juliansteed
Well-Known Member
Not sure what you are meaning...
Ramsay did torture Theon. Even worse in the books.
Book Jeyne/Talisa survives with the child, which would throw quite the monkeywrench into things.
The Hound and Brienne do fight in the books.
You'll note that I said scenes with Ramsay torturing Theon. Of course books don't have "scenes" but I'm sure you can figure out what I mean. We get Ramsay capturing Theon in Book 2 and then the next few books we only hear other characters mention Theon but don't actually see him again until Book 5 when he's been transformed into Reek.
Yes in addition to having a different name and backstory, Robb's book wife also has a different fate. It's unclear to me what point you are making by mentioning that as it relates to my comment though. I was responding to someone that was suggesting that Talisa was some sort of epic fail on the show, comparable to the Dorne storyline. That poster didn't go into detail but I didn't get the impression that they were referring to the fact that she died on the show but lived in the books (which I would probably still question if that's what I thought was meant). It just seemed like he/she had a problem in general with the character. The changes and the character herself were pretty insignificant in my opinion. The fact that Robb broke his oath and married someone else is what mostly mattered. The fact that she was the daughter of a Lannister bannerman was kind of interesting but I'm not sure that it was all that critical.
I don't remember The Hound and Brienne fighting at all in the books. Not saying it didn't happen as I certainly don't have them memorized, but I just don't remember it happening.
Last edited: