POLL Which NFC East is on the hottest seat?

[eaglesnut]

Sirianni has supposedly learned from his awful mistake of hiring idiots to run both sides of the ball. He was probably promoted too early if he needed that lesson, but training on the job works. Just look at Tom Brady. He started pretty lame and just kept getting better and better. Nick will be able to do his job if the coordinators do theirs.

 

[PDay8810]

Nick will be able to do his job if the coordinators do theirs.

said every coach everywhere.

 

[eaglesnut]

said every coach everywhere.

They all fired both their coordinators???

If you can't grasp the dialogue why comment lol

 

[PDay8810]

They all fired both their coordinators???

If you can't grasp the dialogue why comment lol

lol at you...always the bridesmaid.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

I think Daboll is pretty much a dead man walking simply because the team flat out isn't talented enough to get him out of it but I voted Sirianni because he has zero excuses if things go south. Nobody can point to the co-ordinaters this season if they suffer another meltdown. They have about as solid a roster as anybody and anything less than an NFCCG would be considered a failure. Also, Lurie has shown that he won't hesitate to pull the plug, no matter what past success a guy had.

 

[Sportsguy9695]

Brian Daboll is for sure. With the ny media and the expectations they put on him

 

[Thruthefog]

Sirianni.

 

[jarntt]

It's a dead heat. From what you read all three were almost (and probably should have been) fired last year. Sirianni had one of the worst, most delightful collapses in NFL history and probably only survived because his coordinators were scapegoated. McCarthy came up short AGAIN when it mattered most and he and his coaching staff were clearly outcoached again in a playoff loss and I'm not sure how the heck Daboll is still the HC

 

[ducky]

I think it's Daboll because Belichik has practically come out and said he covets the Giants job. So Daboll would need a surprisingly good season to stave that off.

Belichick isnt going to coach again. He might want to but to the rest of the league isn't going to want him.

The game has passed him by. And it is pretty damn clear from the last couple of seasons that he isnt capable of developing young talent especially on offense. What team that fires its coach is going to be in a position where the new head coach who doesnt need to develop young offensive talent?

You literally have to go back to the 2010 NFL draft to find an offensive skill position player that developed under Belichick and that was fricking Gronk. During that entire 14 year period by FAR the best player he can hang his hat on is Rhamondre Stevenson.

 

[Pastafazul]

My Giants ..

They have not lost a regular season game this year

And Jones? hottest QB in NFL

Has not thrown an interception yet

 

[PDay8810]

Belichick isnt going to coach again. He might want to but to the rest of the league isn't going to want him.

could not read anymore.
jerry says hold my beer.

 

[Clayton]

I think Daboll is pretty much a dead man walking simply because the team flat out isn't talented enough to get him out of it but I voted Sirianni because he has zero excuses if things go south. Nobody can point to the co-ordinaters this season if they suffer another meltdown. They have about as solid a roster as anybody and anything less than an NFCCG would be considered a failure. Also, Lurie has shown that he won't hesitate to pull the plug, no matter what past success a guy had.

Kinda my read on things. Sirianni basically gets fired if he ever goes 3 games below .500 or misses the playoffs, I think.

The thing about Daboll is that he might keep his job if he plays his way out of a QB sweepstakes in next year's draft. I know its hard to predict draft classes but not a lot of people are excited about the QB crop next year. If the Giants win 6 or 7 games then they might roll with Daboll one more season. Giants have some exciting players. A big thing to watch in this division is Malik Nabers and Jayden Daniels. Nabers is already getting overanalyzed by NY media for 'getting open but not getting any targets'. Its one preseason game, guys.

 

[Iggloo]

I think all three could be fired depending on how the season plays out. Daboll seems the most likely to me. The chances that that team is good are quite low.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Kinda my read on things. Sirianni basically gets fired if he ever goes 3 games below .500 or misses the playoffs, I think.

The thing about Daboll is that he might keep his job if he plays his way out of a QB sweepstakes in next year's draft. I know its hard to predict draft classes but not a lot of people are excited about the QB crop next year. If the Giants win 6 or 7 games then they might roll with Daboll one more season. Giants have some exciting players. A big thing to watch in this division is Malik Nabers and Jayden Daniels. Nabers is already getting overanalyzed by NY media for 'getting open but not getting any targets'. Its one preseason game, guys.

I don't think Sirianni even has to have things go that bad but if either of those scenarios happen, it's a no brainer. I think even finishing behind Dallas in the division and losing in the first round would be the end of Sirianni. Lurie won't hesitate, imo. I mean hell, Dougie P got the boot only a couple years removed from a SB win.
You could be right on Daboll. It's gonna be a tough road for him though. That sorta fluke 2022 season raised the expectations too much, I think. Nabers helps but I don't know if it's enough or if they will have the same old issues in the trenches they've had seemingly forever. Not much depth on offense if they have any injuries. The defense might keep them in a few games though. They are really good up front. 5-7 wins is the best they can hope for, imo and 7 would require some breaks to go their way.

 

[fastforward]

I don't think Sirianni even has to have things go that bad but if either of those scenarios happen, it's a no brainer. I think even finishing behind Dallas in the division and losing in the first round would be the end of Sirianni. Lurie won't hesitate, imo. I mean hell, Dougie P got the boot only a couple years removed from a SB win.
You could be right on Daboll. It's gonna be a tough road for him though. That sorta fluke 2022 season raised the expectations too much, I think. Nabers helps but I don't know if it's enough or if they will have the same old issues in the trenches they've had seemingly forever. Not much depth on offense if they have any injuries. The defense might keep them in a few games though. They are really good up front. 5-7 wins is the best they can hope for, imo and 7 would require some breaks to go their way.

I'm not sure who else would want the Eagles job. Sure, it's an NFL HC job, but there are very few opportunities to make meaningful player changes outside of the Draft.

 

[eaglesnut]

Belichick isnt going to coach again. He might want to but to the rest of the league isn't going to want him.

The game has passed him by. And it is pretty damn clear from the last couple of seasons that he isnt capable of developing young talent especially on offense. What team that fires its coach is going to be in a position where the new head coach who doesnt need to develop young offensive talent?

You literally have to go back to the 2010 NFL draft to find an offensive skill position player that developed under Belichick and that was fricking Gronk. During that entire 14 year period by FAR the best player he can hang his hat on is Rhamondre Stevenson.

Defense was still money. Even with such a shitty offense.

"The game passed him by" is a lame critique.

 

[eaglesnut]

I'm not sure who else would want the Eagles job. Sure, it's an NFL HC job, but there are very few opportunities to make meaningful player changes outside of the Draft.

Belichick. Duh.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

It's a dead heat. From what you read all three were almost (and probably should have been) fired last year. Sirianni had one of the worst, most delightful collapses in NFL history and probably only survived because his coordinators were scapegoated. McCarthy came up short AGAIN when it mattered most and he and his coaching staff were clearly outcoached again in a playoff loss and I'm not sure how the heck Daboll is still the HC

completely agree with most of it.
I do think Daboll is a little bit insulated with the fact he has had shit to work with.
Cowboys & Eagles cant say that.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Belichick. Duh.

If he gets full control yes and Howie manages only the cap and goes back to the broom closet.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

A repeat of last season and Nicky is gone. There's no one else to throw under the bus.