POLL Is Aaron Rodgers a TOP 20 quarterback all-time?

[knowyourenemy]

Anyone picking McNabb over Rodgers is doing something wrong...

Nobody did that.

 

[PatsFan2003]

Nobody did that.

LOL. Mcnabb was cited as having a better playoff record than Rodgers so I just had to nip even the thought of that in the bud before people got carried away.

(McNabb was a decent QB but I don't think he'll ever sniff the HOF)

 

[PatsFan2003]

To give Elway his due, he and the Broncos played against some very good NFC teams.. Dallas, SF, Giants and Redskins..

 

[knowyourenemy]

LOL. Mcnabb was cited as having a better playoff record than Rodgers

That’s because McNabb does, in fact, have a higher playoff winning percentage than Rodgers.

 

[PatsFan2003]

That’s because McNabb does, in fact, have a higher playoff winning percentage than Rodgers.

I know.. And Jim Plunkett has more Superbowl wins than Rodgers too..

 

[knowyourenemy]

I know.. And Jim Plunkett has more Superbowl wins than Rodgers too..

It would be nice if Rodgers could at least make it to another one. Then maybe his fanboys would have another leg to stand on.

 

[Wamu]

With his pitiful performance in the NFC Championship Game yesterday, he fell to 10-8 all-time in the playoffs. That’s a lower playoff winning percentage than Donovan McNabb.

So, what say you?

If this has already been mentioned my bad. So Rodgers is 10-8 all time in the playoffs with one ring. You don't think he's a top 20 QB right?

Then is Brett Favre a top 20 all time QB with one ring & a 13-11 all time playoff record? What about Marino? He was 8-10 in the playoffs. Peyton Manning? He was 14-13.

 

[knowyourenemy]

If this has already been mentioned my bad. So Rodgers is 10-8 all time in the playoffs with one ring. You don't think he's a top 20 QB right?

Then is Brett Favre a top 20 all time QB with one ring & a 13-11 all time playoff record? What about Marino? He was 8-10 in the playoffs. Peyton Manning? He was 14-13.

Manning and Favre both have 140+ more touchdowns and 25,000 more yards. Marino played in a different era but also has way more touchdowns and yards as of right now.

As much as Peyton was labeled a choker, he appeared in 4 Super Bowls and went 2-2. Favre went to 2. Rodgers has only gone to 1. For being as talented as everyone says, this guy has somehow only managed to put together one Super Bowl run. It’s baffling...

 

[GNG]

It's unanimous, Rodgers is a top 20 QB...

 

[PatsFan2003]

It would be nice if Rodgers could at least make it to another one. Then maybe his fanboys would have another leg to stand on.

He used to be in the conversation as one of the best ever. And he still might be but not with as much conviction as before.

 

[Wamu]

Manning and Favre both have 140+ more touchdowns and 25,000 more yards. Marino played in a different era but also has way more touchdowns and yards as of right now.

As much as Peyton was labeled a choker, he appeared in 4 Super Bowls and went 2-2. Favre went to 2. Rodgers has only gone to 1. For being as talented as everyone says, this guy has somehow only managed to put together one Super Bowl run. It’s baffling...

Marino, Favre & Manning didn't sit behind another QB for 3 full season either. As far as the yards & TD's: Marino- 242 games played / 240 starts. Favre- 302 games played / 298 starts. Manning- 266 games played / 265 starts. Rodgers- 181 games played / 174 starts.

Marino started 66 more games
Favre started 124 more games
Manning started 91 more games


Passing yards per game

Marino- 253.6
Favre- 237.9
Manning- 270.5
Rodgers- 259.4

Rating

Marino- 86.4
Favre- 86.0
Manning- 96.5
Rodgers- 102.4

 

[GNG]

Manning and Favre both have 140+ more touchdowns and 25,000 more yards. Marino played in a different era but also has way more touchdowns and yards as of right now.

As much as Peyton was labeled a choker, he appeared in 4 Super Bowls and went 2-2. Favre went to 2. Rodgers has only gone to 1. For being as talented as everyone says, this guy has somehow only managed to put together one Super Bowl run. It’s baffling...

Your argument is very weak. I suggest you engage your brain before you comment anymore.

 

[GNG]

I know.. And Jim Plunkett has more Superbowl wins than Rodgers too..

So you think Plunkett is a top 20 QB. Most folks here would disagree with you.

 

[The Derski]

It's unanimous, Rodgers is a top 20 QB...

Yeah, the poll really backfired on the OP.

 

[Black Manta]

Yes! If he gets one more Superbowl Championship, move him into the top 15. At best I have him at 18 as of now.

 

[PatsFan2003]

So you think Plunkett is a top 20 QB. Most folks here would disagree with you.

Not at all. Just pointing out how his "stats" are better than Rodgers and McNabb if you look at SB wins..

 

[Wamu]

Not at all. Just pointing out how his "stats" are better than Rodgers and McNabb if you look at SB wins..

I like your thinking. Ignore Plunkett's 72-72 regular season record & his TD to int ratio (164 to 198). The rings is what matter. It'll drive some people crazy when Eli gets into the HOF. 2 rings & an 8-4 playoff record. By the way. What team did he beat to get his 2 rings?


I'm outta here!

 

[sonnyblack65]

It's unanimous, Rodgers is a top 20 QB...

Might want to look up the word unanimous

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Definitely

 

[GNG]

Not at all. Just pointing out how his "stats" are better than Rodgers and McNabb if you look at SB wins..

You need to look at the whole picture and not just the part you want to. Your comment is laughable.