Top 10 QBs in the NFL, today

[msgkings322]

Do I get extra credit?

320 × 180

 

[WizardHawk]

Why is it so hard for you goombahs to just list 10 QBs? Sheesh.

Because it's clear from your not so passive aggressive bullshit with Harold that you aren't really interested in any kind of discussion, you are only looking for validation of your QB. People's lists may not match some simple one dimensional stat. How have they performed in the playoffs/SB's in the past? What pieces do they have around them that may make them look better/worse than they are? How much is their D propping them up?

Wilson had nearly no respect among fans up here even through his run to their second SB with him at the helm. It was all their defense people said. He's getting respect now because he's earned it. Not in some flash in the pan one off season with crazy TE making him look better than he is.

Stop worrying about what anyone else thinks of your team/QB. Grow the fuck up and just enjoy the ride while it lasts.

 

[msgkings322]

Because it's clear from your not so passive aggressive bullshit with Harold that you aren't really interested in any kind of discussion, you are only looking for validation of your QB. People's lists may not match some simple one dimensional stat. How have they performed in the playoffs/SB's in the past? What pieces do they have around them that may make them look better/worse than they are? How much is their D propping them up?

Wilson had nearly no respect among fans up here even through his run to their second SB with him at the helm. It was all their defense people said. He's getting respect now because he's earned it. Not in some flash in the pan one off season with crazy TE making him look better than he is.

Stop worrying about what anyone else thinks of your team/QB. Grow the fuck up and just enjoy the ride while it lasts.

Seriously why is everyone so fucking sensitive. Fuck Garoppolo. Fuck that overrated pretty boy loser.

Now, does anyone have an opinion on who the top ten QBs are?

 

[SteelersPride]

Jimmy ranked high by many

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Mahomes
Jackson
Wilson
Brees
Watson
Prescott
Cousins
Stafford
Rodgers
Wentz

Jimmy G is just outside the top 10 for me.

 

[msgkings322]

Mahomes
Jackson
Wilson
Brees
Watson
Prescott
Cousins
Stafford
Rodgers
Wentz

Jimmy G is just outside the top 10 for me.

No Brady at all, rather have Wentz and Stafford even now? Totally defensible, I'm definitely on the "Brady is officially old" train

 

[msgkings322]

Jimmy ranked high by many

20-5 record will do that

 

[Fountain City Blues]

No Brady at all, rather have Wentz and Stafford even now? Totally defensible, I'm definitely on the "Brady is officially old" train

Yes, unironically.

I feel quite comfortable saying Brady isn't a good QB right now. He's flat missing throws he used to make in his sleep.

I thought (still think) I'd take more heat for saying Rodgers is the 3rd best QB in his own division right now and defending Wentz.

 

[Robotech]

Mahomes
Jackson
Wilson
Brees
Watson
Prescott
Cousins
Stafford
Rodgers
Wentz

Jimmy G is just outside the top 10 for me.

I think Jimmy is better than Wentz this season, but I've only watched Wentz a couple times, and in those games I watched (Seattle and NE), Wentz made several throws that missed by a lot. I guess he was better in the other games.

 

[msgkings322]

Yes, unironically.

I feel quite comfortable saying Brady isn't a good QB right now. He's flat missing throws he used to make in his sleep.

I thought (still think) I'd take more heat for saying Rodgers is the 3rd best QB in his own division right now and defending Wentz.

You might but all I can get to discuss it here is Seattle fans who dis JG

 

[Ojb81]

one thing that i think needs to be mentioned, is that Jimmy G has very solid mechanics from the pocket, and one of the quicker releases in the game...that's not something to minimalize..if anything, that's a foundation that he can build upon as his career progresses. he just needs to work on his pre-snap reads and protection calls, he gets himself into trouble and panics too often when he sees a blitz he wasn't ready for.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

1. Mahomes
2. Jackson
3. Wilson
4. Brees

5. Watson
6. Rodgers
7. Prescott

8. Cousins
9. Stafford
10. Ryan

...

