Jonas_steven
Active Member
I have said that I believe the offseason will be a complete failure if the D'backs do not end up with a proven ace somehow. Now that more time has gone by, I still feel the same way, but I also think there is something else crucial that needs to happen. The D'backs absolutely have to get rid of Cahill. There is no way around it. Even if you have to eat his contract, he must be off the team before the season starts. I just cannot stand to even look at him pitching at this point.
I could list all the reasons and stats why I want Cahill off the team but I am not going to. I will just say I truly hope that he is no longer on the D'backs when the season starts. In my opinion, he brings the entire pitching staff down.
If they end up moving anyone, it will be McCarthy. Cahill has some value, as he is still somewhat young, but that ballooning contract is bad. He looked decent to start the season and then tapered off before the injuries. He actually had a nice finish to the end of the season which is ultimately why I would keep him over McCarthy. Mccrapy's contract and poor performance have made him public enemy number one in the rotation. If he had not played so bad last season, it would have likely been him traded over Kennedy. I suspect we will have to eat at least half his contract but that is a small price to pay to avoid having him on the books past next season.