Give Me Your Top 10 QBs For This Year

[jarntt]

Most of the people I know have stated repeatedly that Tony Romo was overrated by most Cowboy fans. You could set your watch to his season..... Great September, October and November......December.....Implosion.

Oh....and Tony Romo was a better QB than Dak ever was.

I don't know how to fix the sucky formatting, but that misnomer has been proven wrong over and over:

QB Performance in December games, 2009-2013 (min. 200 ATT)

QB Passer
Rating CMP ATT Yds CMP% YPA TD INT
Aaron Rodgers 107.3 360 565 4,754 63.7 8.4 39 8
Peyton Manning 105.2 455 670 5,236 67.9 7.8 48 16
Drew Brees 104.4 621 886 6,790 70.1 7.7 53 17
Tony Romo 104.1 359 549 4,342 65.4 7.9 34 8
Russell Wilson 103.1 155 245 2,062 63.3 8.4 16 5
Philip Rivers 101.7 446 685 5,369 65.1 7.8 41 12
Nick Foles 98.3 202 321 2,494 62.9 7.8 16 4
Colin Kaepernick 98.1 175 287 2,294 61.0 8.0 14 3
Tom Brady 97.9 501 800 6,169 62.6 7.7 45 14
Cam Newton 93.8 231 393 2,994 58.8 7.6 23 8
Matt Ryan 92.3 454 727 4,824 62.5 6.6 38 12
Ben Roethlisberger 91.2 379 626 4,986 60.5 8.0 29 15
Michael Vick 90.7 154 260 2,129 59.2 8.2 14 8
Alex Smith 90.0 273 447 3,092 61.1 6.9 21 8
Carson Palmer 86.5 427 670 5,020 63.7 7.5 29 23
Matt Schaub 84.6 369 588 4,346 62.8 7.4 19 16
Andrew Luck 84.5 201 362 2,398 55.5 6.6 18 7
Andy Dalton 84.2 263 439 2,896 59.9 6.6 20 11
Jay Cutler 83.0 259 454 3,258 57.1 7.2 26 17
Ryan Tannehill 82.0 188 330 2,050 57.0 6.2 14 6
Eli Manning 81.7 420 719 5,479 58.4 7.6 37 31
Joe Flacco 81.5 371 642 4,171 57.8 6.5 33 20
Matthew Stafford 81.0 334 560 3,905 59.6 7.0 19 15
Kyle Orton 77.9 195 329 2,204 59.3 6.7 11 10
Christian Ponder 75.1 137 244 1,473 56.25 6.0 12 9
Matt Cassel 73.9 232 409 2,706 56.7 6.6 15 15
Ryan Fitzpatrick 72.5 378 651 4,275 58.1 6.6 22 26
Sam Bradford 72.4 215 372 2,339 57.8 6.3 8 10
John Skelton 63.2 127 241 1,536 52.7 6.4 7 11
Mark Sanchez 59.6 243 450 2,553 54.0 5.7 10 20

 

[PhillyGreen]

And most of the people you know, including yourself, are stupid.

More than 25 years of shit football. I think for the most part when we all say the Cowboys suck.....we tend to be right.

Dak's rookie season is a product of Zeke....that great offensive line and his supporting cast. He has not been much since and he was absolutely putrid yesterday.

 

[PhillyGreen]

I don't know how to fix the sucky formatting, but that misnomer has been proven wrong over and over:

QB Performance in December games, 2009-2013 (min. 200 ATT)

QB Passer
Rating CMP ATT Yds CMP% YPA TD INT
Aaron Rodgers 107.3 360 565 4,754 63.7 8.4 39 8
Peyton Manning 105.2 455 670 5,236 67.9 7.8 48 16
Drew Brees 104.4 621 886 6,790 70.1 7.7 53 17
Tony Romo 104.1 359 549 4,342 65.4 7.9 34 8
Russell Wilson 103.1 155 245 2,062 63.3 8.4 16 5
Philip Rivers 101.7 446 685 5,369 65.1 7.8 41 12
Nick Foles 98.3 202 321 2,494 62.9 7.8 16 4
Colin Kaepernick 98.1 175 287 2,294 61.0 8.0 14 3
Tom Brady 97.9 501 800 6,169 62.6 7.7 45 14
Cam Newton 93.8 231 393 2,994 58.8 7.6 23 8
Matt Ryan 92.3 454 727 4,824 62.5 6.6 38 12
Ben Roethlisberger 91.2 379 626 4,986 60.5 8.0 29 15
Michael Vick 90.7 154 260 2,129 59.2 8.2 14 8
Alex Smith 90.0 273 447 3,092 61.1 6.9 21 8
Carson Palmer 86.5 427 670 5,020 63.7 7.5 29 23
Matt Schaub 84.6 369 588 4,346 62.8 7.4 19 16
Andrew Luck 84.5 201 362 2,398 55.5 6.6 18 7
Andy Dalton 84.2 263 439 2,896 59.9 6.6 20 11
Jay Cutler 83.0 259 454 3,258 57.1 7.2 26 17
Ryan Tannehill 82.0 188 330 2,050 57.0 6.2 14 6
Eli Manning 81.7 420 719 5,479 58.4 7.6 37 31
Joe Flacco 81.5 371 642 4,171 57.8 6.5 33 20
Matthew Stafford 81.0 334 560 3,905 59.6 7.0 19 15
Kyle Orton 77.9 195 329 2,204 59.3 6.7 11 10
Christian Ponder 75.1 137 244 1,473 56.25 6.0 12 9
Matt Cassel 73.9 232 409 2,706 56.7 6.6 15 15
Ryan Fitzpatrick 72.5 378 651 4,275 58.1 6.6 22 26
Sam Bradford 72.4 215 372 2,339 57.8 6.3 8 10
John Skelton 63.2 127 241 1,536 52.7 6.4 7 11
Mark Sanchez 59.6 243 450 2,553 54.0 5.7 10 20

You know what......that was the first time I ever saw the numbers......so......I have to admit I was wrong when it comes to Tony Romo......aside from the Dak part....I stand by that. He was a better QB than Dak ever was and from the looks of it ever will be. I liked Romo aside from the fact that he was a Cowboy.....and I think he got screwed over.

