2025 NFL Draft: The Quarterback Class

[dtgold88]

I think Kyle McCord might go rd2-rd3 so he doesn't fit the undrafted QB part but I think someone will kick the tires on him even though his name isnt showing up here.

Dillon Gabriel is also an older QB with a really capped ceiling but maybe could walk into the NFL as the 25th best QB.

will say he looked amazing against OSU in first game against us. Not so much in CFP. For sure seems like a guy if given time can play really well....though guessing this is true of many top QBs.

 

[Clayton]

Interesting though guessing big boards don't really take into account how important QBs are to QB needy teams. Did he have Daniels top 2-3 last year?

I think if we saw real draf boards they would be wildly different from each other.

His grade on Sanders is similar to Bo Nix's grade last year. Lower than Daniels.

My gut tells me Sanders is likely top 4 in the draft. Patriots would trade down if he gets to 4, I'd imagine. I think the Browns might take him, too, but that would be fairly divisive.

 

[Xeliou66]

As of right now I think Sanders won’t go past the #6 pick, I think the Raiders will take him if he’s available at 6, I think Cam Ward will go to the Titans at #1 and then the Browns or Giants might draft Sanders but they could pass, Pats and Jags obviously don’t need a QB but they might trade down and another team might jump up to take Sanders. It will be a very interesting draft for sure.
I will be very surprised if any other QB besides Ward and Sanders are selected in the first round.

 

[Clayton]

I will be very surprised if any other QB besides Ward and Sanders are selected in the first round.

If I had to guess, Milroe will go rd3 and Shough will go rd4. I'd imagine its going to be difficult for a team to go QB in rd1-3 because it means theyre losing a starter on defense for a project.

 

[Xeliou66]

If I had to guess, Milroe will go rd3 and Shough will go rd4. I'd imagine its going to be difficult for a team to go QB in rd1-3 because it means theyre losing a starter on defense for a project.

I wouldn’t touch Milroe, he looks like a weaker version of Anthony Richardson and Richardson sucks bad enough. Where do you think Jaxson Dart will go? I bet he goes higher than Milroe, he certainly should, he was a better college QB and better passer.

 

[Clayton]

I wouldn’t touch Milroe, he looks like a weaker version of Anthony Richardson and Richardson sucks bad enough. Where do you think Jaxson Dart will go? I bet he goes higher than Milroe, he certainly should, he was a better college QB and better passer.

Its tough because once teams go 'I dont think this guy is playing QB for us next year' then I think it becomes about traits and not college tape. I also don't think teams will approach Milroe as 'well Richardson didn't work so he won't' and instead they'll be 'hey, 30% chance we get Jalen Hurts'

I wouldn't be shocked if the run of QBs was rd5 or rd6. Is that an insult to Dart and Howard? Yes. But historically mid rounds QB generally dont make it

 

[Xeliou66]

Its tough because once teams go 'I dont think this guy is playing QB for us next year' then I think it becomes about traits and not college tape. I also don't think teams will approach Milroe as 'well Richardson didn't work so he won't' and instead they'll be 'hey, 30% chance we get Jalen Hurts'

I wouldn't be shocked if the run of QBs was rd5 or rd6. Is that an insult to Dart and Howard? Yes. But historically mid rounds QB generally dont make it

Interesting. I just find it absurd that Milroe would go ahead of Dart, but he probably will, Milroe just wasn’t a very good college QB though, but his athleticism and running ability will get some team to take a chance on him. It’s why Richardson was picked at 4 overall by the Colts, and I’m not shocked at all that he’s been dismal, he was a mediocre college QB, there’s no way he was going to be a good NFL QB, the Colts were just so desperate for a QB that they selected him but I think they made a huge mistake, especially since Jalen Carter was available and he’s a beast on the D-Line, they really screwed up by passing on him in favor of Richardson.
I would take Dart and even Will Howard over Milroe, Milroe just isn’t good IMO.

 

[PDay8810]

Will Howard is Sam Darnold at USC in my sofa opinion. Hard pass for me.

 

[dtgold88]

His grade on Sanders is similar to Bo Nix's grade last year. Lower than Daniels.

My gut tells me Sanders is likely top 4 in the draft. Patriots would trade down if he gets to 4, I'd imagine. I think the Browns might take him, too, but that would be fairly divisive.

Guessing many fan bases are like this but lately no matter what the Browns do it's divisive. Hell, even the Myles situation.

I 100% agree IF taken would for sure start out with fans on opposite side.....winning could change that (though some who complain no matter what).

 

[dtgold88]

Its tough because once teams go 'I dont think this guy is playing QB for us next year' then I think it becomes about traits and not college tape. I also don't think teams will approach Milroe as 'well Richardson didn't work so he won't' and instead they'll be 'hey, 30% chance we get Jalen Hurts'

I wouldn't be shocked if the run of QBs was rd5 or rd6. Is that an insult to Dart and Howard? Yes. But historically mid rounds QB generally dont make it

agree with all of this.....I'd even say once you get past the alleged top guys the vast majority of QBs will fail let alone midround guys. Will always here the "what about Hurts, Wilson or Brady) but there are, what, 30 or even 50 for every 1 of them?

 

[Clayton]

agree with all of this.....I'd even say once you get past the alleged top guys the vast majority of QBs will fail let alone midround guys. Will always here the "what about Hurts, Wilson or Brady) but there are, what, 30 or even 50 for every 1 of them?

I think this is a deep draft, too, so the opportunity cost of taking a QB who isn't a sure thing is higher.