Wild Turkey
Sarcasm: Just one of my many services.
Until you're the head coach I don't think the players can be considered your recruiting classes. You think Alabama has the exact same class if Kirby Smart is the head coach and Saban is not in the picture at all? And if people think it's the same being the hunted as opposed to the hunter they don't know as much about football as they think. Total different mindset and Auburn has never done well in the "target on your back" role.
You also never know what leaves with them when players leave, including at Alabama. Anyone remember when Alabama won the 199 SEC championship and only lost Shaun Alexander and Chris Samuels. Started season #3 and finished 3-8! Now, there were other issues like internal coach issues and Dubose starting to earn his nickname of Coach "Dumbass" but leadership is hard to replace. Losing your top lineman,top back, teams seeing scheme for the second time around while having a target on your back is a little different than what they faced this year.
You are missing the point the players were recruited for Malzah's system so he didn't have to reinvent the wheel. They count as his same as Jimbo's guys are his not Bobby's.