POLL Star Wars: final rankings (best)

[PatsFan2003]

RESULTS:
I weighed positive votes more for the top of the list and negative votes more for the bottom.

MOVIE POS NEG

1. Empire 27 1
2. New Hope 23 2
3. Rogue One 21 5
4. Return Jedi 20 2
5. Revenge Sith 13 6
6. Force Awakens 12 5
7. Rise Skywalker 10 4
8. Solo 5 10
9. Last Jedi 3 16
10. Attack Clones 0 16
11. Phantom Menace 1 17

Of course, there are other ways to break down the data. Rogue only got one more positive than Return, but three more negs. And Phantom got the most votes on the Neg column, but it did get one Positive.

On a personal note, I can’t believe Rise only got 4 negative votes... and 10!!! positives?

I think it salvaged the story after the Last Jedi and did a good job. I don't dislike the Last Jedi near as much as others.

 

[ElTexan]

I think it salvaged the story after the Last Jedi and did a good job. I don't dislike the Last Jedi near as much as others.

It created a new story. It didn’t salvage anything. It just did clunky blatant retconning.

 

[PatsFan2003]

It created a new story. It didn’t salvage anything. It just did clunky blatant retconning.

They still had to complete/correct some of the confusion of the Last Jedi, the Rey-Ben story, Leia, Luke etc.

 

[ElTexan]

They still had to complete/correct some of the confusion of the Last Jedi, the Rey-Ben story, Leia, Luke etc.

Making up stuff on the fly in flashbacks isn’t storytelling or fixing anything

 

[ElTexan]

RISE is soooooo bad.