Yankees @ M's 6/1-6/3

[Anointed One]

You're doing fine on your own

Cop out... You don't have a rational reason to debunk my statement...

 

[Itsmytime]

He is overrated... Lifetime .263 hitter... He's talked up by so many here like he's a all star that's going to the HOF... He's overrated...

You know who was a career .267 hitter... Mike Schmidt. Yeah BA is a bullshit stat. No one is claiming Seager is going to be a HoF but he produces 2 years of 20+ HR and 80+ RBIs

 

[Tapey]

Again, prove to me why he's not overrated... Did you not read the entire sentence? Selective reading I see...

Selective reading indeed, and I've never said he will be a hof, also there is more to judge a player than just their batting avg.

 

[Anointed One]

Are you for real or making an effort just to troll at this point. He's the 2nd best hitter on the team right now. If you aren't letting him swing away then there's some serious issues.

2nd best hitter on the team? Seriously? That's what you're going to run with? How is our team hitting?

 

[Cloud]

He is overrated... Lifetime .263 hitter... He's talked up by so many here like he's a all star that's going to the HOF... He's overrated...

2.6 WAR in 2012 - His second season.
3.9 WAR in 2013.
5.8 WAR in 2014.

Yup.. He's overrated, because a batting average is a good way to go at it.

 

[Anointed One]

You know who was a career .267 hitter... Mike Schmidt. Yeah BA is a bullshit stat.

? LOL...

 

[Anointed One]

2.6 WAR in 2012 - His second season.
3.9 WAR in 2013.
5.8 WAR in 2014.

Yup.. He's overrated, because a batting average is a good way to go at it.

Who said I was just going by BA? How is he doing this year?

 

[gohusk]

2nd best hitter on the team? Seriously? That's what you're going to run with? How is our team hitting?

And the #1 hitter might be the #1 hitter in the AL. What the fuck is your point? It doesn't matter how you "rate" him. He's the #5 hitter, the #2 hitter on the team, and they're trying to gimmick a run with him. That's stupid. Do you even watch baseball or do you just wait for the team to come off the rails for some great trolling material?

 

[Tapey]

Who said I was just going by BA? How is he doing this year?

Pretty good, Better than what he is usually doing, around this time.

 

[Anointed One]

You guys are making a classic cas

And the #1 hitter might be the #1 hitter in the AL. What the fuck is your point? It doesn't matter how you "rate" him. He's the #5 hitter, the #2 hitter on the team, and they're trying to gimmick a run with him. That's stupid. Do you even watch baseball or do you just wait for the team to come off the rails for some great trolling material?

Not really... I never bought into Seager... He's a solid player... That's all... Nothing more...

 

[Cloud]

Who said I was just going by BA? How is he doing this year?

Claiming he was overrated based on his .263 lifetime batting in your previous post suggest to me otherwise. And he's doing perfectly fine this year. 2.0 WAR, still has plenty more season left to go for him.

Keep asking questions to validate your argument that he's "overrated"

 

[Tapey]

I like this Austin jackson a lot more than usual A jacks.

 

[gohusk]

2.6 WAR in 2012 - His second season.
3.9 WAR in 2013.
5.8 WAR in 2014.

Yup.. He's overrated, because a batting average is a good way to go at it.

Don't bother. he doesn't know what the hell he's talking about. He thinks that it's easy to find a guy with that type of glove and arm who can also be really productive at the plate.

 

[Cloud]

You guys are making a classic cas



Not really... I never bought into Seager... He's a solid player... That's all... Nothing more...

So now you back track and claim he's a solid player.

A solid player and an overrated player are two completely different players. Which is it?

 

[Anointed One]

Claiming he was overrated based on his .263 lifetime batting in your previous post suggest to me otherwise. And he's doing perfectly fine this year. 2.0 WAR, still has plenty more season left to go for him.

Keep asking questions to validate your argument that he's "overrated"

He's overrated from where M's fans' tend to place him... Seems like he get's a pass so much because he's, Kyle Seager... Just shows how low our standards have gone...

 

[Anointed One]

So now you back track and claim he's a solid player.

A solid player and an overrated player are two completely different players. Which is it?

With what I hear from M's fans, who think he's a stud, I don't think he's there... That's why I think he's overrated...

 

[Tapey]

He's overrated from where M's fans' tend to place him... Seems like he get's a pass so much because he's, Kyle Seager... Just shows how low our standards have gone...

That's just stupid, he gets a "pass" because he plays good baseball.

 

[Anointed One]

That's just stupid, he gets a "pass" because he plays good baseball.

He plays solid baseball but M's fans tend to place him in an entirely different category...

You guys rip on Cano like it's going out of style but tend to give Seager a pass...

 

[gohusk]

You guys are making a classic cas



Not really... I never bought into Seager... He's a solid player... That's all... Nothing more...

Then who the hell do you want playing 3rd base, if he's so overrated?

 

[Podunkparte]

He was just mad Seager made his fat ass run a little bit for the base ball. Haha.

Think he was just pissed because the shift was on and Seager tried to sneak the bunt through. It was cheap.

Shift wasn't on, but Seager was trying to get it passed CC.

Offense is struggling, Seager already struck out twice badly, he had to try something. Trying to win a game isn't cheap. That's the point of the game.