Rowdy
Well-Known Member
Pre-injury, I'd take Wentz
After injury I'd take Smith
After injury I'd take Smith
What you have to ask yourself is why Dak regressed and Wentz became very good.
No we don't. Both QB's have had 1 really good year and 1 average year.
What you have to ask yourself is why Dak regressed and Wentz became very good.
now if it was foles im on boardWentz in the top 10? Give me a fuckin' break NFL.com... I mean the guy had a great season, but let's see him do it again (his rookie one was fairly mediocre) and win a fuckin' playoff game before we crown him top 10...
He's got the #1 O-Line in the NFL to boot (for sure top 3)...
now if it was foles im on board
Wentz in the top 10? Give me a fuckin' break NFL.com... I mean the guy had a great season, but let's see him do it again (his rookie one was fairly mediocre) and win a fuckin' playoff game before we crown him top 10...
He's got the #1 O-Line in the NFL to boot (for sure top 3)...
its like theres a bat light, when wentz is typed @PhoenixEagles1 comes a calling
And when it comes to Wentz is average year he had a team with a broke down line and no receivers coming off a college career with almost ZERO reps.
And you are correct. Now flip that around to 2017 and that's what Dak had to deal with. Broken line, susp top RB and mediocre WR's at best. That's why I say lets take a look at each at the end of their first contract, so that would be 4 yrs in and have a better judgement on both. Who knows, one could distance themselves from the pack or both could be on par with each other. Only time will tell.
Coaching is pretty high on the list, being a mediocre talent that was carried by a phenom rookie RB is right up there too.
I agree with that but we don’t need time. Dak will never have the talent Wentz has. He doesn’t have the arm talent that Wentz has. I see progression from one QB and regression from another. It sounds like I’m ripping Dak but I’m not. He can be good in the right situation. He reminds me of McNabb in ways but he doesn’t have the ability to be an elite QB... Wentz has the potential to be the best player in the NFL... Dak doesn’t.
"Wentz is the best QB ever and will be forever, my magazine said so"
PEdOOfuSS
Most QB's will regress with a broken line, top RB missing and WR's that are hurt or average. This year and next will be telling about both QB's.