My top 25 QBs of all time

[Shanemansj13]

I didn't read it, but I was impressed with your effort. Not many go into the details around here and even if you were looking at an inconsequential number you still looked at it thoroughly and I like that.

Again, I can backup my statements, you can't. LOL You are a joke. Hard to take anything you post as being logical

 

[Shanemansj13]

LOL..boy, some opinions do stink worse than others

Yep @eaglesnut continues to prove his opinion is shit. Sticking up for Eli...he is getting desperate in here, saying stupid shit like Skip Bayless

 

[eaglesnut]

Again, I can backup my statements, you can't. LOL You are a joke. Hard to take anything you post as being logical

QB rating isn't worth the bandwidth. If you want to get smart instead, then I could listen.

Again, your work was probably enjoyed by someone and it was well done. Don't be upset it didn't land where you intended.

 

[rmilia1]

Yep @eaglesnut continues to prove his opinion is shit. Sticking up for Eli...he is getting desperate in here, saying stupid shit like Skip Bayless

I'm pretty sure @PDay8810 was referring to my ranking of Aikman. We've had recent discussions on our opinions . They are different ( shocking I know lol )

 

[eaglesnut]

Yep @eaglesnut continues to prove his opinion is shit. Sticking up for Eli...he is getting desperate in here, saying stupid shit like Skip Bayless

I've read that skip likes QBR as much as you like QB rating. Two mindless peas in a pod.

 

[PDay8810]

I'm pretty sure @PDay8810 was referring to my ranking of Aikman. We've had recent discussions on our opinions . They are different ( shocking I know lol )

I expected your Aikman ranking....surprised you even had him on the list

I think your ranking pretty much stinks and reflects pure homer with Ryan at 18 best all time. Tarkington at 15 is a joke and I watched him play in NY & Minnesota. You might be the only person who would put McNabb ahead of Bradshaw and Aikman. You show no regard to the era's in which these guys played played.

BUT HEY....least you took the opportunity....Good for You! LOL

 

[PDay8810]

and...you're right. Eaglenut is the biggest ass clown homer on this forum and isn't worth the time

 

[Shanemansj13]

I've read that skip likes QBR as much as you like QB rating. Two mindless peas in a pod.

meh you prove time and time again your opinion is shit. At least you are consistent lolz

 

[CaptainStubing]

Carson wentz #1

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I will never understand those who have BOTH Aaron Rodgers in their top 10 AND Brady as the goat.

I don’t have a problem with either. But how can you have both. Brady is not the best statistically. He is just a WINNER!!!

Rogers is not a winner.

Me, personally I don’t have Rodgers in my top 10 or Brady as my best.

 

[rmilia1]

I expected your Aikman ranking....surprised you even had him on the list

I think your ranking pretty much stinks and reflects pure homer with Ryan at 18 best all time. Tarkington at 15 is a joke and I watched him play in NY & Minnesota. You might be the only person who would put McNabb ahead of Bradshaw and Aikman. You show no regard to the era's in which these guys played played.

BUT HEY....least you took the opportunity....Good for You! LOL

Just pure numbers and results based rankings . There are guys on there I wouldn't have ranked at all if I didn't use criteria ( McNabb, Eli, Aikman, Esiason ,) guys who id have higher without criteria ( Marino ) and guys who id have lower ( Rodgers , Warner )

 

[eaglesnut]

and...you're right. Eaglenut is the biggest ass clown homer on this forum and isn't worth the time

So being very very correct about the Super Bowl winning Eagles makes me a homer. Interesting take by you. If you were smarter you'd know it just makes me accurate.

For some contrast, remember that Bears fan that ran away from his hilarious prediction thread? He homered so hard he got it wrong. Now that is a homer.

Getting it right is just called getting it right. That's me.

Doug Pederson is a tremendous coach. Knowing that doesn't make me a homer, but not knowing that does make you an ass clown dumbass.

 

[eaglesnut]

meh you prove time and time again your opinion is shit. At least you are consistent lolz

You certainly prove you can't handle them. Stay triggered by the information I show you.

 

[Tapey]

Matt Ryan isnt a top 25 qb of all time.
The rest of the list is cool tho

 

[PDay8810]

very very correct about

I'm very very correct about the Cowboys sweeping the Eagles last year.

 

[jarntt]

Because I gave equal weight to MVPs as I did Super Bowls . A QB wins a SB every year , a QB does not win a MVP every year and ( imo ) winning a MVP in a better indicator of actual elite individual performance

and plus it helps Ryan more...

 

[jarntt]

Eli is the definition of average. But there's not a QB w/ 110+ wins, 55,000+ yards, 350+ TD's & 2 S.B. mvp's that's been left outta the HOF.

Not yet

 

[PDay8810]

Just pure numbers and results based rankings . There are guys on there I wouldn't have ranked at all if I didn't use criteria ( McNabb, Eli, Aikman, Esiason ,) guys who id have higher without criteria ( Marino ) and guys who id have lower ( Rodgers , Warner )

it's just your opinion and why opinions are like ass holes...some stink more than others.
Congrats!

 

[rmilia1]

and plus it helps Ryan more...

Nah . MVP is just a tougher award to win than a SB. Joe Flacco, Trent Dilfer , Brad Johnson etc have SBs. Pretty much any halfway competent QB can win one if the roster around them is great . The top top guys ( Brady, Montana , Manning ) win with less than loaded rosters though . That's what really separates them

 

[rmilia1]

it's just your opinion and why opinions are like ass holes...some stink more than others.
Congrats!

Numbers and results aren't my opinion. They're called facts . Which ones I used as criteria ( yards , TDs, wins, SBs and MVPs ) are pretty much the same ones the HoF uses though I did look at advanced stats a bit even though you can't really use them too much as they've only recently become trendy .

What criteria would you use ? I'm open to further suggestions