 

[Earl Stevens]

More than 25 years of shit football. I think for the most part when we all say the Cowboys suck.....we tend to be right.

Dak's rookie season is a product of Zeke....that great offensive line and his supporting cast. He has not been much since and he was absolutely putrid yesterday.

Yea dude I get it. Dak isn't Brees, Rodgers, or Brady. That does't make him bad. Goff and Wentz weren't shit either with bad supporting casts or bad coaching.

 

[PhillyGreen]

Yea dude I get it. Dak isn't Brees, Rodgers, or Brady. That does't make him bad. Goff and Wentz weren't shit either with bad supporting casts or bad coaching.

Wentz threw for almost 4000 yards his rookie season. He only had 13 interceptions as well which I think is pretty good for a rookie. However his TD number was low but as far as rookie seasons go he had a fantastic rookie season with a shit supporting cast.

I am probably not going to go out and say that Dak is bad. That may be harsh be it seems he is regressing each week and that is not good.

 

[Earl Stevens]

You know what......that was the first time I ever saw the numbers......so......I have to admit I was wrong when it comes to Tony Romo......aside from the Dak part....I stand by that. He was a better QB than Dak ever was and from the looks of it ever will be. I liked Romo aside from the fact that he was a Cowboy.....and I think he got screwed over.

Yea it's easy to say that now Romo is retired. When he was playing I'm sure you thought he was a choker and not the answer at QB just like the rest of the trolls. Dak just started his 33rd game and he doesn't have prime Witten, TO, and Austin as security blankets. A little too soon to be saying such stupid shit like this.

 

[Across The Field]

Wrong about what? Dak isnt a shit QB you fucking idiot. Every fucking stat suggests that I'm right. QBs that finish top 5 in total QBR in b2b years aren't shit. QBs with a career 65% completion aren't shit. Is Dak top 10-15 right now? Probably not, but saying he is shit is a shit opinion. Brent Hundley is shit. DeShone Kizer is shit. Nathan Peterman is shit. You're shit.

Not top 15 is for sure. He's probably at best top 20.

 

[Earl Stevens]

Wentz threw for almost 4000 yards his rookie season. He only had 13 interceptions as well which I think is pretty good for a rookie. However his TD number was low but as far as rookie seasons go he had a fantastic rookie season with a shit supporting cast.

I am probably not going to go out and say that Dak is bad. That may be harsh be it seems he is regressing each week and that is not good.

A 49.4 total QBR is not good.

 

[PhillyGreen]

Yea it's easy to say that now Romo is retired. When he was playing I'm sure you thought he was a choker and not the answer at QB just like the rest of the trolls. Dak just started his 33rd game and he doesn't have prime Witten, TO, and Austin as security blankets. A little too soon to be saying such stupid shit like this.

I have gone on record from the very beginning saying that Dak was ridiculously overrated. From day one I have said that and stated that his numbers are thanks to Zeke and that offensive line.

 

[PhillyGreen]

A 49.4 total QBR is not good.

QBR? That is a fucking useless rating. Skip Bayless is the only one that keeps harping on that stat and he is a fucking moron.

 

[Earl Stevens]

From day one I have said that and stated that his numbers are thanks to Zeke and that offensive line.

Then we can agree that Wentz season last year was a product of his supporting cast. I mean, they won the SB without him.

 

[handicappers]

Then we can agree that Wentz season last year was a product of his supporting cast. I mean, they won the SB without him.

Boom

 

[Earl Stevens]

QBR? That is a fucking useless rating. Skip Bayless is the only one that keeps harping on that stat and he is a fucking moron.

Of course it's useless, because it doesn't fit your narrative.

 

[SteelersPride]

jimmies being rustled

 

[Fountain City Blues]

I think most Dak defenders like myself figured this would not be a great year for him. 2019 is really gonna be the year to show out when he has a fair shot with some receiving talent.

 

[PhillyGreen]

Of course it's useless, because it doesn't fit your narrative.

What was Carson Wentz QBR last season? Where was he ranked in QBR? Your argument is stupid.

 

[SteelersPride]

What was Carson Wentz QBR last season? Where was he ranked in QBR? Your argument is stupid.

 

[Earl Stevens]

What was Carson Wentz QBR last season? Where was he ranked in QBR? Your argument is stupid.

It was the best in football. Wentz played extremely well last year. Was a front runner for MVP. His total QBR supported his play. So no, my argument isn't stupid.

 

[PhillyGreen]

It was the best in football. Wentz played extremely well last year. Was a front runner for MVP. His total QBR supported his play. So no, my argument isn't stupid.

Yes it is. You bashed me for saying QBR was a useless state. Stating that I don't like it because it does not support my narrative. Considering the fact that my favorite QB led that particular stat and I still bashed the stat made your argument about my stance.....well......stupid.

 

[Across The Field]

I would not be surprised of the Cowboys parted ways with Dak after this season. If he does not perform he could very well get cut. He is regressing that badly.

They're going to waste Zeke playing with a bum like Dak. Their best bet is to start looking high in the 2019 class for their next signal caller, or maybe even go after a vet who can be a good bridge.