RG3 Ranked 13 in Jaws QB Ratings

[elocomotive]

You just made my point. Thank you.

LOL! What is this guy talking about?

The only issue of color we should be talking about in the NFL today is your boy repping the orange and teal!

 

[skinsdad62]

quick question raptor , when can i upload an avatar ?

 

[RegentDenali]

Beware rankings based on prom king criteria.

 

[skinsdad62]

First off WOW guys glad to see this board hopping. Havent seen this action since I came to SportsHoopla.

On RG3, if healthy he has potential to be a top 3 in the NFL. Has all the tools and just needs to develop and be smarter especially when running.

ANd Fuck ESPN and Jaws anyways

now you can see why we were devastated when espn went south and how happy we are to be here

 

[Mitziman]

I like College Football, but I LOVE the NFL. And at the end of the day, we don't have to worry about "rankings" to sort things out.

Hail to you my brothers and sisters, it's good to be a Redskins fan!

 

[SaintGibbs]

Sorry guys, I have a hard time giving a shit what Jaws thinks. He could rank RGIII #1 or #32, and it wouldn't change my view of that gas-bag.

 

[SaintGibbs]

gas-bag = Jaws, not RGIII...just wanted to make sure that was clarified!

 

[martinez]

First off WOW guys glad to see this board hopping. Havent seen this action since I came to SportsHoopla.

On RG3, if healthy he has potential to be a top 3 in the NFL. Has all the tools and just needs to develop and be smarter especially when running.

ANd Fuck ESPN and Jaws anyways

slowest month of the year for us espn posters lol

 

[apachef4]

quick question raptor , when can i upload an avatar ?

You should be able to do that as soon as you sign up. Click on "User CP" at the top of the page, then click on "Edit Avatar".

 

[RoboticDreams]

Alex Smith? You could at least make a case for some of the other guys (marginal in Schaub's case). However - Smith has been a journeyman at best during his career. He had a few moments a few seasons ago but overall there is no way that he should be anywhere near the top 10.

Journeymen travel, he has been on one team until now.

 

[Skin'EmAll]

Going in to work late today...Just finished looking at ESPN first take.

Steven Smith, Herm Edwards, and Skip Bayless all seemed to agree 13 was too low.

The conversation included taking a franchise QB, only Rogers, Brady, Brees both Mannings, and Ryan were considered ahead of RGIII.(S.Smith)

they had him in the 7-10 range.
They also agreed Luck, Wilson and Caepernick(i know i butchered his name) did not merit a better ranking at this point in their careers.

 

[Warpath]

Never thought I'd agree with those idiots over Jaws, but they are right.

 

[elocomotive]

Just a note - I saw Jaws talk about RG3 and his QB rankings last night. He must be doing a spot on each QB each day and I just happened to see it.

He said during his comments that he almost never rates a 2nd year player this high.

I agree with most of you RG3 is in the top 10 (hell I'd put up right around #4 or #5 to be honest) if healthy, but I thought the comments from Jaws provided a little context as to his #13 ranking. Basically, he doesn't ever put rookies/2nd year guys in the top 10 from the sound of it.

 

[Warpath]

Just a note - I saw Jaws talk about RG3 and his QB rankings last night. He must be doing a spot on each QB each day and I just happened to see it.

He said during his comments that he almost never rates a 2nd year player this high.

I agree with most of you RG3 is in the top 10 (hell I'd put up right around #4 or #5 to be honest) if healthy, but I thought the comments from Jaws provided a little context as to his #13 ranking. Basically, he doesn't ever put rookies/2nd year guys in the top 10 from the sound of it.

that logic is fine until you take into account that he'll be ranking two 2nd year quarterbacks ahead of RG3.

 

[j_y19]

He doesn't? Then how does he explain Wilson, Luck, and knapernick all rated higher than rg3? I also saw him explaining. He dinged RG3 for his injury, but more for the type of offense we run. Bottom line is that he doesn't like the pistol formation, he doesn't like the read option, he doesn't like running qbs, and most of all, he doesn't like the redskins. If you look at his history of commenting on the skins, he is way more negative than positive, and is wrong more than he is right.

I hope he picks us to finish in the cellar so we can prove him wrong again. I think he must be Justus.....

 

[SoCalWizFan]

Journeymen travel, he has been on one team until now.

Fair enough - perhaps journeyman was not the right term. However - in no way should anyone rank A. Smith anywhere near the top 10 NFL QBs at this pt. Like I said - most of his career he was as bad or worse than Sanchez & only had relatively recent success on a team that was loaded.

He is not bad, but I can think of lots of other QBs I would rather have on my team.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

Just a note - I saw Jaws talk about RG3 and his QB rankings last night. He must be doing a spot on each QB each day and I just happened to see it.

He said during his comments that he almost never rates a 2nd year player this high.

I agree with most of you RG3 is in the top 10 (hell I'd put up right around #4 or #5 to be honest) if healthy, but I thought the comments from Jaws provided a little context as to his #13 ranking. Basically, he doesn't ever put rookies/2nd year guys in the top 10 from the sound of it.

I saw his review today of Wilson who he ranked one spot higher. Without specifically mentioning him he made numerous references to RG3. I honestly believe that Jaws dislikes RG3 & the Skins. Oh well - his problem.

 

[skinsdad62]

it keeps saying upload failed

 

[skinsdad62]

You should be able to do that as soon as you sign up. Click on "User CP" at the top of the page, then click on "Edit Avatar".

it keeps saying upload failed over and over

 

[apachef4]

it keeps saying upload failed over and over

I'm not sure what the issue is then, skinsdad. Maybe you should try PMing one of the mods to see if they can help you out. Sorry you're having an issue with it.