Would you make either of these trades?

[femurov]

Yes

I would absolutely trade Gibbs for Garrett Wilson and AJ Brown. I am finding it hard to believe that there is not some sort of miscommunication going on here because I don't think this is even a question.

 

[SteelersPride]

Accept it before he pulls it.
For real?

A third of his career carries were in one game.

Yep. Lol. I know i have at least once. Perhaps that game

 

[SteelersPride]

I would absolutely trade Gibbs for Garrett Wilson or AJ Brown. I am finding it hard to believe that there is not some sort of miscommunication going on here because I don't think this is even a question.

You know I dont communicate well.

 

[femurov]

You know I dont communicate well.

Ok... I do know that. But that was what the clarification question was about and when you said yes, I was really confused as to what I was missing. Is this a dynasty league? Are you competitive?

 

[SteelersPride]

Ok... I do know that. But that was what the clarification question was about and when you said yes, I was really confused as to what I was missing. Is this a dynasty league? Are you competitive?

My fault.

Redraft. But yes competitive.

Gibbs for garrett wilson

Or

Gibbs for aj brown

 

[TKOSpikes]

My fault.

Redraft. But yes competitive.

Gibbs for garrett wilson

Or

Gibbs for aj brown

That’s how I interpreted it.
Yes on Brown
Yes on Garrett (plus a side)…

I’ll add, Garrett’s side piece would have to be pretty decent for me to even look. Probably just insta-accept AJB.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

My fault.

Redraft. But yes competitive.

Gibbs for garrett wilson

Or

Gibbs for aj brown

Gibbs for AJ Brown yes
Gibbs for Garrett Wilson no

 

[SteelersPride]

That’s how I interpreted it.
Yes on Brown
Yes on Garrett (plus a side)…

I’ll add, Garrett’s side piece would have to be pretty decent for me to even look. Probably just insta-accept AJB.

He had kittle in there but wanted nico collins then kirk. Kittle holds far less value bc we dont start a tight end

 

[Shanemansj13]

He had kittle in there but wanted nico collins then kirk. Kittle holds far less value bc we dont start a tight end

So he wanted Gibbs and Nico or Kirk for Kittle and Wilson?

If so, I am in one league I haven’t started Kittle yet. I do have Hockenson, part of the reason, but even with W/R/T slots I have better options. I wouldn’t give Collins/Kirk straight up for Kittle so that makes little sense.
I would just do AJ Brown straight up for Gibbs

 

[SteelersPride]

So he wanted Gibbs and Nico or Kirk for Kittle and Wilson?

If so, I am in one league I haven’t started Kittle yet. I do have Hockenson, part of the reason, but even with W/R/T slots I have better options. I wouldn’t give Collins/Kirk straight up for Kittle so that makes little sense.
I would just do AJ Brown straight up for Gibbs

Yeah thats the offer. I play him this week and of course kittle got him 16. But hes erratic. In a non te slot…ill pass. I have ajb for gibbs on the table. That guy is trigger shy and he very much goes week by week. Im hoping gibbs goes off and ajb struggles some afain. If he has a great game he wint trade him, even if gibbs goes nuts

 

[Shanemansj13]

Yeah thats the offer. I play him this week and of course kittle got him 16. But hes erratic. In a non te slot…ill pass. I have ajb for gibbs on the table. That guy is trigger shy and he very much goes week by week. Im hoping gibbs goes off and ajb struggles some afain. If he has a great game he wint trade him, even if gibbs goes nuts

You better hope AJB struggles this week but I think he goes off. Gibbs will get his golden opportunity this week too

 

[Shanemansj13]

I am hijacking this thread as well.

I am in a dynasty 10 team full PPR. My QB's are Dak, Watson and Geno.

His QB's are Tua, Burrow and Fields and he is a big Tua-Bama fan.

I am thinking about trading Mattison and Pitts for Joe Burrow. I have not made a real offer yet but my roster is below. I also put his roster below too. I am getting discouraged by Pitts and Mattison is not the future imo. I wanted to couple those two for a player.

Any suggestions?

My Squad

View attachment 341222
View attachment 341223

His squad

View attachment 341224
View attachment 341225

So in my dynasty, he countered:

He gets:
Pitts
Mattison
Ford (got him on WW)

I get:
Burrow
Schultz

 

[MilkSpiller22]

So in my dynasty, he countered:

He gets:
Pitts
Mattison
Ford (got him on WW)

I get:
Burrow
Schultz

Dynasty. Sure. Burrow is the best value. Even if he is a question right now.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

So in my dynasty, he countered:

He gets:
Pitts
Mattison
Ford (got him on WW)

I get:
Burrow
Schultz

In dynasty you hit accept quickly, Burrow is the only one with high future value.

 

[Shanemansj13]

In dynasty you hit accept quickly, Burrow is the only one with high future value.

I did lol

 

[SteelersPride]

Ok guys. This hs me thinking

I get
Garrett wilson, joe mixon, cam akers

I give
Jamyr gibbs
Courtland sutton

 

[Shanemansj13]

Ok guys. This hs me thinking

I get
Garrett wilson, joe mixon, cam akers

I give
Jamyr gibbs
Courtland sutton

Dynasty or redraft?

Either way getting Mixon and Wilson is enough for me to that deal in redraft. Dynasty hesitant but I would pull the trigger

 

[SteelersPride]

Dynasty or redraft?

Either way getting Mixon and Wilson is enough for me to that deal in redraft. Dynasty hesitant but I would pull the trigger

It was re-draft. Sorry I missed this.

anyone want to revisit this now? Gibbs value is tanking

 

[MilkSpiller22]

It was re-draft. Sorry I missed this.

anyone want to revisit this now? Gibbs value is tanking

sure... but so is mixons!!!

 

[SteelersPride]

sure... but so is mixons!!!

True he has on the table now

Akers, mixon, garrett wilson

For

Sutton, gibbs, achane.

Hard pass