POLL Cam Newton is...

[Cyder]

MVP, been to a Super Bowl.


Nobody but seven guys have any logical reason to be above him imo.

Unless people want to go plugging Eli and Flaco ahead of him, which they shouldn't be doing.

I put top 10 but that was going on just this year. If we're talking career I may vote differently. I can see putting these guys easily ahead of him

Big Ben
Brady
Brees
Wilson
Rodgers (But if we're going just this year should he count?)

But then there's guys who depending on the year could have preformed better. Do we count Wentz after only 2 years, he was having a great year when he got knocked out. Alex Smith had a better year than Cam this year but isn't better over his career despite a ridiculous won/loss record.

 

[controlvoice]

He's got a lot of potential.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Based on 2017...

Top Tier:
1. Brady
2. Roethlisberger
3. Rodgers... Obviously incomplete season, but cannot put him outside of top 3.
4. Brees
5. Wilson

Solid:
6. Wentz
7. Stafford
8. Ryan
9. Smith
10. Rivers
11. Keenum

Outside of that its a crapshoot.

Incomplete... need to see more:
Watson
Luck
Garrapolo
Trubisky
Tannehill

Good enough:
Cousins
Carr
Prescott
Winston
Newton
Flacco
Dalton
Mariota
Taylor

Placeholder?:
McCown
Bortles
Kizer
Broncos QB carousel

Retirement calling:
Palmer
Manning