MLB Dynasty Draft

[Johnnydollaz89]

Sorry about that. Was out. Thought my list may still be used. Will pick now

 

[Johnnydollaz89]

Can I have Franco as a set up man?!

 

[Nosferatu]

Can I have Franco as a set up man?!

Would you call a guy with 424 career saves a set up man?

 

[Nosferatu]

I hate that it seems i'm being an ass about this but there are middle relievers and set up guys out there, you just gotta search for them.

 

[Nosferatu]

Johnny has to pick someone other than Franco and Clayton is OTC...

 

[UK Cowboy]

I hate that it seems i'm being an ass about this but there are middle relievers and set up guys out there, you just gotta search for them.

I don't think you're being an ass, it's a pretty tough judgement call on some guys. Mitch Williams, KRod, Brad Lidge, John Wetteland. Guys who spent at least part of their careers as premier set up men before becoming closers. I would rank all those guys as Closers, but I get the argument

 

[Ritzarmy]

21.1 - Johnny : OTC
21.2 - 500 : Tom Gordon - RP
21.3 - Clayton : OTC-11:30
21.4 - Smitty : 11:30-12
21.5 - Nos : 12-12:30
21.6 - Nava : 12:30-1
21.7 - Ritz : 1-1:30
21.8 - UK : 1:30-2

22.1 - UK : 2-2:30
22.2 - Ritz : 2:30-3
22.3 - Nava : 3-3:30
22.4 - Nos : 3:30-4
22.5 - Smitty : 4-4:30
22.6 - Clayton : 4:30-5
22.7 - 500 : 5-5:30
22.8 - Johnny : 5:30-6

 

[Clayton]

Mid relievers never stick on teams, though, and the good ones have a whole lot of saves because they get moved there or they get moved to the starting rotation because they are too good to keep in the middle. Im having a hard time finding 1 let alone 4

 

[UK Cowboy]

Mid relievers never stick on teams, though, and the good ones have a whole lot of saves because they get moved there or they get moved to the starting rotation because they are too good to keep in the middle. Im having a hard time finding 1 let alone 4

Eric O'Flaherty
Jonny Vetters
Jared Burton
Darren O'Day
Joaquin Benoit
Joel Peralta
Ryan Cook
David Robertson
Drew Soren
Tyler Clippard
Ernesto Frieri
David Hernandez
Jack McGee
Antonio Bastardo

 

[Clayton]

Eric O'Flaherty
Jonny Vetters
Jared Burton
Darren O'Day
Joaquin Benoit
Joel Peralta
Ryan Cook
David Robertson
Drew Soren
Tyler Clippard
Ernesto Frieri
David Hernandez
Jack McGee
Antonio Bastardo

You have to admit that you're looking at a freefall from the talent level of HOF players and legends that are teams are filled with.

 

[Johnnydollaz89]

Mid relievers never stick on teams, though, and the good ones have a whole lot of saves because they get moved there or they get moved to the starting rotation because they are too good to keep in the middle. Im having a hard time finding 1 let alone 4

Same here.

 

[Johnnydollaz89]

Changed Franco to left handed specialist formerly of the Mets, Pedro Feliciano

 

[Ritzarmy]

Clayton, Smitty and nos are OTC

 

[Clayton]

Im OTC?

 

[UK Cowboy]

You have to admit that you're looking at a freefall from the talent level of HOF players and legends that are teams are filled with.

Oh, there's no doubt about that. But it's a rule, and it's too late to change it. I know I'd want to go back and drop the 3 set up guys I drafted and add Sutter, Eck, and Chapman lol

 

[Ritzarmy]

Clayton, Smitty and nos are OTC

Yes
21.1 - Johnny : OTC
21.2 - 500 : Tom Gordon - RP
21.3 - Clayton : OTC-11:30
21.4 - Smitty : 11:30-12
21.5 - Nos : 12-12:30
21.6 - Nava : 12:30-1
21.7 - Ritz : 1-1:30
21.8 - UK : 1:30-2

22.1 - UK : 2-2:30
22.2 - Ritz : 2:30-3
22.3 - Nava : 3-3:30
22.4 - Nos : 3:30-4
22.5 - Smitty : 4-4:30
22.6 - Clayton : 4:30-5
22.7 - 500 : 5-5:30
22.8 - Johnny : 5:30-6

 

[Clayton]

Is O'Flaherty not a legal pick?

 

[Ritzarmy]

Is O'Flaherty not a legal pick?

Sorry I didn't see that you picked and Nos didn't update the full draft thread. No idea about O'Flaherty Nos has vetoed everyone. LOL

 

[broncosmitty]

Tekulve, hopefully my RH setup man, did have a couple 31 save seasons. But he pitched in a crazy amount of games to do it. (91 and 94 respectively). I had eyeballed Orosco three or four rounds ago. Even thought I PMd Nos about his position eligibility. Thought it was weird he didn't return my message with an answer. And then picked him. Then I realized I sent that PM to myself. . Kind of weird that's even an option.

 

[Ritzarmy]

I picked Dick "The Monster" Radatz - RP red socks best relief pitcher ever.