Current HOF players

[Duffman]

Unless he falls of drastically I’d say Von Miller will be a lock.

 

[rmilia1]

First of all, you're not using logic....you're using stats at face value, coupled with some nonsensical ''06-10' era argument to make your point. Anyone who quotes guys like Fouts and Marino and stats is either completely ignorant of the history of NFL football, or is blind homering out. In this case, it could be both. Secondly, I already stated that I like Matt Ryan, so any claims that I believe 'he sucks' is straight up bullshit. Third, everybody has pointed out ten ways to Tuesday how your numbers don't add up to a HOF career. You can keep saying 'top 5' this and that, but the bottom line is, he's never been considered even a top 5 QB playing in his own time, save for one year.

No one has pointed out how a guy top 5 in all major passing categories by careers end equals not HoF worthy . Because it's impossible to do so. It's never happened and never will happen .

 

[Ricky Roma]

No one has pointed out how a guy top 5 in all major passing categories by careers end equals not HoF worthy . Because it's impossible to do so. It's never happened and never will happen .

Like I said....you still don't get it.

 

[rmilia1]

Like I said....you still don't get it.

Lol. Ok let's try this .

Currently Ryan has played 4 less seasons than Big Ben, Rivers and Eli and 2 less than Rodgers .

Gun to your head , knowing the 5 guys durability and current trending , who of those 5 do you think ends with more yards.

Right now

Ben 56,100
Eli 55,900
Rivers 54,700
Ryan 46,700
Rodgers 42,900

Then TDS

Right now

Rivers 374
Ben 363
Eli 360
Rodgers 338
Ryan 295

Once again knowing Ben, Rivers , Eli have all played 4 more seasons and Rodgers 2 more and their current play plus durability . Your life on the line . Who ya taking to end with the most in both categories ?

 

[SteelersPride]

actually looking at 2006-2010
guys that were legit starters:

bradford
stafford
sanchez
josh freeman
Ryan
Flacco
jamarcus
Kolb?
vince young
leinart
cutler

i mean holy hell thats bad

 

[Ricky Roma]

Lol. Ok let's try this .

Currently Ryan has played 4 less seasons than Big Ben, Rivers and Eli and 2 less than Rodgers .

Gun to your head , knowing the 5 guys durability and current trending , who of those 5 do you think ends with more yards.

Right now

Ben 56,100
Eli 55,900
Rivers 54,700
Ryan 46,700
Rodgers 42,900

Then TDS

Right now

Rivers 374
Ben 363
Eli 360
Rodgers 338
Ryan 295

Once again knowing Ben, Rivers , Eli have all played 4 more seasons and Rodgers 2 more and their current play plus durability . Your life on the line . Who ya taking to end with the most in both categories ?

I know who I am not taking for the HOF.....

You. Just. Don't. Get. It.

 

[rmilia1]

actually looking at 2006-2010
guys that were legit starters:

bradford
stafford
sanchez
josh freeman
Ryan
Flacco
jamarcus
Kolb?
vince young
leinart
cutler

i mean holy hell thats bad

You have to delineate eras somewhere . I do every 5 years but people have their own opinions . However you can't just bundle everyone together just because they're currently playing at the same time .

 

[SteelersPride]

right, but not every era has to have a HOF'er

just because its a passing era now, and ryan slings it, doesnt make him a hall of famer? is stafford?

 

[rmilia1]

I know who I am not taking for the HOF.....

You. Just. Don't. Get. It.

So Ryan for both ? Yeah I already knew that . You'd be crazy not to

 

[HaroldSeattle]

So Ryan for both ? Yeah I already knew that . You'd be crazy not to

Did a poll to help you see the light, Homer.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Poll is up.

 

[Ricky Roma]

So Ryan for both ? Yeah I already knew that . You'd be crazy not to

When you aren't considered one of the best 5 QB's of your own time, you ain't gonna be considered for an all time great club....unless he starts pulling off SB's.

I know, I know....but 'top 5.'

Get it? You don't.

 

[rmilia1]

Did a poll to help you see the light, Homer.

Not going to change the facts man . Numbers are numbers

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Compiler, but not special. It's simple.

 

[rmilia1]

When you aren't considered one of the best 5 QB's of your own time, you ain't gonna be considered for an all time great club....unless he starts pulling off SB's.

I know, I know....but 'top 5.'

Get it? You don't.

So top 5 all time is less important to the HoF than arbitrary era rankings from a dude on a message board ? Lol

 

[HaroldSeattle]

So top 5 all time is less important to the HoF than arbitrary era rankings from a dude on a message board ? Lol

All that actually counts is those that vote for HOF, but since this is a message board we can debate it. If his stats are all that impressive I’m sure he’ll win this poll. If there not, he’ll lose.

 

[rmilia1]

Compiler, but not special. It's simple.

The HoF is full of compilers man . You're acting like I said he's s HoFer now . He's not . I said if his career continues as it has he will end top 5 in all major QB categories . If you can find one other skill guy who is Top 5 all time at their position .who isn't in the Hall or won't be in you let me know

 

[rmilia1]

All that actually counts is those that vote for HOF, but since this is a message board we can debate it. If his stats are all that impressive I’m sure he’ll win this poll. If there not, he’ll lose.

Well you'll need to leave the poll open for 6 plus years then so it's going to be a long wait

 

[Ricky Roma]

So top 5 all time is less important to the HoF than arbitrary era rankings from a dude on a message board ? Lol

Of course it is.....he's not even considered top 5 in his own time. Then you have the glaringly obvious fact that for the most part, the only reason as to why he's achieved 'top 5' in any stat is the because the era he started and plays in. There are literally tons of QB's in NFL history who won't be in the 'top 5' that piss on Matt Ryan.

But you don't get it.....and you never will.

 

[steelerssb]

Who the fuck is Erin Brockovich