BINGO
New Member
Are you stupid or blind?
What I said about Crabtree He has rarely shown bright.
How in the hell is that shown absolutely nothing
Stop crapping up the conversation with BS.
"WR is a position where you should see an occasional spark even in really bad situations. Look at Calvin Johnson's college QBs".
Is this the reason why you're avoiding the question I had asked pertaining to the above comment?
Let's compare Crabtree's numbers to the of the wideouts from his draft class:Crabtree is now 42 games into his career. He has rarely shown bright.
DHB: 41career games; 99 Total Receptions; 1,465yds; 6 TDs
Maclin: 44career games; 189 reception; 2,596yds; 19TDs
P. Harvin: 45career games; 218 Total Receptions; 2,625yds; 17 TDs
H. Nicks: 42career games; 202 receptions; 3,034yds; 24TDs
K. Britt: 31career games; 101 Total receptions; 1,765yds; 15 TDs
Robiskie: 31career games; 39 Total receptions; 441yds, 3 TDs
Massaquoi: 45 career games, 101 receptions; 1,491yds, 4 TDs
M. Wallace:48 career games; 171 recs; 3,206yds; 24 TDs
J. Knox: 45 career games; 133 Ttl receptions; 2,214yds; 12 TDs
Lobsterbush:42career games; 175 Total recs; 2,240yds; 12 TDs
By the look of things, in terms of overall production, Lobsterbush is on par with the best players from his class. The biggest variable one can see from the #s above, is that receivers with probowl caliber QBs (BigBen, Cutler; Eli, Vick) are at a greater advantage. With the exception of Britt, it appears as if the only reason why Lobsterbush doesn't have "occasional spark" (whatever that means) is because of his QB. Put Massaquoi in Detroit and you'll see how good he plays. Put Crabtree in NY you'll see how good he plays. Put Nicks in SF, you'll see how his yearly #s would resemble Crabtree's.
Last edited by a moderator: