1990 - 2014 NFL Draft Chat

[UK Cowboy]

UK

SQB Brett Favre
BQB Mark Brunell
SRB Ladanian Tomlinson
BRB Marshawn Lynch
SWR Terrell Owens
SWR Julio Jones
BWR TY Hilton
TE Shannon Sharpe
OT Larry Allen
OG Zach Martin
C Matt Burk
OG Jahri Evans
OT Chris Samuels

DE Cameron Wake
DT Ndamakong Suh
DT Star Lotulelei
DE Dwight Freeney
OLB Derrick Brooks
MLB Levin Kirkland
OLB Lance Briggs
SCB Chris McAlister
SCB Leodis McKelvin
NCB Antrel Rolle
SS Bob Sanders
FS Darren Sharper

 

[broncosmitty]

Shit, it made so much sense to me

If it works for everybody, it works for me.

Im going to do as many teams as I can tonight. Don't think I'll be able to put time into it in the morning.

But I'll adjust scores if add/drops are made.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I trying to figure out what is considered a 10. For only 15 years there could be a bunch of ten's. I probably won't go lower than 5

 

[Nosferatu]

I trying to figure out what is considered a 10. For only 15 years there could be a bunch of ten's. I probably won't go lower than 5

PLEASE NOTICE THIS IS THE SCORING WE ARE USING...

Starting QB = 20 Backup = 5
Starting RB = 10 Backup = 5
Starting WR = 15 3rd Receiver = 10
Starting TE = 10
Starting O-Line = 10 Each
OFFENSE TOTAL = 140

Starting D-Line = 10 Each
Starting LB's = 10 Each
Starting CB's = 15 Nickel = 10
Starting SS/FS = 15 Each
DEFENSE TOTAL = 140

 

[Nosferatu]

If it works for everybody, it works for me.

Im going to do as many teams as I can tonight. Don't think I'll be able to put time into it in the morning.

But I'll adjust scores if add/drops are made.

It seems as though the drop and pick ups are done, that's why I waited until just a few minutes ago to do mine.

I will probably do most of my ranking tonight and finish it up when I get to work.

I again hope everyone can get me their rankings by Noon EST tomorrow.

 

[Shanemansj13]

PLEASE NOTICE THIS IS THE SCORING WE ARE USING...

Starting QB = 20 Backup = 5
Starting RB = 10 Backup = 5
Starting WR = 15 3rd Receiver = 10
Starting TE = 10
Starting O-Line = 10 Each
OFFENSE TOTAL = 140

Starting D-Line = 10 Each
Starting LB's = 10 Each
Starting CB's = 15 Nickel = 10
Starting SS/FS = 15 Each
DEFENSE TOTAL = 140

Yes, or 20's or 15's. I mean the best of the best

 

[Nosferatu]

Congrats on 27K Shane

 

[Pack 500]

I trying to figure out what is considered a 10. For only 15 years there could be a bunch of ten's. I probably won't go lower than 5

That's my thing too. There should be a scale. Like I said before when I think of a one i think of Ryan Leaf. Obviously there are no players like that in here

 

[broncosmitty]

Two down, six to go. (Well, five n a half. It was time to make a drink.)

I gave out one 2 out of five on a backup. And I doubt any other player in this mock gets a 2.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Congrats on 27K Shane

Ohh shit I forgot!

Thanks

 

[wlk3]

Congrats Shane!

 

[broncosmitty]

Half way there!

 

[wlk3]

Team WLK

Offense

QB - Drew Brees - 2001
BU - EJ Manuel - 2013
FB - Sam Gash - 1992
RB - Emmitt Smith - 1990
WR - Donald Driver - 1999
WR - Demaryius Thomas - 2010
3rd - Sammy Watkins - 2014
TE - Heath Miller - 2005
LT - Orlando Pace - 1997
LG - Alan Faneca - 1998
C - Matt Unger - 2009
RG - Marshal Yanda - 2007
RT - Ryan Clady - 2008

Defense

DE - John Abraham - 2000
DT - Vince Wilfork - 2004
DT - Warren Sapp - 1995
DE - Elvis Dumervil - 2006
OLB - Jason Gildon - 1994
MLB - Ray Lewis - 1996
OLB - Jessie Armstead - 1993
CB - Aeneas Williams - 1991
CB - Nnamdi Asomugha - 2003
NB - Patrick Peterson - 2011
FS - Tashaun Gibson - 2012
SS - Roy Williams - 2002

 

[wlk3]

I did end up doing three drops & pickups after all since WLK dropped half his team.


