POLL Is Aaron Rodgers a TOP 20 quarterback all-time?

[SteelersPride]

I guess Cobb and Nelson were shitty WRs.

Aaron made them.

 

[megalodon30]

Aaron made them.

Considering what they've accomplished outside of GB, I'd have to agree.

 

[SteelersPride]

Considering what they've accomplished outside of GB, I'd have to agree.

they were a little over the hill and injured,

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Aaron made them.

Of course. They didn't have any talent.

 

[knowyourenemy]

I would think so, but he looks like he don't want to be out there anymore....Maybe he is unhappy with FO for not getting more playmakers or coaching etc....But he don't look like he has any fire in him to me....

I got that sense, too. Did he even try to recover that fumble on the botched snap? Seems like he doesn’t care.

 

[sonnyblack65]

I got that sense, too. Did he even try to recover that fumble on the botched snap? Seems like he doesn’t care.

When you have cool Superman or Wrestling signature celebrations after a TD like Cam or AR, no need too

 

[Rex Racer]

Rodger's is top 20 and I'll just leave it at that.

No.

 

[Rex Racer]

I have him 6th all time right now

Drugs are bad for you.

 

[Rex Racer]

LOL, love the salt from the Elway haters. 5 SBs are better than 99.9% of QBs that have ever played in the NFL. Only some guy name Bardy has started more Super Bowls.

Keep hating, weirdos.

Go Broncos!

Elway is one of thee most overrated Dooshbags to ever play QB in the NFL and you're not old enough to have watched him suck in big games.

Pipe down and go sit in the corner.

 

[kburjr]

No.

C'mon, man, you promised you'd learn something about football before you posted here again.

 

[TheRangerDude]

I think a lot of people forget, he started out the same or maybe even better than Mahomie and played at that level for a while. I think he may have got the starter position two years later than Maholmes.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

pretty darn good list....I might find room for Fouts and maybe Moon too. Never was a big fan of Tarkenton

Would have to create a Tier 3 because I'm not so sure I'd remove anyone off the top 2 tiers other than reshuffling a few.

 

[megalodon30]

Elway is one of thee most overrated Dooshbags to ever play QB in the NFL and you're not old enough to have watched him suck in big games.

Pipe down and go sit in the corner.

Let the hate flow, homie.

 

[SteelersPride]

The broncos and elway are a bit irrelevant anymore, even including him as a GM. I don't think the "hate" is going to flow. Very few people care.

 

[ATL96Steeler]

Rodgers is an interesting case study if you will...I think talent wise, he's clearly one of the top 20 all time, but as @FaCe-LeE-uS suggested, there needs to be a tier A, B, C, etc.

While many of us had him in the Brady, Brees, Manning tier at one time...imo he was on a MVP run for a short time but, I always thought he belonged in the tier with Ben, and Eli.

 

[SteelersPride]

Rodgers is an interesting case study if you will...I think talent wise, he's clearly one of the top 20 all time, but as @FaCe-LeE-uS suggested, there needs to be a tier A, B, C, etc.

While many of us had him in the Brady, Brees, Manning tier at one time...imo he was on a MVP run for a short time but, I always thought he belonged in the tier with Ben, and Eli.

I agree 100% here. Most talented, and GOAT are not the same thing IMHO.

 

[eaglesnut]

Well, you did compare him to Donovan McNabb. Kinda sounds like hate. And 21st is a little weak. In the 10-15 range at least, imo.

Andy Reid would have won 9 Super Bowls with Rodgers's instead of McNabb during that era.

McNabb sucked and Andy dragged his lame ass to moments from glory multiple times, only to have donny throw it all away every time.

 

[Clayton]

Andy Reid would have won 9 Super Bowls with Rodgers's instead of McNabb during that era.

McNabb sucked and Andy dragged his lame ass to moments from glory multiple times, only to have donny throw it all away every time.

If you actually look at career stats, McNabb and Alex Smith are right next to each other. I definitely think that the Eagles would have won 1-3 Super Bowls with a better QB when they had those defenses.

 

[wings-pens2166]

I really wanted to vote Yes because I do believe he is. But I had to go with the cheesehead is stupid, because, well, it’s stupid.

 

[ATL96Steeler]

Andy Reid would have won 9 Super Bowls with Rodgers's instead of McNabb during that era.

McNabb sucked and Andy dragged his lame ass to moments from glory multiple times, only to have donny throw it all away every time.

McNabb didn't suck, but he was the weak link...that run from '00 to '05 had a top 10 DEF and OFC for most of it and didn't produce a SB and that's really how Reid's lack of producing in the post season was born.

Idk about 9, GB had some pretty good teams as well and only got 1, he would've won one at least I think.