If the ASG vote were today

[tzill]

Which Giants would make the team?

Webb
Ray
Doval
Lee
Flores
Rogers
Miller
RanRod

I’d guess Webb, Ray, Flores, Doval.

 

[msgkings322]

Which Giants would make the team?

Webb
Ray
Doval
Lee
Flores
Rogers
Miller
RanRod

I’d guess Webb, Ray, Flores, Doval.

No way they get 4 all stars

Webb for sure, maybe Doval or Ray. Flores I don't think so, lotta 1Bs and DHs with better numbers in the NL

 

[tzill]

No way they get 4 all stars

Webb for sure, maybe Doval or Ray. Flores I don't think so, lotta 1Bs and DHs with better numbers in the NL

Ok, fair point about the ML leader in RBI.

What about RanRod and Rogers? Can’t be too many other RP with better numbers…

 

[calsnowskier]

Non-closer RP just don’t get named. And Walker is NOT an all-star this year.

Webb is a no brainer.
Ray is solid, but NOT at an all-star level.
Flores might make an MVP push, but not an all-star at 1B/DH
Yaz is having a strong year, but not All-Star.
Lee may get some vote support, and he is having a nice year, but not really all-star worthy
Chappy is making too many errors (shows how worthless a stat THAT is) and his bat hasn’t really shown up yet.

End of the day, I would be surprised with anyone beyond Webb gets in.

 

[msgkings322]

Ok, fair point about the ML leader in RBI.

What about RanRod and Rogers? Can’t be too many other RP with better numbers…

RBI lol

They ain't putting him in over Alonso and Freeman and Harper and a few others

RanRod is a 7th inning guy and Rogers an 8th...very doubtful on both. Come on man you have watched the game a long time, you know how they do it

 

[msgkings322]

Non-closer RP just don’t get named. And Walker is NOT an all-star this year.

Webb is a no brainer.
Ray is solid, but NOT at an all-star level.
Flores might make an MVP push, but not an all-star at 1B/DH
Yaz is having a strong year, but not All-Star.
Lee may get some vote support, and he is having a nice year, but not really all-star worthy
Chappy is making too many errors (shows how worthless a stat THAT is) and his bat hasn’t really shown up yet.

End of the day, I would be surprised with anyone beyond Webb gets in.

I don't see Flores getting a lot of MVP votes either

 

[LHG]

No way they get 4 all stars

Webb for sure, maybe Doval or Ray. Flores I don't think so, lotta 1Bs and DHs with better numbers in the NL

Agree. I think Webb gets in for sure and maybe Ray. Doval isn't a dominant closer and dominant non closers are usually reserved for ones on teams who have no other representatives.

 

[LHG]

I will point out that Ramos and Yastrzemski are in a 3 way tie (with Andy Pages) for 9th place among NL outfielders in OPS+. That should at least put them in this discussion as well.

 

[msgkings322]

I will point out that Ramos and Yastrzemski are in a 3 way tie (with Andy Pages) for 9th place among NL outfielders in OPS+. That should at least put them in this discussion as well.

LOL come on man

How many OFs are on the teams? 6 maybe?

 

[msgkings322]

I will point out that Ramos and Yastrzemski are in a 3 way tie (with Andy Pages) for 9th place among NL outfielders in OPS+. That should at least put them in this discussion as well.

Ramos pulled ahead today and there's still time, so if he keeps on this tear he could make the team for sure.

 

[tzill]

Non-closer RP just don’t get named. And Walker is NOT an all-star this year.

Webb is a no brainer.
Ray is solid, but NOT at an all-star level.
Flores might make an MVP push, but not an all-star at 1B/DH
Yaz is having a strong year, but not All-Star.
Lee may get some vote support, and he is having a nice year, but not really all-star worthy
Chappy is making too many errors (shows how worthless a stat THAT is) and his bat hasn’t really shown up yet.

End of the day, I would be surprised with anyone beyond Webb gets in.

Ray is NOT an all-star??
He's 6-0; 1.25 WHIP and 3.04 ERA 1.2 WAR....I think that's AS level
Yaz was never in the convo
Lee is .782 OPS and 1.4 WAR....probably not AS
Chap is .759 OPS and 1.9 WAR...he's in the convo
Wilmer won't make it b/c he adds no value on defense. There is no NL DH having a better year though.

You may be right and its only Webb, but one of the relievers should go; we've got four monsters in that bullpen (Doval, RanRod, Miller, Rogers)...but they won't have the saves.

 

[msgkings322]

Ray is NOT an all-star??
He's 6-0; 1.25 WHIP and 3.04 ERA 1.2 WAR....I think that's AS level
Yaz was never in the convo
Lee is .782 OPS and 1.4 WAR....probably not AS
Chap is .759 OPS and 1.9 WAR...he's in the convo
Wilmer won't make it b/c he adds no value on defense. There is no NL DH having a better year though.

You may be right and its only Webb, but one of the relievers should go; we've got four monsters in that bullpen (Doval, RanRod, Miller, Rogers)...but they won't have the saves.

Ray has a case, agreed. Needs to keep it up the next month and a half obviously. Ramos can get there too if he keeps hitting. No way they get more than 3.

 

[LHG]

LOL come on man

How many OFs are on the teams? 6 maybe?

Have you looked at the 8 outfielders above them? They are really close to the next 3 guys. Its close enough that both should be in the conversation of possible All-Stars. Not saying that would be automatics but if we are talking Flores as a 1B/DH pick, then we should talk about Ramos and/or Yastrzemski as possible outfield picks.

 

[msgkings322]

Have you looked at the 8 outfielders above them? They are really close to the next 3 guys. Its close enough that both should be in the conversation of possible All-Stars. Not saying that would be automatics but if we are talking Flores as a 1B/DH pick, then we should talk about Ramos and/or Yastrzemski as possible outfield picks.

Right but I already said Flores should not and will not be considered.

But Ramos has a good case if he keeps up the recent hitting. Yaz there's just no way.

 

[tzill]

Have you looked at the 8 outfielders above them? They are really close to the next 3 guys. Its close enough that both should be in the conversation of possible All-Stars. Not saying that would be automatics but if we are talking Flores as a 1B/DH pick, then we should talk about Ramos and/or Yastrzemski as possible outfield picks.

I haven’t researched it (yet!) but I’ve got to think Wilmer is near the top of the DH stats.