Carson Palmer is the 4th QB with 100 TD passes for 2 teams

[Rock Strongo]

Testaverde, Palmer and Collins wouldn't get my vote. Rivers and Bledsoe likely get a yes, but both could have helped their cause by winning a SB.

Everyone else on that list is an easy yes except for the guy at #17. Who is Joe Montana? I've heard of Joe Cool, Joe Dirt and Joe Momma, but not him

i have always said bledsoe gets in someday. hes arguably one of the more successful #1 picks in history.

 

[Rex Racer]

It's a mix of watered down and too exclusive to me. Guys like Schilling and Mussina should be in, guys like Lou Brock and Jim Rice should not.

Rice has that "shooting Star" thing going on as well. You might be a younger fella, but I watched Rice absolutely terrorize American League pitching for close to a dozen years before age and his eyesight started becoming an issue.

 

[tducey]

Palmer's a very good QB, gets a little under appreciated, but over the past 10-15 years he's been a top 10-15 NFL QB.

 

[Rex Racer]

i have always said bledsoe gets in someday. hes arguably one of the more successful #1 picks in history.

Someday, I think so too.

 

[soxfan1468927]

Rice has that "shooting Star" thing going on as well. You might be a younger fella, but I watched Rice absolutely terrorize American League pitching for close to a dozen years before age and his eyesight started becoming an issue.

Yeah the fear factor. I didn't see Rice play. I can only look at numbers and highlights. The people who did watch him play took 15 years to vote him in and he still barely got in.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Yeah the fear factor. I didn't see Rice play. I can only look at numbers and highlights. The people who did watch him play took 15 years to vote him in and he still barely got in.

Black Phil Rizzuto

 

[soxfan1468927]

Black Phil Rizzuto

Difference being that at least Rice was voted in by the BBWAA. Rizzuto never got over 40% and got in once his buddies got on the Veteran's Committee.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Difference being that at least Rice was voted in by the BBWAA. Rizzuto never got over 40% and got in once his buddies got on the Veteran's Committee.

Rex is a big Jeter fan

 

[soxfan1468927]

Rex is a big Jeter fan

They won't put a Yankee in the HOF right?

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

They won't put a Yankee in the HOF right?

Some things are too obvious before you lose your vote

 

[soxfan1468927]

Some things are too obvious before you lose your vote

We are 1.5 years away from someone explaining why they didn't vote for Mariano Rivera. So glad all ballots are public now.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

We are 1.5 years away from someone explaining why they didn't vote for Mariano Rivera. So glad all ballots are public now.

Itll happen...No doubt about it

And it will be defended with the "Relief pitcher" argument

 

[Rex Racer]

Yeah the fear factor. I didn't see Rice play. I can only look at numbers and highlights. The people who did watch him play took 15 years to vote him in and he still barely got in.

He hated talking to reporters, treated them with the disdain that they deserve and they never forgot about it.

 

[Rex Racer]

Rex is a big Jeter fan

Yeah, nothing I like more than a rag armed, slap hitting SS that is a mediocre defender

 

[Rock Strongo]

Yeah the fear factor. I didn't see Rice play. I can only look at numbers and highlights. The people who did watch him play took 15 years to vote him in and he still barely got in.

his splits were...bad...and hes more legend than he was "the most feared hitter in baseball". tough guy to get out, at fenway, for sure.

.920 OPS at home

.798 on the road

one of the bigger disparities in the HOF. its amazing...only a 7 game difference between home and road...yet he had 153 more HR at fenway than the road....in 7 games difference.

 

[Sir Robin Of Camelot]

my case for vinny:

12th all time in yards (46,233)
15th in TD passes (275)
4th all time in passes intercepted (not a good stat, but of the top 5 in this category, 3 are in (favre, blanda, tarkenton)
10th all time in pass attempts
13th in completions
10th all time in 4th quarter comebacks (tied with big ben, and 11 fewer than brady)

And has a tribute song.

SHOW SONGS « BaD Radio | Bob and Dan | Sports Radio 1310 The Ticket

 

[megalodon30]

What happened to Dak Prescott? Last week he looked like hot poopy. It's like he's still a good QB or something. 1/3rd of his career INTs are against the No Fly Zone.

Go Broncos!

 

[Rock Strongo]

What happened to Dak Prescott? Last week he looked like hot poopy. It's like he's still a good QB or something. 1/3rd of his career INTs are against the No Fly Zone.

Go Broncos!

you lost to something called a tyrod.

 

[megalodon30]

you lost to something called a tyrod.

One of the hazards of starting a 7th round pick at QB.

 

[soxfan1468927]

One of the hazards of starting a 7th round pick at QB.

You should try a 6th round pick, it works a lot better