The MLB Pick a Player Draft SF1 : 500 vs Shane

[Nosferatu]

500

LINEUP
1. Craig Biggio (R) - 2B - 250 - 299
2. Paul Waner (L) - RF - 100 - 149
3. Alex Rodriguez (R) - SS - 500+
4. Ralph Kiner (R) - LF - 300 - 399
5. Jeff Bagwell (R) - 1B - 400 - 499
6. Don Mattingly (L) - 1B - 200 - 249
7. Home Run Baker (R) - 3B - 50 - 99
8. Ernie Lombardi (R) - C - 150 - 199
9. Charlie Blackmon (L) - CF - 150 - 199

ROTATION
1. Walter Johnson (R) - 300+
2. Whitey Ford (L) - 200 - 249
3. Bob Feller (R) - 250 - 299
4. Clayton Kershaw (L) - 150 - 199
5. Stephen Strasburg (R) - 149

BULLPEN
Francisco Rodriguez (R) - 300+
Greg Holland (R) - 200 - 299
Zack Briton (L) - 100 - 199
Felipe Vazquez (L) - 99

VS

SHANE

LINEUP
1. Tris Speaker (L) - CF - 100 - 149
2. Joey Votto (L) - 1B - 250 - 299
3. Ted Williams (L) - LF - 500+
4. Miguel Cabrera (R) - 3B - 400 - 499
5. Johnny Bench (R) - C - 300 - 399
6. Lou Whitaker (L) - 2B - 200 - 249
7. Jesse Burkett (L) - RF - 50-99
8. Alan Trammell (R) - SS - 150 - 199
9. Richie Ashburn (L) - DH - 0-49

ROTATION
1. Pedro Martinez (R) - 200 - 249
2. Lefty Grove (L) - 300+
3. Fergie Jenkins (R) - 250 - 299
4. Lefty Gomez (L) - 150 - 199
5. Jacob deGrom (R) - 149

BULLPEN
Craig Kimbrel (R) - 300+
Dan Quisenberry (R) - 200 - 299
Wilbur Wood (L) - 99
Tug McGraw (L) - 100 - 199

 

[Nosferatu]

500 -
SHANE -

VOTED -

Race to FIVE

 

[Shanemansj13]

I think 500 has the best rotation in this mock but imo I think my offense is much better. Great team like always, 5

 

[tducey]

500

 

[femurov]

5

 

[Pack 500]

I think 500 has the best rotation in this mock but imo I think my offense is much better. Great team like always, 5

You're the man but I don't believe that is the case. The bottom of your lineup is not anything to write home about. I actually like your rotation better than your lineup. I vote me here

 

[Stakesarehigh]

500

 

[broncosmitty]

500


Even though I wanted you to use Biggio as a catcher.

 

[Shanemansj13]

You're the man but I don't believe that is the case. The bottom of your lineup is not anything to write home about. I actually like your rotation better than your lineup. I vote me here

Yours isn't either

 

[Hall]

500

 

[Pack 500]

Yours isn't either

No, but I never claimed it was much better

 

[Nosferatu]

Congrats whatever your name is!

 

[Pack 500]

Congrats whatever your name is!

I'm pretty sure you had it as fuck face at one point....

 

[Shanemansj13]

No, but I never claimed it was much better

yeah but you specifically pointed out my bottom. Overall did you honestly think your lineup was better than mine? Where is @blstoker aka the stat king when we need him

 

[Nosferatu]

yeah but you specifically pointed out my bottom

Ghey

 

[Shanemansj13]

Ghey

I didnt ask you your preference!

 

[blstoker]

yeah but you specifically pointed out my bottom. Overall did you honestly think your lineup was better than mine? Where is @blstoker aka the stat king when we need him

Working

 

[Nosferatu]

Working

You need to come back and you ignoring my texts hurt my feels!!

 

[Pack 500]

yeah but you specifically pointed out my bottom. Overall did you honestly think your lineup was better than mine? Where is @blstoker aka the stat king when we need him

Speaker > Biggio
Votto > Waner
Ted > A-Rod
Miggy > Kiner but really only because of longevity. per season Kiner is right there with him
Bagwell > Bench
Donny > Whitaker
Burkett > Baker
Lombardi > Trammel
Ashburn > Blackmon although this is much closer than anybody would think when you look at it. Gotta give Blackmon a Coors downgrade.

So would it crazy to say my lineup is better? No. Waner/Votto Miggy/Kiner, Burkett/Baker, Ashburn/Blackmon are all really close and I feel I have solid edges in 5, 6 and 8 spots You probably have the marginally better one, but you made it sound like it's a huge difference.