Living in the DC market it is amusing how they regard Harper. One radio guy who apparently is unfamiliar with the name Mike Trout called him the face of baseball. LOL. With that said and back to the OP's thoughts he is a very good, at times great, player. He has already had two season with an OPS above 1 and he's working on a third. So "just one good year" really does not apply IMO. But yeah he is overrated and hurt too much to be worth the price he will cost.