1990 - 2014 NFL Draft Chat

[wlk3]

QB, Backs and Ends, Line. DLine, Linebakers, Dbacks. 1-10 scale.

My FB is the first RB to be selected to the probowl without having 1 carry... Emmit Smith told me to tell you guys that...

 

[UK Cowboy]

I saw Shane add/dropped 3, do we get 2 or 3? I have no idea who's turn it is, so I'm gonna PM mine to Nos to post when it's my turn

 

[UK Cowboy]

QB, Backs and Ends, Line. DLine, Linebakers, Dbacks. 1-10 scale.

And bench....or are we grading bench with starters?

 

[wlk3]

I saw Shane add/dropped 3, do we get 2 or 3? I have no idea who's turn it is, so I'm gonna PM mine to Nos to post when it's my turn

If I'm not mistaken Nos said you can add / drop what you want as long as it fits the requirements (years / positions) when you're done so I think he's okay...

 

[Shanemansj13]

I give Shane a 1 for effort

 

[Shanemansj13]

QB 1-10
RB 1-10
WR's 1-10
TE 1-10
O-Line 1-10
D-Line 1-10
LB's 1-10
CB's 1-10
SS/FS 1-10
Bench 1-10

Separate G's and T's. DE's and DT's

 

[UK Cowboy]

QB 1-10
RB 1-10
WR's 1-10
TE 1-10
O-Line 1-10
D-Line 1-10
LB's 1-10
CB's 1-10
SS/FS 1-10
Bench 1-10

I like this

 

[wlk3]

I like this

Only question is... People are talking about starting a Nickel... Is that the starting D...? I'm starting a 2 back set most are starting 3 WR... Ritz drafted a 3-4, deferent number of players...

 

[Nosferatu]

QB 1-10
RB 1-10
WR's 1-10
TE 1-10
O-Line 1-10
D-Line 1-10
LB's 1-10
CB's 1-10
SS/FS 1-10
Bench 1-10

Nope, don't like that. 1 TE gets as many points as 3 WR's? Bench consists of 2 or 3 players which is fair but should they get the same points as your starters? I don't think we should use bench those 3 players should just fall into whatever position they are. I also think TE should be included in WR's...

 

[Nosferatu]

Maybe what works is giving different point value to each position.

 

[Ritzarmy]

Maybe what works is giving different point value to each position.

Maybe but you can't do that now after a draft because we may have picked deferently if we new a QB gets more points then a FS. (Just a example)

 

[blstoker]

Shane - Olin Kruetz is 1998 not 2008....you can't take him where you have him.

 

[Nosferatu]

Maybe breaking down a little more


1 - 10 Starting QB 1 - 5 Backup QB
1 - 10 Starting RB 1 - 5 Backup RB
1 - 7 for each WR
1 - 10 TE
1 - 15 O-Line
1 - 15 D-Line
1 - 15 LB's
1 - 15 Secondary 1- 5 Nickel Back


Something like this, maybe not this exactly but something like it...

 

[Ritzarmy]

Nope, don't like that. 1 TE gets as many points as 3 WR's? Bench consists of 2 or 3 players which is fair but should they get the same points as your starters? I don't think we should use bench those 3 players should just fall into whatever position they are. I also think TE should be included in WR's...

Nope I don't like including TE with the WR's I feel they should be separated. What's wrong with saying Team A has a outstanding WR core 10pts, Team A has good TE 7pts when it's all added together it shows who has the best players. IMO. Really wish we stop drafting before we sort out these rules.

 

[Nosferatu]

Add/drops

Add - RT Ju'Waun James - 2014
C Olin Kreutz - 2008
WR Chad "OchoCinco" Johnson - 2006

Drop - C Jack Mewhort - 2014
RT Jake Long - 2008
WR Brandon Marshall - 2006




WTF is this? lolzzz


Wrong years on Kreutz and Chad Johnson

 

[wlk3]

Maybe what works is giving different point value to each position.

I think putting all together makes most fair because everybody doesn't have the same schemes... Meaning

QB - Both
RB - Both
WR - All
Oline - All
Dline - All
LBs - All
DBs - All

Question is should Safties be lumped in with Corners and should the TE go with Backs or Recivers... I'd say receiver... So Ritz would get judged for 3 Dline but 4 Backers, but that's just the breaks...

 

[Nosferatu]

Nope I don't like including TE with the WR's I feel they should be separated. What's wrong with saying Team A has a outstanding WR core 10pts, Team A has good TE 7pts when it's all added together it shows who has the best players. IMO. Really wish we stop drafting before we sort out these rules.

I gave an example above and didn't include TE with WR. You cant give a TE 7 and WR's 10. IMO that's saying a good tight end is worth more than double a good WR.

Yeah, well we don't think of these things until after we have drafted, remember we aren't living and dying with these drafts as long as we continue to put things together eventually we will have a perfect system.

 

[Nosferatu]

I posted UK's drops and pickups...

 

[UK Cowboy]

I think putting all together makes most fair because everybody doesn't have the same schemes... Meaning

QB - Both
RB - Both
WR - All
Oline - All
Dline - All
LBs - All
DBs - All

Question is should Safties be lumped in with Corners and should the TE go with Backs or Recivers... I'd say receiver... So Ritz would get judged for 3 Dline but 4 Backers, but that's just the breaks...

If we are gonna do it, lets do it, Starting QB, RB, WR, TE, OL, DL, LB, CB, S and bench. It might take an extra 10 minutes, but that's fine. Just my opinion

 

[wlk3]

Add/drops

Add - RT Ju'Waun James - 2014
C Olin Kreutz - 2008
WR Chad "OchoCinco" Johnson - 2006

Drop - C Jack Mewhort - 2014
RT Jake Long - 2008
WR Brandon Marshall - 2006




WTF is this? lolzzz


Wrong years on Kreutz and Chad Johnson

Are you saying that isn't cool...? cause when I saw that I had an idea...

Let me know cause I'm up next I think...