Andre Johnson: Andrew Luck is NFL's best QB

[HammerDown]

No defense. No run game.

3 straight playoff appearances.

Aaron Rodgers and Peyton Manning are the only other two in the discussion but I think it's time to anoint Luck as the best in the game.

 

[The Derski]

HA HA HA

Rodgers is a surgeon who throws the tightest spiral on the planet. No one can touch him. Luck is top 5.

 

[GenJac]

36 wins in 3 years is amazing. I'd like to see Rodgers-Luck in Super Bowl 50. It'd be what the NFL deserves. A SHOOT OUT.

 

[mick7-1961]

 

[flyerhawk]

I think Luck is a great QB. Probably Top 5 at this point. But he's not the best.

Record isn't the only indicator of greatness. He's won 36 games while playing in the weakest division in football. I think he has only lost 2 divisional games in those 3 years.

Rodgers is still the top dog.

Of course Andre Johnson is going to say he is the best. What else is going to say?

 

[TheRangerDude]

Everyone knows that title belongs to Tony Romo...

But seriously, I still would say Rodgers is the best. Luck is up there too but needs to cut down on the interceptions. Completion Percentage was 23rd in the NFL last year too, so you would like to see that come up too. I'm pretty certain both of those things are coming though.

 

[redseat]

I'm utterly shocked that a player on Luck's team would say something like this... Utterly shocked!

 

[Rock Strongo]

"my new QB is the best"

-every WR ever on a new team

 

[sonnyblack65]

HA HA HA

Rodgers is a surgeon who throws the tightest spiral on the planet. No one can touch him. Luck is top 5.

I agree you have Rodgers and Brady and then the rest, great td/int ratio and above .500 playoffs. Manning,Ben,Wilson,Flacco, Luck. Now Wilson and Luck are young the sky is the limit for these 2

 

[HammerDown]

I'm utterly shocked that a player on Luck's team would say something like this... Utterly shocked!

And I'm utterly shocked that this thread is filling up with indignant Pats fans. Utterly shocked!

 

[redseat]

And I'm utterly shocked that this thread is filling up with indignant Pats fans. Utterly shocked!

Love ya too Hammer!

I thought you didn't have time to respond... Though Thumper had you in trial court, LMAO

 

[redseat]

But yes, He is getting up there on the chart of "great qbs"

 

[FantasyBelowZero]

"my new QB is the best"

-every WR ever on a new team

This is so true. The media would have a cow if he said that he liked another QB more than Luck. Plus, that'd send bad messages to the fanbase.

 

[RP-29]

I'd like to see Rodgers-Luck in Super Bowl 50.

I endorse this comment. Both teams' defense and special teams need to pull their weight to get there though.

 

[Scooby-Doo]

I endorse this comment. Both teams' defense and special teams need to pull their weight to get there though.

Shocking.

If there is a Green Bay or Indy fan that does not endorse their team in the SB, please come forward.

 

[jarntt]

As of right now I put Luck at #2 behind Rodgers and if Manning is healthy (big if) I think he probably still is #2, but my top 3 are the same. I don't really think there is a 4th that is that close (again assuming a healthy Peyton otherwise he's not in the top group either). After this season I wouldn't be surprised if Luck surpasses Rodgers

 

[Rock Strongo]

As of right now I put Luck at #2 behind Rodgers and if Manning is healthy (big if) I think he probably still is #2, but my top 3 are the same. I don't really think there is a 4th that is that close (again assuming a healthy Peyton otherwise he's not in the top group either). After this season I wouldn't be surprised if Luck surpasses Rodgers

4109 yards
33 TD
9 picks

97.4 rating

"hes the 18th best QB in the AFC"

 

[tedman2012]

No defense. No run game.

3 straight playoff appearances.

Aaron Rodgers and Peyton Manning are the only other two in the discussion but I think it's time to anoint Luck as the best in the game.

manning had a better team around him than luck in his first 3 years . i do like rodgers

 

[ducky]

As of right now I put Luck at #2 behind Rodgers and if Manning is healthy (big if) I think he probably still is #2, but my top 3 are the same. I don't really think there is a 4th that is that close (again assuming a healthy Peyton otherwise he's not in the top group either). After this season I wouldn't be surprised if Luck surpasses Rodgers

I would.

People still don't realize how much better Rodgers is and has been than everyone else.

In the last 4 seasons Rodgers has thrown 139 TD's. In that same span he 25 INT's. And he has averaged about 8.5 ypa. (Don't look at QBR or QB rating.....those 3 are the most important stats).

Last year in Luck's best season he threw 40 TD's had 16 INT's and averaged 7.73 YPA. Those are great numbers but they still aren't even close to what Rodgers is doing.

Luck has been great. But he is still A LONG ways behind where Rodgers is and has been. For Luck to pass Rodgers, Rodgers would have to take a big step backwards and I don't see that happening.

 

[tedman2012]

Shocking.

If there is a Green Bay or Indy fan that does not endorse their team in the SB, please come forward.

it is hard to get excited since the pats fans says that the evil empire will put up 70 points on the colts at home .