MLB One Player Per Team Draft : CHAT

[Nosferatu]

hey EHB, do you want to trade me Morgan?? I will give you the current pick and my next pick for morgan and your 6th rounder!!!

LOLZZZZ your 5th round pick is only 4 picks ahead of his 6th round pick.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

LOLZZZZ your 5th round pick is only 4 picks ahead of his 6th round pick.

we could negotiate if needed... But don't ruin the trade before EHB can get it!!! he also has the CURRENT pick if he takes it, so he could take WHOEVER He wants other than Morgan!!!

 

[Gold Rush 86]

I skipped over Cy Young cuz I thought we couldn't draft him cuz they weren't called the Boston Red Sox back then.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Trade is off... Nos deflated my balls!!!

 

[UK Cowboy]

I skipped over Cy Young cuz I thought we couldn't draft him cuz they weren't called the Boston Red Sox back then.

Cy Young isn't eligible either

 

[UK Cowboy]

Nos knew he was #2 on my list, pretty sure Christy is good to go.

No he isn't, neither is Mathewson or Young

 

[UK Cowboy]

So I guess as long as the franchise is still existing we can draft from them, when Smitty took Grove I figured that's what we were doing.

Not unless we start the draft over, which is fine. Can't take pitchers in the 3rd round that several guys passed over because they are ineligible

 

[Nosferatu]

Cy Young isn't eligible either

Yes he is, the Red Sox changed their name from the Americans for the 1908 season, same city, same team just a name change.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Yes he is, the Red Sox changed their name from the Americans for the 1908 season, same city, same team just a name change.

That's fine, I caught all the BS last draft and now we're taking guys like Grove that were clearly ineligible and Young who played for the Americans. You should let Milk keep Mathewson, at least there is a Giants. Do it however, but this is my last draft if we can't take 5 minutes to clearly outline the rules then stick to them

 

[Nosferatu]

Bad timing to be sure but I gotta go into the office ill be back ASAP.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Bad timing to be sure but I gotta go into the office ill be back ASAP.

Just leave it the way it is, I don't give a squirt

 

[Ritzarmy]

For the record I asked earlier if Nos wanted to post all the teams that are eligible with their alternative team names. He said no if you have a question just ask. I asked him if I could take Spahn as a brave and he said yes. Next time you guys have questions please PM or text him your questions before you make a decision so we don't get to the 3rd round with misunderstandings. I'm sorry some guys got confused on the rules. I tried to eliminate this problem a long time ago but....

 

[MilkSpiller22]

now I am confused again!!! why was Warren spahn good for the braves, but Christy Mathewson was not good for the giants??

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I vote on restarting this draft... we could do it fast... But I think there is so much confusement going on right now that if we keep on going like this we are going to start fighting again... And as recovering quitter, I don't want to be the one who says or does something they will regret...

 

[Ritzarmy]

now I am confused again!!! why was Warren spahn good for the braves, but Christy Mathewson was not good for the giants??

Ask nos. I asked him before I drafted him and if Spahn isn't illegible then we have a problem because I was told he was. I feel if you can link a team to a current major league team then the players should be allowed. Now if that team doesn't exist anymore then the player shouldn't be allowed. Just my opinion. We wait on nos who is OTC and needs to explain what's going on.

 

[UK Cowboy]

I vote on restarting this draft... we could do it fast... But I think there is so much confusement going on right now that if we keep on going like this we are going to start fighting again... And as recovering quitter, I don't want to be the one who says or does something they will regret...

Agreed on a restart, or, give Milk back Christy, or, cut all ineligible players and repick for them

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Ask nos. I asked him before I drafted him and if Spahn isn't illegible then we have a problem because I was told he was. I feel if you can link a team to a current major league team then the players should be allowed. Now if that team doesn't exist anymore then the player shouldn't be allowed. Just my opinion. We wait on nos who is OTC and needs to explain what's going on.

just saying now, carl Hubbell was taken... he is the same as Christy Mathewson... and the same as spahn... and everyone passed on cy young because they thought he was illegible... this is getting dirty...

 

[Ritzarmy]

just saying now, carl Hubbell was taken... he is the same as Christy Mathewson... and the same as spahn... and everyone passed on cy young because they thought he was illegible... this is getting dirty...

I agree. Well nos has been texted about this. No more picks will be made because he is OTC. So hopefully he responds soon.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Simple solution to me. Restart, all players are eligible if they played 5 years with one team, only rule is you can't take 2 players from the same team. Simple. Whatever city Walter Johnson played for is his city

 

[UK Cowboy]

i do think we should only be drafting the 30 current franchises...

Bump