No. The questions is do you want 30+ homers a .355 OBP and an average around .260, or do you want about half the power production, an average around .285 and a .375 OBP. That's the trade off.
Call for Ian with an uppercut swing
you seemed to think that getting rid of the uppercut is somehow going to drastically affect his overall numbers by lowering them. if he levels out his swing, hits .285-295, hits 23-26 homers, increases his double production by 8-12 and doubles the number of triples he hits, he is still going to score a bunch of runs
Did you follow this team in the Spring of 2010? The talk about Ian was he was working on a more level swing. He took that into the season and those were the numbers. You are guessing something that has already been proven not to be true.