Simply a bad year? Or these guys are FLUKES!!??

[BINGO]

Cam Newton, Matthew Stafford, Ndamukong Suh, Jason Babin... You make the call.

 

[wartyOne]

Newton - FLUKE, with a capital FLU.
Stafford - Bad year, but with his injury history he is dangerously close to FLUKE precipice.
Suh, not sure of his stats, but would lean toward bad season.
Babin's fluke year was last year. He's pretty much who he has been his whole career this season.

Also:
When do the Jets give up on both QB projects?
What the hell is going on in New England?
Do the Saints make the playoffs?
Is Denver the AFC's best team, or is Houston going to "not" flame out like they always do?
Finally, who are the real Packers/Bears/Vikings/Lions? That division should be renamed the NFC Jekyl and Hyde.

 

[Bemular]

Cam Newton, Matthew Stafford, Ndamukong Suh, Jason Babin... You make the call.

Psycho (Currently a Fluke)
Overrated (Currently a Fluke)
Overrated PunkAss Bitch (Currently a Fluke)
Real Deal (Currently having a Bad Season - along with the entire D'Line)

 

[CalamityX11]

Newton - Bad year but will raise to fluke status if he doesn't change himself as a leader/QB
Stafford - Bad year mixed with bad Offensive calls.... They're not adjusting and he's just slinging it.
Suh - Bad year(stat wise), still a Bad bad man.
Babin - Fluke

 

[Jikkle]

Newton- I'll call it a sophomore slump but if he doesn't get his head on straight he's heading into Vince Young territory (and no Warren Moon I'm not being a racist)

Stafford- In a way you could call this a sophomore slump as well but I think he's gunslinger style of play is going to lend to him being hot and cold. Also I do have concerns about his arm considering he's just not throwing it like he last season in terms of mechanics.

Suh- A tad overrated but DT isn't exactly a flashy position in the first place

Babin- Wide 9 product and I think offenses are just countering that defense better.

 

[Kinzu]

Cam Newton - He is just trying to do to much on his own right now. They need to focus more on the running game to help open things up for Cam and make things easier for him.

Stafford - He has no running game. Teams are taking away Megatron and giving 0 respect to the Lions ground game. Stafford is a gunslinger and a deep ball thrower, but he needs a good running game and play action. If the Rams are willing to trade Stephen Jackson the Lions should jump all over it.