Hank Kingsley
Undefeated
No Russ in top 5. Opinion discarded.
So who do you kick out?
I have him best of the rest.
I might agree to Ryan but this year would weigh somewhat against that.
No Russ in top 5. Opinion discarded.
Oh, ok so maybe like 12 or 13? It's really hard to compare all the qbs at any given time because they are in different systems and at different stages in their career. But for a guy who has been in the league for 7 years Cam Newton has accomplished a lot.No. He's in a group after my top 11. I had him top 10 but can't see how anyone has him top 10. Not based on right now anyway . I already posted my thoughts. Page 1 I think
Big Ben for sure.So who do you kick out?
I have him best of the rest.
I might agree to Ryan but this year would weigh somewhat against that.
Big Ben for sure.
Brees or Ryan arguments can be made
Yeah I'd say 13-15 for me but id have no issue at 12Oh, ok so maybe like 12 or 13? It's really hard to compare all the qbs at any given time because they are in different systems and at different stages in their career. But for a guy who has been in the league for 7 years Cam Newton has accomplished a lot.
Have you seen ben play this year? He hasn't looked top 10 at timesReally eh?
I'd almost wish he wins another SB to prove you so very wrong.
Have you seen ben play this year? He hasn't looked top 10 at times
vote and discuss
No. He's in a group after my top 11. I had him top 10 but can't see how anyone has him top 10. Not based on right now anyway . I already posted my thoughts. Page 1 I think
looks like cams a top 15 QB...or...middle of the pack.
thank you all.
My top 10 (that I would take over Cam)
Brady, Brees, Ben, Rodgers, Wilson, Ryan, Luck, Stafford, Cousins, Wentz, Prescott, Goff...sorry I said 10, but that's 12 I would take over Cam.
Wow
Brees, Ben, Rodgers, Wilson, Wentz, Brady
Than I think a lot of different arguments can be made
Ryans' one sensational season id put right next to Cams one, and call the rest a wash
Cousins I cant slot ahead of him just yet, but think that could change, need more convinicng
Dak definitely not for me, thought he was greatly exposed without Zeke
Luck Yes only if he could prove health for 16 next season
Goff on his way
Stafford should be a Yes, just cant get past his in-ability to win an important game
There's always something to his outfit emsemble.....the 3/4 length pants make me laugh most. I thought only girls wore those.I actually don't mind the bottom pic save the awful hat
Ryan no question...he's better at the position, especially the way the game is played today.
Dak doesn't have the talent that Cam does, but he can make all the throws, and a better leader...all things being equal I think I'd get just as far with Dak.
Luck, yep...health is the only caveat.
Stafford to me is more of a no brainer...I agree on the record, but imo that's a bigger indictment on the FO.
Goff...yeah premature on this one, but I like his demeanor, more accurate than Cam, I think he's only going to get better.
I think you can say Cam is a top 10 right now, and I emphasize right now, but he's slipping imo...that's why he slides don't my list.
People always forget Rivers. In no world is Cam a better QB than RiversRyan no question...he's better at the position, especially the way the game is played today.
Dak doesn't have the talent that Cam does, but he can make all the throws, and a better leader...all things being equal I think I'd get just as far with Dak.
Luck, yep...health is the only caveat.
Stafford to me is more of a no brainer...I agree on the record, but imo that's a bigger indictment on the FO.
Goff...yeah premature on this one, but I like his demeanor, more accurate than Cam, I think he's only going to get better.
I think you can say Cam is a top 10 right now, and I emphasize right now, but he's slipping imo...that's why he slides don't my list.
People always forget Rivers. In no world is Cam a better QB than Rivers
I don't mind them with the suit . Never been a big bow tie guy either
Didn't he miss his first 15 passes in week 17?
Pretty close to it IIRC.
Eh. Cam is 3-4 in the playoffs. Rivers is 4-5. Neither is a playoff dynamoDepends how many notches you knock a guy down for being one of the worst big game QB's of our time
Ive always seen Rivers as a great fantasy QB, one of the last guys I want in a big game