Eli Manning

[flaraider]

OMG Eli

2 picks first 2 possessions , one for six.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Nassib> Eli

Disgusting that this guy has two rings .

 

[dirtboy068]

What woulld you do with Eli "pickoff" Manning?

I actually feel sorry for eli. what would you do if you were Tom C?? Tom is in a very hard spot figuring out whether to bench the two time SB winner .tom could let him try to pull himself together or let him fight threw it on the field. Some players handle benching different, some it totally destroys their pride and others it motivates them to get it together. what would you do if you were coaching the Giants?

 

[tabascojet]

let him fail. and use the stellar 1st round pick to draft his replacement

 

[David_son]

I would bench him if you go 0-5 Nassib cant be any worst. You are already out of the race. Time to see what you have.

 

[dirtboy068]

sorry didn't mean to burn your thread with another one. I started making mine before you posted yours'


I actually feel sorry for eli. what would you do if you were Tom C?? Tom is in a very hard spot figuring out whether to bench the two time SB winner .tom could let him try to pull himself together or let him fight threw it on the field. Some players handle benching different, some it totally destroys their pride and others it motivates them to get it together. what would you do if you were coaching the Giants?

ps he almost threw another . got away with it

 

[dirtboy068]

eli really need that drive but he again almost there a pick. maybe that scoring drive will calm him down.

 

[dirtboy068]

I would bench him if you go 0-5 Nassib cant be any worst. You are already out of the race. Time to see what you have.

I wonder what eli's contract looks like present day IE: how much time and guarantees.

 

[dirtboy068]

let him fail. and use the stellar 1st round pick to draft his replacement

they drafted nassib though. hes not in the picture if eli totally bombs out?

 

[NinerSickness]

Nassib> Eli

 

[dirtboy068]

I would bench him if you go 0-5 Nassib cant be any worst. You are already out of the race. Time to see what you have.

what if nassib played well?

 

[dirtboy068]

Nassib> Eli

Disgusting that this guy has two rings .

eli earned both of them. his first SB run maybe the greatest qb performance through the playoffs ever.

 

[tabascojet]

what if nassib played well?

herschel walker trade him....

 

[flaraider]

sorry didn't mean to burn your thread with another one. I started making mine before you posted yours'


I actually feel sorry for eli. what would you do if you were Tom C?? Tom is in a very hard spot figuring out whether to bench the two time SB winner .tom could let him try to pull himself together or let him fight threw it on the field. Some players handle benching different, some it totally destroys their pride and others it motivates them to get it together. what would you do if you were coaching the Giants?

ps he almost threw another . got away with it

All good man, I agree Coughlin in a tough spot, that look on Eli's face tells a lot right now, probably time for plan B as painful as that may be.

 

[tabascojet]

use the pieces to rebuild for multiple SBs....hell even dilfer won a trophy they dont need eli.

 

[wildturkey]

Eli has two rings. He earned them. He's a pretty good quarterback. However, this season should finally put the rest the question of "Is Eli an elite quarterback?". I never believed it but if you believe it after the start to this season, you're delusional

 

[dirtboy068]

herschel walker trade him....

what about his fat contract? some like jax or cleveland would be willing gamble on him?

 

[dirtboy068]

use the pieces to rebuild for multiple SBs....hell even dilfer won a trophy they dont need eli.

eli was clutch for both SB runs. the first one was maybe the great qb performance in play history.

 

[NinerSickness]

Eli has two rings. He earned them. He's a pretty good quarterback. However, this season should finally put the rest the question of "Is Eli an elite quarterback?". I never believed it but if you believe it after the start to this season, you're delusional

That's ridiculous. Eli Manning is still Eli freeking Manning, and the rest of the NFL better not forget it once they get these problems solved. The start of this season is clearly an anomaly. He's proven he can play better than this. They're having problems that go WAY beyond Eli .

5 or 6 games and all of a sudden the guy isn't a great QB. :rollseyes: Short sided.

 

[dirtboy068]

That's ridiculous. Eli Manning is still Eli freeking Manning, and the rest of the NFL better not forget it once they get these problems solved. The start of this season is clearly an anomaly. He's proven he can play better than this. They're having problems that go WAY beyond Eli .

5 or 6 games and all of a sudden the guy isn't a great QB. :rollseyes: Short sided.

but these 5 games have been most of the worst qb I've seen in awhile. last year didn't go so well either " not saying it was all eli