Melky by the numbers

[msgkings322]

Is he really worth it?

Half-full, half-empty: Melky Cabrera - SweetSpot Blog - ESPN

 

[MarcoPolo]

Is he really worth it?

No.

 

[Mays-Fan]

No.

So who is? Please provide a specific alternative.

 

[jeep99tj]

So who is? Please provide a specific alternative.

If the Giants don't make a deal for a left fielder we could be stuck with a Perez/Blanco platoon. Good defense but the offense would suffer.

 

[MarcoPolo]

So who is? Please provide a specific alternative.

There are two problems with Melky : long contract, and lotsa money per year. I'm not going to propose anybody, as it's a choice between really bad decision, and dumpster dive.

 

[calsnowskier]

There are two problems with Melky : long contract, and lotsa money per year. I'm not going to propose anybody, as it's a choice between really bad decision, and dumpster dive.

And it would cost the #19 pick.

And he has a bad history with this exact clubhouse.

And STEROIDS!!!


That's 5 problems.

 

[raptorlife4]

Melky had a very good year last year and was clutch

Having said that I wouldn't give him the years and money he wants.

But cmon guys sign him so we can get the pick please

 

[tzill]

Melky had a very good year last year and was clutch

Having said that I wouldn't give him the years and money he wants.

But cmon guys sign him so we can get the pick please

you wouldn't get our pick, you'd get a sandwich pick no matter who signs him.