WiggyRuss
Well-Known Member
Obviously Rutschman and Henderson have proved themselves already at the major league level--- I would rate them - along with the prospects like this:
1. Rutschman- MVP level team leader and catcher
2. Holiday- one of the best prospects in years
3. Henderson- already an All Star level 3B- they have him playing SS this year--- probably to clear room for Mayo soon- or for Westburg to play a little 3B
4. Mayo- only 22- hes a third basemen- but hes a consensus top 30 prospect
5. Basallo- only 19- but hes looked reeally good- consensus he is ranked higher than Mayo - a top 20 guy almost everywhere- but hes still at least 2 years away-- hes listed as C/1B but he prob. ends up being mostly 1B- will eventually replace Mountcastle
6. Cowser- great outfield prospect- very highly rated- 24--- he should be up soon but they just dnt have a spot for him since the vets Mullins and Santander are both very solid above average guys.
7. Bradfield- proto-type CF- 22- he is their CF of the future
8. Kjersted--- in some systems he would be #1--- here (after Henderson and Rutscham who are obv. not rooks anymore) he is at best 6....great corner outfield prospect- he is 25 and I think is a prime trade candidate.
9. Westburg- absolutely a starting level 2B -- he has had a solid start to the season
10. Kyle Stowers- another proto-type corner outfielder with power
Norby and Beavers are very solid too- NOrby an undersized infield-- a little Pedroia like- and Beavers another corner big bodied corner outfielder.
I think Kjersted eventually gets dealt. I think Westburg or Norby could get dealt.....
2 years down the line I think they look like:
C- Rutschman
1B- Basallo
2B- Holiday
3B- Mayo
SS- Holiday
CF- Bradfield
LF- Cowser
RF- still Santander? Mullins? Stowers or Beavers?
Not all prospects work out- but I have to say---- I would count on just about all of those guys working out- they all have great profiles. I think WEstburg and Kjersted work out too--- I think Norby works out.....Stowers and Beavers have a little bit more hit or miss too them.
who do you sign and who do you trade?
I have never seen a system like this. The next closest was the young Cubs that really fell apart a lot quicker than people thought they would (Bryant, Rizzo, Schwarber, Contreras, Addison Russell (who didnt pan out), Heyward (who they aquired obv.), Happ)
Indians had similar but they had more veterans sprinkled in and it wasnt all at the same exact time --- Belle, Manny, Thome, Baerga, Vizquel, Lofton--- there was more seperation with Belle and say Manny. Though they were all on the team together for a while.
1. Rutschman- MVP level team leader and catcher
2. Holiday- one of the best prospects in years
3. Henderson- already an All Star level 3B- they have him playing SS this year--- probably to clear room for Mayo soon- or for Westburg to play a little 3B
4. Mayo- only 22- hes a third basemen- but hes a consensus top 30 prospect
5. Basallo- only 19- but hes looked reeally good- consensus he is ranked higher than Mayo - a top 20 guy almost everywhere- but hes still at least 2 years away-- hes listed as C/1B but he prob. ends up being mostly 1B- will eventually replace Mountcastle
6. Cowser- great outfield prospect- very highly rated- 24--- he should be up soon but they just dnt have a spot for him since the vets Mullins and Santander are both very solid above average guys.
7. Bradfield- proto-type CF- 22- he is their CF of the future
8. Kjersted--- in some systems he would be #1--- here (after Henderson and Rutscham who are obv. not rooks anymore) he is at best 6....great corner outfield prospect- he is 25 and I think is a prime trade candidate.
9. Westburg- absolutely a starting level 2B -- he has had a solid start to the season
10. Kyle Stowers- another proto-type corner outfielder with power
Norby and Beavers are very solid too- NOrby an undersized infield-- a little Pedroia like- and Beavers another corner big bodied corner outfielder.
I think Kjersted eventually gets dealt. I think Westburg or Norby could get dealt.....
2 years down the line I think they look like:
C- Rutschman
1B- Basallo
2B- Holiday
3B- Mayo
SS- Holiday
CF- Bradfield
LF- Cowser
RF- still Santander? Mullins? Stowers or Beavers?
Not all prospects work out- but I have to say---- I would count on just about all of those guys working out- they all have great profiles. I think WEstburg and Kjersted work out too--- I think Norby works out.....Stowers and Beavers have a little bit more hit or miss too them.
who do you sign and who do you trade?
I have never seen a system like this. The next closest was the young Cubs that really fell apart a lot quicker than people thought they would (Bryant, Rizzo, Schwarber, Contreras, Addison Russell (who didnt pan out), Heyward (who they aquired obv.), Happ)
Indians had similar but they had more veterans sprinkled in and it wasnt all at the same exact time --- Belle, Manny, Thome, Baerga, Vizquel, Lofton--- there was more seperation with Belle and say Manny. Though they were all on the team together for a while.