeated argument is when the whiny bitch in you and the name calling comes out.

 

[Montalban]

When all else fails lay out a ridiculous hypothetical

You are an expert at that, I'll give you that.

 

[Montalban]

Yeah, that you're a fucking dipshit.

Uh oh here comes another whiny bitch

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

Uh oh here comes another whiny bitch

"i freely admit that didn't know that Roy Halladay was an elite pitcher of his generation, but you should all take me and my opinions seriously"

Get the fuck out of here, clown.

 

[Yanks23242]

LOL! The surety of a defeated argument is when the whiny bitch in you and the name calling comes out.

Ignorant and hypocritical is the span of 20 words. Impressive. Nowhere in that post did I call you names (I’m about to) and if you think I did then you’re a fucking idiot.

 

[Yanks23242]

You are an expert at that, I'll give you that.

This is an act right? Or do you seriously not know what hypothetical means? I’ll lay off if you’re legitimately brain damaged.

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

Ignorant and hypocritical is the span of 20 words. Impressive. Nowhere in that post did I call you names (I’m about to) and if you think I did then you’re a fucking idiot.

The irony of him saying some one has lost an argument when they resort to name calling -- in the same post that he called you a bitch -- was not lost on me.

 

[Montalban]

"i freely admit that didn't know that Roy Halladay was an elite pitcher of his generation, but you should all take me and my opinions seriously"

Get the fuck out of here, clown.

Are getting angwy? Do we need a nap or a timeout? Mussina did not deserve to get in, nor did Halladay.

 

[Montalban]

This is an act right? Or do you seriously not know what hypothetical means? I’ll lay off if you’re legitimately brain damaged.

Uh oh, more name calling. You mad or something?

 

[broncosmitty]

Are getting angwy? Do we need a nap or a timeout? Mussina did not deserve to get in, nor did Halladay.

Halladay wouldn't be in right now if he was breathing.



But I think he would've got in before Schilling either way.

 

[StanMarsh51]

Someone convinced me a while back that Halladay was one of the elite guys of his era.

You couldn't tell that a guy who finished top 5 in Cy voting 7x (including 4x finishing 1st or 2nd) was one of the elite guys of his generation?

Additionally, Halladay:
-finished top 3 in ERA 5x
-won 20 games 3x and had another 2 seasons of 19 wins
-led the league in innings 4x
-finished top 3 in ERA 5x
-finished 1st or 2nd in WHIP 5x
-led the league in complete games 7x


How was that not obvious?

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

Are getting angwy? Do we need a nap or a timeout? Mussina did not deserve to get in, nor did Halladay.

Yes. Fucktards on the internet get me so mad. My hands are shaking and my face is red. Whatever you do, don't say more retarded shit or I'm gonna blow my top.

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

Halladay wouldn't be in right now if he was breathing.



But I think he would've got in before Schilling either way.

I tend to agree with that.

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

You couldn't tell that a guy who finished top 5 in Cy voting 7x (including 4x finishing 1st or 2nd) was one of the elite guys of his generation?

Additionally, Halladay:
-finished top 3 in ERA 5x
-won 20 games 3x and had another 2 seasons of 19 wins
-led the league in innings 4x
-finished top 3 in ERA 5x
-finished 1st or 2nd in WHIP 5x
-led the league in complete games 7x


How was that not obvious?

@Montalban missed it because he was fishing.

Spoiler