VikingFan2k2
Well-Known Member
Where does Joe Mauer set on the career most games caught list?
After you look up the answer, acknowledge this: His HOF qualification determination was driven by the fact that he was a 'catcher'. This is just one more indication of the continuing eroding of the HOF voting think tank.
Even when he was a full-time catcher, he almost always DHed on day games after night games.
I didn't think he would get in on the first ballot and I can see an argument that he shouldn't have. The last 5 years of his career he was an average 1st Baseman with little power.
He takes a lot of heat locally because he was given such a massive contract that he never lived up to, because concussions drove him out from behind the plate. He also was not the most engaging personality. Just a boring guy and not the team leader that he should have been at that rate of pay.
It also doesn't help that he was never on a roster that won even a single playoff game.
But, it's not his fault that the Twins owners decided that was going to be their only big contract that they gave out and virtually ignored signing expensive pitchers. Opting for mid level cast aways like Phil Hughes and Ricky Nolasco.
The argument for him is that he did what hadn't been done in the AL ever. Win a batting title as a catcher and he did it 3 times. Only Posey and two other guys back in the 1930s were able to do it in the NL.
I could go either way with it, but I don't see it as a joke that he got in.