Bloody Brian Burke
#1 CFL Fan!
You're right in how it'll play out, most likely.I agree with you, but I think some type of compromise is going to be the only way out of it. The C is never going to agree to give up all claim to those players. This wouldn't be a perfect solution, but some form of compromise would be better for all parties than the status quo.
What I would like to see is a massive lawsuit brought against the CHL given that these policies are literally taking money from the pockets of young people given that a) They'd be paid a living wage in the AHL/NHL, and b) the CHL is almost at NCAA levels of compensation as it is, and how that isn't illegal in itself is inexplicable.
Fact is, if the CHL says they need to keep the older players because they stand to lose revenue, those same players should be getting a much larger slice of that revenue. This could become a very slippery slope.