Mebert
Not Mebert's Alt
Lions got two stars and two maulers on the O line plus some D players w nice upsides. No TE’s and no long snappers.
B++
Te and long snapper are the first 2 udfa they signed.
Lions got two stars and two maulers on the O line plus some D players w nice upsides. No TE’s and no long snappers.
B++
Ramsey*, Van Jefferson, Cam Akers, Terrell Lewis...yeah, thats a lot of talent.We did good, like usual
Seahawks B+.
I cannot give them an A although I loved all their picks with exception of the Stanford TE. But end of day they received very little trade down value and surrendering the extra 3rd while not addressing some depth at CB is a bit of an issue on my end.
I have ZERO fucking clue why we drafted a TE. You can't really let Dissly go (was on pace to be the best TE last year until the injury), Olsen we spent $8M on and basically sacrificed Clowney or the resigning of Quinton Jefferson, and are we going to give up on Hollister already? Even then that means cutting Willson and going in with four tight ends this year? Woof... I'm not sure we can carry that many but who knows.
End of day I loved the players we took elsewhere and I very much like Swain even in the 6th to fix issues with our anemic return game, but we just didn't get the trade value to give it a full A. If we could've gotten Brooks in the early 2nd (or even 31st/32nd before the Bengals picked) and Taylor with our 59th, I'd give them an A.
A B+ is generous considering they had two of the worst value picks in the draft. Filled needs just reached.
Brooks was rated 84 and taken at 27.
Taylor was rated 185 and taken at 48.
I give the grade Extremely happy!
Thank you Eagles for that BTW.Dallas- A. Thought they nailed every pick except for the fourth round. I wanted the Wisconsin C. Then they turned around and traded right back in and got him.
Dallas was an A+ draft all the way. The 3rd rounder was basically their only "eh okay" pick. Everything else was basically a landslide steal and they addressed major needs while also screwing over Philly in the first.
3rd round - Gallimore - DT Oklahoma
I loved this pick. He was projected mid 2 Nd
Now their 4rth round pick - Reggie Robinson - I scratched my head some. Some had him going in the 4rth. Some had him in the 6th
C
Picked a guy who could be a bust because of his knee. Traded up for a WR who likely would've been available at 31. No picks on Day 2. Drafted an OL who reportedly can't handle a bull rush. Drafted a WR on Day 3 who ran 4.72 in the 40 and only got a 29 inch vertical leap. Was he injured during those tests? LOL. That would be good athleticism if he were a middle aged guy.
They did pick up Trent Williams. Kinlaw does have very high potential and Aiyuk looks like he could the real deal at WR, so the Niners did okay overall.
Loved the first two picks.
Seahawks B+.
I cannot give them an A although I loved all their picks with exception of the Stanford TE. But end of day they received very little trade down value and surrendering the extra 3rd while not addressing some depth at CB is a bit of an issue on my end.
I have ZERO fucking clue why we drafted a TE. You can't really let Dissly go (was on pace to be the best TE last year until the injury), Olsen we spent $8M on and basically sacrificed Clowney or the resigning of Quinton Jefferson, and are we going to give up on Hollister already? Even then that means cutting Willson and going in with four tight ends this year? Woof... I'm not sure we can carry that many but who knows.
End of day I loved the players we took elsewhere and I very much like Swain even in the 6th to fix issues with our anemic return game, but we just didn't get the trade value to give it a full A. If we could've gotten Brooks in the early 2nd (or even 31st/32nd before the Bengals picked) and Taylor with our 59th, I'd give them an A.