Soon to be Hall of Famer - Eli Manning

[NEPatsfan]

Yep Steve Grogan

Just think if the Giants had Grogan instead of Eli how many SBs they would have won. Probably another 3 or 4.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

You realize there was no guarantee Lynch would have gotten in, and had been stopped in similar situation earlier, right?

It was a low risk call, which would have left them a down to still rush. Malcom Butler just made a "historically great" play.

No, there is nothing low risk about violating every unwritten rule about goal line football that ever existed

- Throw from the one yard line with the best power back in the NFL? Check
- Split best power back in the NFL out wide, removing even the threat of a run? Check
- Throw to the middle of the field from the one, where usually only bad things can happen? Check
- Throw to LITERALLY your worst WR on the roster on the biggest call of your season in the middle of the field? Double Check

 

[cerealboi]

If the Giants could get their hands on Fitzpatrick they'd be a real threat.

 

[sonnyblack65]

As soon as Lynch split wide, Bill said "Thanks Pete, you idiot"

Lynch was actually 1-5 I believe on 3rd and 1 and 4-1

You realize there was no guarantee Lynch would have gotten in, and had been stopped in similar situation earlier, right?

It was a low risk call, which would have left them a down to still rush. Malcom Butler just made a "historically great" play.

Lunch running the ball or the throw weren't the right calls. Thank goodness Wilson didn't roll out and run it into the endzone, that would have been the right call and prob ballgame. I still don't know have Pats give up 75 yards on 3 plays with little time left. That D seems to bend too much in the last minute of every SB, no lead is safe. They blew a 4 point lead late to NY and almost another 4 point lead to Seattle WTF

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Just think if the Giants had Grogan instead of Eli how many SBs they would have won. Probably another 3 or 4.

Definitely, nothing says winning football like 46-10

 

[NEPatsfan]

No, there is nothing low risk about violating every unwritten rule about goal line football that ever existed

- Throw from the one yard line with the best power back in the NFL? Check
- Split best power back in the NFL out wide, removing even the threat of a run? Check
- Throw to the middle of the field from the one, where usually only bad things can happen? Check
- Throw to LITERALLY your worst WR on the roster on the biggest call of your season in the middle of the field? Double Check

You don't actually watch football do you?

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

 

[sonnyblack65]

Just think if the Giants had Grogan instead of Eli how many SBs they would have won. Probably another 3 or 4.

Leaf or Russell would have sufficed

 

[NEPatsfan]

Lynch was actually 1-5 I believe on 3rd and 1 and 4-1



Lunch running the ball or the throw weren't the right calls. Thank goodness Wilson didn't roll out and run it into the endzone, that would have been the right call and prob ballgame. I still don't know have Pats give up 75 yards on 3 plays with little time left. That D seems to bend too much in the last minute of every SB, no lead is safe. They blew a 4 point lead late to NY and almost another 4 point lead to Seattle WTF

It's not what I would have called, and I agree a roll out. I'm just saying it was a low risk call that a rookie player made a play for the ages on.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

You don't actually watch football do you?

TYpical

 

[NEPatsfan]

TYpical

If you are so much more knowledgeable than the future HoF coach of the Seahawks why the fuck are you on here chatting and not leading a team to the SB?

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Lynch was actually 1-5 I believe on 3rd and 1 and 4-1



Lunch running the ball or the throw weren't the right calls. Thank goodness Wilson didn't roll out and run it into the endzone, that would have been the right call and prob ballgame. I still don't know have Pats give up 75 yards on 3 plays with little time left. That D seems to bend too much in the last minute of every SB, no lead is safe. They blew a 4 point lead late to NY and almost another 4 point lead to Seattle WTF

Not even presenting the deception of a run was the biggest error made there

Once he split out wide, 2 men in America said "Holy Shit"

Me and BB

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

If you are so much more knowledgeable than the future HoF coach of the Seahawks why the fuck are you on here chatting and not leading a team to the SB?

Everyone in America that doesnt live in the greater Boston area, has called the play call the worst in the history of big game American Sports

 

[NEPatsfan]

Not even presenting the deception of a run was the biggest error made there

Once he split out wide, 2 men in America said "Holy Shit"

Me and BB

Again, you don't actually watch football do you.


And no you didn't say that at the moment.

But I do love how butt hurt you are over the Pats winning another SB against a team you don't even cheer for.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Why do the intelligent QBs from Harvard or Stanford look like cavemen or Grizzly Adams?

 

[NEPatsfan]

Everyone in America that doesnt live in the greater Boston area, has called the play call the worst in the history of big game American Sports

"Everyone"?


Oh, and I don't live in the "Greater Boston area".

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Running Lynch from the one after a 7 yard run wasnt low risk

Throwing to the worst WR on the roster in the middle of the field was

Only here

 

[NEPatsfan]

Running Lynch from the one after a 7 yard run wasnt low risk

Throwing to the worst WR on the roster in the middle of the field was

Only here

Cry all you want, it was a low risk play that a rookie made a play for the ages on. You can certainly disagree with the play, but that doesn't then make it high risk simply because you don't agree.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Running Lynch from the one after a 7 yard run wasnt low risk

Throwing to the worst WR on the roster in the middle of the field was

Only here

With the bump play by Chancellor ODB would have been picked off, doesn't matter who the receiver was. The play by Cam was just as big as Butlers

 

[NWPATSFAN]

15 TD's and 2 picks in his 2 SB runs

He was pretty damn important

Are we still talking about Eli? 17 TDs to 8 INTs in his playoff career.
Eli Manning Stats | Pro-Football-Reference.com