Coach of the Year Thread

[NEPatsfan]

To me that is the best measuring stick. When you have a team that goes 4-12 loses their starting QB in preseason, starts a rookie QB and RB and has that huge turnaround. he deserves it or Quinn. Please don't tell me you have Belichick in the mix?

It's flawed, so next here he won't qualify simply because he had a good year this year?

 

[sonnyblack65]

It's flawed, so next here he won't qualify simply because he had a good year this year?

I could coach the Pats to a good record with Brady, that offense, that defense Mc Daniels as OC and Patricia as DC

 

[jarntt]

Well deserved award for Garrett. Was it even close?

 

[jarntt]

It's flawed, so next here he won't qualify simply because he had a good year this year?

Of course not, but tougher to win. You guys will argue anything. It's very hard to compare coaches of different teams and see who did best. So you have to look at how they did versus how they were expected to do as part of it. Not all, but part

 

[NEPatsfan]

I could coach the Pats to a good record with Brady, that offense, that defense Mc Daniels as OC and Patricia as DC

I'm not ever referring to the Patriots.

 

[Carnzo]

Actually a very good choice.
No complaints from me.

 

[NEPatsfan]

Of course not, but tougher to win. you guys will argue anything.

No we wouldn't.

 

[Clayton]

Not much of a complaint but usually when a team wins too many awards then somebody is overrated or else the team would go undefeated. I think in context, though, having 2 OROYs isnt the same as having 2 MVP candidates so there is a good chance that everyone is being properly rated even if Garrett did not have a very good track record going into the season.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Of course not, but tougher to win. You guys will argue anything. It's very hard to compare coaches of different teams and see who did best. So you have to look at how they did versus how they were expected to do as part of it. Not all, but part

Who's you guys?

 

[Inimical]

Jack del rio or KC coach.

 

[jarntt]

Who's you guys?

Anyone whose username starts with "N" and ends with "Patsfan"

 

[packerzrule]

my homeboy choice was for McCarthy

 

[PDay8810]

my homeboy choice was for McCarthy

only because that 56 yarder was good.

poor ass coaches call in that situation if he misses

oh well.....

 

[cdumler7]

Good choice for the Coach of the Year. I didn't think it was that tough of a choice this season compared to some in the past. He met pretty much every criteria and beyond of what we usually see in a coach who wins this award.

 

[packerzrule]

only because that 56 yarder was good.

poor ass coaches call in that situation if he misses

oh well.....

more on how they finished the season and not during the playoffs

I will admit, he made some gutsy\stupid calls in both post season games which is very unlike his conservative self

 

[Great Dayne]

I'd give it to Rodgers, Mcmuffin is just holding this team back while Rodgers has to call his own plays at the line. Mcmuffin wouldn't be a starting coach in the NFL if it wasn't for having Rodgers and Favre save his fat ass.

 

[PDay8810]

more on how they finished the season and not during the playoffs

I will admit, he made some gutsy\stupid calls in both post season games which is very unlike his conservative self

just saying and I don't have a problem with playing to win.

tough ass call this week for me
great dayne or rmilia1

that sucks

 

[NEhomer]

I'm ok with Garrett but I also think it should include the entire season and voting should be after it's completed.

 

[klbynes500]

Quinn.

 

[Dolemite censored]

Cowboys' Jason Garrett named Coach of the Year by Pro Football Writers Association | SportsDay

I agree that Garrett is COY. It was either Garrett, or Dan Quinn or Adam Gase. Garrett got the best results and bigger turnaround.