Eli Manning

[NinerSickness]

*note i think Ryan gets to the SB this year.

It'll never happen.

 

[Clayton]

The stats tell me that Ryan is the better QB but gun to my head and Im a GM, Im taking the guy that has Tiger Woods like confidence, a cannon arm and an average supporting cast over the guy thats had top5 offensive talent around him for his whole career.

 

[NinerSickness]

The stats tell me that Ryan is the better QB but gun to my head and Im a GM, Im taking the guy that has Tiger Woods like confidence, a cannon arm and an average supporting cast over the guy thats had top5 offensive talent around him for his whole career.

I'll drink to that! (in a couple of hours when the Niners' game starts).

 

[JDM]

why, the team is built around Ryan and the offense and rightfully so in an offensive league. He has probably 3 HORer to throw to and had a nice running game to boot? Plus it's not like the ATL defense was that bad, i'd say they were average since he has been there.

Because it's a team game. Same reason Eli gets too much.

 

[Jack_John_Mark]

Is Eli Manning on drugs?

Let the discussion begin

 

[Golden Spur]

I think he's definitely going to need some anti-inflammatories and painkillers after being knocked him on his ass so many times.

 

[Steelboy84]

Giants seem to be done, cant believe it

 

[Black Adam]

Giants seem to be done, cant believe it

Agreed. The Giants are WAY out ta whack. Luckily it's still early in the season...

 

[pabartl787]

Our defense is embarrassing

 

[SEC Official]

Game killed me... I started Sam Bradford today instead of Cam Newton (not the best options I know)... but I figured the Giants would rebound from the 1st two games and Cam would be himself.

Instead, Sam shits the bed against Dallas... and Cam has a good game against the Giants.

What a day....

 

[Shanemansj13]

Ever since he did that goofy commercial with Peyton. And Peyton is the opposite...deadly

 

[I'm always right]

No he's just a whining, crying douche bag who is lucky to be Archie's kid and play on talented teams.

 

[Southieinnc]

He is quite obviously on the wrong ones. Somebody better hook him up.

 

[NinerSickness]

Something is going on with him (and the whole Giants' team). This isn't just a case of bad talent / coaching; something else has to be up. JMO.

 

[Podunkparte]

Cooper Manning: At least he's not Eli

 

[ATL96Steeler]

I said last week actually that I thought Cam was the best passer of the young read option QBs and was blasted for it as if he was already washed up.

NYG have a tendency to look really ugly at times...the fire Coughlin rumors start to swirl and they pull it together late. I don't know if they will happen this yr, but Eli is far too good to not scratch at all.

 

[RoboticDreams]

Let the discussion begin

No he just has Downs.

 

[Dude]

I said last week actually that I thought Cam was the best passer of the young read option QBs and was blasted for it as if he was already washed up.

NYG have a tendency to look really ugly at times...the fire Coughlin rumors start to swirl and they pull it together late. I don't know if they will happen this yr, but Eli is far too good to not scratch at all.

Good point, the Fire Coughlin! rant should lick into gear soon. It has happened so many times.

 

[wildturkey]

Pretty sure I said it went people bitched about David Wilson the first week, I said it last week when people bitched about about the lack of a running game, and now I see people are finally waking up to see what I said; the Giants O-line is awful. That's what is wrong with the Giants offense. In fact, line play on both sides will continue to sink them. They stink.

 

[Nasty_Magician]

I'm as big an Eli hater as there is but the guy has absolutely no o-line. I will give this inbred faced idiot some credit, he takes his ass kickings like a man. With that said, I'm loving watching the Giants implode after all those years. Aside from the disliking the Giants, I really wish they hadn't won the Super Bowls of late because the description of Eli being the "Frank Stallone" of NFL quarterbacks was just so perfect.