Would you make either of these trades?

[SteelersPride]

1 ppr. Gibbs useage has been rather poor. If hes truly just swift again, then ill trade and roll with monty. Guy is trying desperately to trade garrett wilson. Aj brown may be available. Obv worries are zach wilson with the jets and browns slow start. That offense hummed last year. I expected some regression.

At this point my only wr lock is nico collins. Dont wanna cripple at rb though too.

 

[femurov]

What is the offer? Gibbs for garrett Wilson and aj brown?

 

[Shanemansj13]

Yeah I’m not a big fan of your WR’s. I would trade Gibbs. I would try to get AJ or Wilson or somehow get both

 

[TKOSpikes]

Gibbs for Brown
Gibbs for Wilson and….

Yes, I would

 

[SmokingMonkey]

full PPR...Gibbs might end up with more rec on the season than whatever you get from the Wilson-Wilson connection.
I'd rather have AJB if this is redraft

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Going to hijack this with my own question for a 16tm full ppr dynasty, I'm Taylor owner not looking to compete for title this year but hope to again next season

Send Adam Thielen, Michael Wilson, '24 early 2nd

Get Hollywood Brown, Zach Moss

Thoughts?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Going to hijack this with my own question for a 16tm full ppr dynasty, I'm Taylor owner not looking to compete for title this year but hope to again next season

Send Adam Thielen, Michael Wilson, '24 early 2nd

Get Hollywood Brown, Zach Moss

Thoughts?

why you trading taylor then???

 

[averagejoe]

Isn't Monty out/hurt?

 

[SmokingMonkey]

why you trading taylor then???

I'm not, or are you asking why I'm not trying to trade him?

I've had him on the block and got a couple people that said they were interested in the off-season, but that all dissipated once the feud with Irsay kicked up followed by the PUP designation

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Isn't Monty out/hurt?

hurt but not out, at least not yet

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Going to hijack this with my own question for a 16tm full ppr dynasty, I'm Taylor owner not looking to compete for title this year but hope to again next season

Send Adam Thielen, Michael Wilson, '24 early 2nd

Get Hollywood Brown, Zach Moss

Thoughts?

OK... i got confused due to half reading...

You are not trading Taylor, you are just informing us you own him since you are thinking about getting Moss....


If you are already conceding this season, then this season should not be a factor IMO...

Which then makes me like an early 2nd round MOST out of the 5 players in this deal... so I WOULD NOT DO IT!!!

 

[SmokingMonkey]

OK... i got confused due to half reading...

You are not trading Taylor, you are just informing us you own him since you are thinking about getting Moss....


If you are already conceding this season, then this season should not be a factor IMO...

Which then makes me like an early 2nd round MOST out of the 5 players in this deal... so I WOULD NOT DO IT!!!

that's actually right around where I have Hollywood's value - rookie pick 18-24 range, mid-late 2nd in a 12 team league but this is 16 teams, at least 2 teams a lot worse than mine, so best case scenario on that pick's value is 18-20.

I like rookies and all, but not sure there will be one available in the draft that deep that has the same 2-3 year production that Hollywood will get

 

[MilkSpiller22]

that's actually right around where I have Hollywood's value - rookie pick 18-24 range, mid-late 2nd in a 12 team league but this is 16 teams, at least 2 teams a lot worse than mine, so best case scenario on that pick's value is 18-20.

I like rookies and all, but not sure there will be one available in the draft that deep that has the same 2-3 year production that Hollywood will get

but Brown is going to be one year older, he is still on the cardinals... and Michael Wilson is the new toy for the cardinals... If the cardinals were better, then maybe i would have more faith in Brown.... But as is, i have Brown and WIlson basically being tied...

The true wild card IMO is Moss...

He could be the colts starting RB next season.... so...

 

[Shanemansj13]

I'm not, or are you asking why I'm not trying to trade him?

I've had him on the block and got a couple people that said they were interested in the off-season, but that all dissipated once the feud with Irsay kicked up followed by the PUP designation

If the plan is to eventually trade Taylor or just see what teams he goes to for the fit...that is your only choice. You won't get the valued deserved for him and probably little interest. If he goes to a nice team he could be part of your rebuild and then compete in the 1-2 years OR you get nice value for him.

Going to hijack this with my own question for a 16tm full ppr dynasty, I'm Taylor owner not looking to compete for title this year but hope to again next season

Send Adam Thielen, Michael Wilson, '24 early 2nd

Get Hollywood Brown, Zach Moss

Thoughts?

You get a Indy starter and a young WR. If Zona tanks for Caleb-Hollywood will be a nice asset then. You aren't giving up much value other than the 2nd. I would try to give a lower pick if possible but player wise you are getting the better end even if Thielen is a nice option this year.

 

[Shanemansj13]

but Brown is going to be one year older, he is still on the cardinals... and Michael Wilson is the new toy for the cardinals... If the cardinals were better, then maybe i would have more faith in Brown.... But as is, i have Brown and WIlson basically being tied...

The true wild card IMO is Moss...

He could be the colts starting RB next season.... so...

If Caleb goes to Zona, I think that only helps him more with this trade (Brown). I don't think it would be a longshot that the Cards end up with the #1 pick. Technically, Houston or Arizona could be the worst team and they get the #1 pick.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I am hijacking this thread as well.

I am in a dynasty 10 team full PPR. My QB's are Dak, Watson and Geno.

His QB's are Tua, Burrow and Fields and he is a big Tua-Bama fan.

I am thinking about trading Mattison and Pitts for Joe Burrow. I have not made a real offer yet but my roster is below. I also put his roster below too. I am getting discouraged by Pitts and Mattison is not the future imo. I wanted to couple those two for a player.

Any suggestions?

My Squad




His squad

 

[TREFF]

@SteelersPride I would agree with the previous comments that yeah, you might need WR help..but man, if theres any week to hold onto Gibbs and see what happens, is this one where Monty should be out. His usage has been very disappointing, but the kid has looked great when given the chance. If he balls out this weekend? sky may be the limit, might even be able to get more.

That said, the value is good enough to pull the trigger on the deal--either of them, IMHO..I just couldn't do it, not this week

 

[broncosmitty]

Would I trade Gibbs?

Yes, yes I would.

Craig Reynolds is going to get the most snaps in that backfield until Monty is back.

 

[broncosmitty]

If Caleb goes to Zona, I think that only helps him more with this trade (Brown). I don't think it would be a longshot that the Cards end up with the #1 pick. Technically, Houston or Arizona could be the worst team and they get the #1 pick.

My money is on Chicago. And they aren’t even tanking.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Would I trade Gibbs?

Yes, yes I would.

Craig Reynolds is going to get the most snaps in that backfield until Monty is back.