Drop Jeremy Shockey TE 2002 Pickup Brett Keisel DE 2002


Drop Asante Samuel CB 2003 Pickup Jason Witten TE 2003


Drop Vance Walker DE 2009 Pickup Vontae Davis CB 2009

Those are nice moves Nos... HATED moving Witten but somebody has 2 tall ass receiver and a fast one on the bench... Felt I lost talent in TE and backup QB but got better everywhere else though so had to do it... It all started with Warford, DAMN YOU UK!!!

 

[blstoker]

I trying to figure out what is considered a 10. For only 15 years there could be a bunch of ten's. I probably won't go lower than 5

I'm just gonna rate each player at those positions and then evenly distribute the points across where they landed. So, the #1 QB would be a 20, the #2 would be an 18 and so forth.

 

[broncosmitty]

Those are nice moves Nos... HATED moving Witten but somebody has 2 tall ass receiver and a fast one on the bench... Felt I lost talent in TE and backup QB but got better everywhere else though so had to do it... It all started with Warford, DAMN YOU UK!!!

Im jus gonna lay it out there.....

The 2, it was EJ Manuel. Hahahaha.

Saved you points by having him and dumping Warford though. I think I would've given Big Lar a 5 or a 6. He was part of an absolute shit line this year. And may not have been the best member of it. (Small sample size for the big fella. Going off just last year he's a solid 8)

 

[blstoker]

Just so everyone knows how my line up will look for the rankings:

SQB Russell Wilson
BQB Donovan McNabb
SHB Curtis Martin
BHB Le'Veon Bell
WR Larry Fitzgerald
WR Roddy White
SWR Odell Beckham
OT Walter Jones
OG Steve Hutchinson
C Kevin Mawae
OG Andre Gurode
OT Joe Thomas

DE J.J. Watt
DT Cortez Kennedy
DT Kevin Williams
DE Kabeer Gbaja-Biamila
OLB Mo Lewis
MLB Zach Thomas
OLB DeAndre Levy
CB Aqib Talib
CB Terrell Buckley
NB Ray Buchanon
FS Earl Thomas
SS Tony Parrish

 

[broncosmitty]

I'm just gonna rate each player at those positions and then evenly distribute the points across where they landed. So, the #1 QB would be a 20, the #2 would be an 18 and so forth.

Only position Im doing that with is QB and WR.(several 19's&18's at QB and 14'd at WR) Nobody else is the clear cut best, at any position, to me.(Tony Gonzalez is the best. But TE is only 10 points, Im not docking the next group a full point because of that.) I've tossed out a bunch of 10's on the OLine, DLine and LBs so far.

 

[wlk3]

Im jus gonna lay it out there.....

The 2, it was EJ Manuel. Hahahaha.

Saved you points by having him and dumping Warford though. I think I would've given Big Lar a 5 or a 6. He was part of an absolute shit line this year. And may not have been the best member of it. (Small sample size for the big fella. Going off just last year he's a solid 8)

First I'll say this is hard as hell... I've only done 1 so far and it's not sitting well... At first I was going, best in draft, then best stats... It's kind of hard to really gauge fairly when there isn't a true measuring stick...

Second, I knew who you gave the 2 to when I saw it lol... But since he wasn't going to see the field I figure that's the best place to put a bum if you gotta have 1... I mean having maybe a top 3 back up QB and a average at best G who's strength is pass pro when I'm going for a running team made it easy to do...

Third this is going to take forever!!!

 

[broncosmitty]

Im so close I can taste it!

(It tastes like Bacardi.)