11. Tannehill
12. Rivers
13. Garoppolo
14. Goff
15. Wentz
16. Allen
17. Carr
18. Brissett
19. Mayfield
20. Minshew
21. Murray
22. Hodges

...
A myriad of backups
...

30. Haskins
31. Trubisky
32. Darnold

....
Everyone else
...

Mason Rudolph

 

[Ricky Roma]

one thing that i think needs to be mentioned, is that Jimmy G has very solid mechanics from the pocket, and one of the quicker releases in the game...that's not something to minimalize..if anything, that's a foundation that he can build upon as his career progresses. he just needs to work on his pre-snap reads and protection calls, he gets himself into trouble and panics too often when he sees a blitz he wasn't ready for.

If anything, he doesn't really panic at all. He took a couple of sacks yesterday where he should've got rid of the ball, but he stands in there when the pocket has collapsed around him trying to make a play. On the flip side of not throwing it away, he'll convert two third and extremely longs when defenders are bearing down to pull out a game for yah. That's probably who he is - take the good with the bad - but in many other aspects, he's more than likely to get better in with more experience.

 

[Ojb81]

If anything, he doesn't really panic at all. He took a couple of sacks yesterday where he should've got rid of the ball, but he stands in there when the pocket has collapsed around him trying to make a play. On the flip side of not throwing it away, he'll convert two third and extremely longs when defenders are bearing down to pull out a game for yah. That's probably who he is - take the good with the bad - but in many other aspects, he's more than likely to get better in with more experience.

panic wasn't the correct word...sometimes he has a tendency to just not make good decisions when he misreads or gets confused by the opposing D, but honestly, that can be any QB. I would love for the Steelers to have a QB of Garoppalo's quality when Ben hangs them up.

 

[Ricky Roma]

panic wasn't the correct word...sometimes he has a tendency to just not make good decisions when he misreads or gets confused by the opposing D, but honestly, that can be any QB. I would love for the Steelers to have a QB of Garoppalo's quality when Ben hangs them up.

I can agree with that in general, and I'd like to think a lot of that will be corrected as he gains more playing experience. He may be 28, but this is still his first full season in Shanahan's complex offense, coming off a major injury. He didn't have his best stuff yesterday, and a lot of that was because the Rams pressure created problems, but after the last drive?

I may have to call him Jimmy 3:16.

 

[Robotech]

one thing that i think needs to be mentioned, is that Jimmy G has very solid mechanics from the pocket, and one of the quicker releases in the game...that's not something to minimalize..if anything, that's a foundation that he can build upon as his career progresses. he just needs to work on his pre-snap reads and protection calls, he gets himself into trouble and panics too often when he sees a blitz he wasn't ready for.

You're right. His mechanics are very sound and his release is quick. He is not some athletic marvel, but he's been a very solid QB. I think he's probably worked his way up to the upper third of NFL QB's and he is on an upward trajectory. Niners should be very happy.

 

[Robotech]

I can agree with that in general, and I'd like to think a lot of that will be corrected as he gains more playing experience. He may be 28, but this is still his first full season in Shanahan's complex offense, coming off a major injury. He didn't have his best stuff yesterday, and a lot of that was because the Rams pressure created problems, but after the last drive?

I may have to call him Jimmy 3:16.

Jimmy's a gun slinger.

 

[SteelersPride]

20-5 record will do that

Yeah we know record is everything. Right?

 

[GNG]

Mahomes
Jackson
Rodgers
Brees
Wilson
Brady
Cousins
Garoppolo
Watson
Prescott

Jackson
Mahomes
Rodgers
Brees
Brady
Wilson
Watson
Prescott
Stafford
Ryan

 

[Robotech]

Yeah we know record is everything. Right?

With no Jimmy last year, the Niners wound up with the the number 2 pick. Jimmy is worth at least 10 wins above a replacement level player!