Soon to be Hall of Famer - Eli Manning

[Robotech]

Actually not true now his brother Peyton has 9 one and dones

I looked it up. This is Eli's fourth one and done.

 

[sonnyblack65]

I looked it up. This is Eli's fourth one and done.

Is it my bad then I knew he has a winning record, and just assumed. I didn't think he made it to playoffs too often

 

[Great Dayne]

Gearing up for another post season run ... looking for #3..

Can anyone stop him?

Giant's had nothing to play for today and coasted to another victory...

Clicking at the right time of the year...

Where you at bro?? Sheli is an average at best QB that got lucky a couple times. No way will his old ass make the HOF. I expect him to retire next season.

 

[Robotech]

Where you at bro?? Sheli is an average at best QB that got lucky a couple times. No way will his old ass make the HOF. I expect him to retire next season.

I think he'll probably make it, but he is not deserving and he is not elite.

 

[Robotech]

Is it my bad then I knew he has a winning record, and just assumed. I didn't think he made it to playoffs too often

Yeah, 8-0 during the two Super Bowl years, and 0-4 the other four times the Giants made the playoffs.

 

[Great Dayne]

I think he'll probably make it, but he is not deserving and he is not elite.

IDK, his numbers would be inferior to every QB in the HOF. I guess the two SB runs mean everything if it does happen.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Yeah, 8-0 during the two Super Bowl years, and 0-4 the other four times the Giants made the playoffs.

So the ice Manning bros have 13 one and dones, Archie never made the playoffs, so can't see if it's in the DNA

 

[Dude]

Luck called in on the Giants SportsHoopla.

 

[sonnyblack65]

IDK, his numbers would be inferior to every QB in the HOF. I guess the two SB runs mean everything if it does happen.

Joe Namath begs to differ, different era sure

 

[Great Dayne]

Joe Namath begs to differ, different era sure

We can only compare how good each player is to the players in that era. Right now Eli is an average QB that had two great runs in the playoffs. Maybe Trent Dilfer gets in?

 

[sonnyblack65]

We can only compare how good each player is to the players in that era. Right now Eli is an average QB that had two great runs in the playoffs. Maybe Trent Dilfer gets in?

I know that but Eli is borderline because he has the TD's and Yards too. Dilfer has shit , except being at the right place with TB, nothing more

 

[darken65]

Eli's bust at the HOF:

 

[Great Dayne]

I know that but Eli is borderline because he has the TD's and Yards too. Dilfer has shit , except being at the right place with TB, nothing more

It's all about how the voters preceive a HOF caliber player, just like the MVP award which is going to Matty Ice now.

When I look at Eli he was never a top 5 QB and most the time was never a top ten QB. Too me I wouldn't put him in the HOF because he never was even close to the best at his position.

 

[Great Dayne]

Eli's bust at the HOF:

Holy shit, maybe he took some of that OBJ boat shit before the game.

 

[sonnyblack65]

It's all about how the voters preceive a HOF caliber player, just like the MVP award which is going to Matty Ice now.

When I look at Eli he was never a top 5 QB and most the time was never a top ten QB. Too me I wouldn't put him in the HOF because he never was even close to the best at his position.

He is borderline, your right

 

[Dude]

Mods: if you merge the two threads from this Giants fan it would be very funny.

 

[darken65]

Holy shit, maybe he took some of that OBJ boat shit before the game.

Actually he looks normal until his medication runs out. After that the retard starts to show.

 

[RobToxin]

Eli's bust at the HOF:

I am telling you people!

He used to play Corky in that tv show.....

 

[Robotech]

IDK, his numbers would be inferior to every QB in the HOF. I guess the two SB runs mean everything if it does happen.

He's got a rate+ stat of 98 for his career. 100 is average.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

#2 all time in interceptions. That should get him something?