Better QB year? 04 Peyton, 07 Brady, or 11 Rodgers?

[BobGnarly]

Hopefully Manning doesn't take a shot and cripple his 37 year old body.

You should probably be more worried about A Rodg having to run for his life every play than Peyton who has been sacked the least times of any QB in the league the last couple years

 

[Broncos6482]

Peyton Manning - 121.1 QB Rating 4,557 yds 49 tds 10 ints 67.6 completion %(497 pass attempts, 15 games)

Tom Brady - 117.2 QB Rating 4,806 yds 50 tds 8 ints 68.9 completion % (578 pass attempts, 16 games)

Aaron Rodgers - 122.5 QB Rating 4,643 yds 45 tds 6 ints 68.3 completion % (502 pass attempts, 15 games)

I would take Rodgers. Fewest picks, highest yards per attempt, lowest interception rate, second best td rate.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

You should probably be more worried about A Rodg having to run for his life every play than Peyton who has been sacked the least times of any QB in the league the last couple years

A great deal why Peyton doesn't take sacks is because Peyton is incredibly decisive and intelligent pre-snap. Pass rush had about 1.5 seconds generally to get to Peyton or the ball is already hitting a receiver.

 

[briz almighty]

Peyton Manning - 121.1 QB Rating 4,557 yds 49 tds 10 ints 67.6 completion %(497 pass attempts, 15 games)

Tom Brady - 117.2 QB Rating 4,806 yds 50 tds 8 ints 68.9 completion % (578 pass attempts, 16 games)

Aaron Rodgers - 122.5 QB Rating 4,643 yds 45 tds 6 ints 68.3 completion % (502 pass attempts, 15 games)


Which season was more impressive? Brady of course holds the record with 50 tds and Rodgers holds the record for highest qb rating.

But to me...Peyton's season was more prolific. 49 tds vs 50 tds to Brady but 81 less passing attempts. That's 2-3 whole games worth of passing attempts for most quarterbacks. Rodgers also had 45 tds playing one less game and having 76 less passing attempts.

The game he sat out...Flynn throws for 6 tds. Now there's no telling what Rodgers would have done...but he might have had a chance to approach that record.

How would you rank these guy's best seasons?

brady played week 15 against the yets in a blizzard with 35 mph winds neither team could throw and he had either 1 td or 0 passing i forget. play that game in peytons cozy rigged dome and brady throws for 5 tds. funny you mention 15 games played for manning and 16 for brady but disregard playing in terrible weather than a dome. good stuff.

 

[fearthepelicans]

It's not trolling when he actually believes it. This guy had (literally) 100's of user names on ESPNGeneral, all of which were utilized to cry about Tom Brady and prop up Peyton. You underestimate him.

I know who he is. I was on ESPN for almost 8 years (geauxtigers1989). What astounds me is how everyone continues to fall for such a transparent act.

 

[JDM]

How hard is it not to answer?

 

[France_Steve]

How hard is it not to answer?

The problem is that he makes really well thought out intelligent posts so people feel compelled to engage him.

 

[Blackshirt]

Brady, Rodgers, Manning in that order. Idk if placed Brady ahead of Rodgers because I can't stand GB and Rodgers or not...

 

[JDM]

I'm not sure I can consider 50TD from Brady the best of the three when it wasn't even the best year of his career. 36-4 was much more impressive.

 

[Steelboy84]

Manning

 

[BOTSLAYER]

Also give me Brady, but how much exactly did Peyton sit out in 04?

13 Manning might top them all.

It is early and I hate the broncos, but this year could really suck for me

I do like Peyton though.

 

[Nipsey]

I know who he is. I was on ESPN for almost 8 years (geauxtigers1989). What astounds me is how everyone continues to fall for such a transparent act.

Nah - choosing to mock him is not "falling" for anything. He's an insecure, apologetic Peyton slurper, and I'm going to remind him every time I see him.

 

[Broncos6482]

Also give me Brady, but how much exactly did Peyton sit out in 04?



It is early and I hate the broncos, but this year could really suck for me

I do like Peyton though.

Just curious why a Lions fan has any reason to hate the Broncos. Care to explain?

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Nah - choosing to mock him is not "falling" for anything. He's an insecure, apologetic Peyton slurper, and I'm going to remind him every time I see him.

So are you denying that Tom Brady was the ultimate stat padder in 2007?

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

I know who he is. I was on ESPN for almost 8 years (geauxtigers1989). What astounds me is how everyone continues to fall for such a transparent act.

I've always spoken the truth....always have, always will. Sadly, my truths get under the skin of insecure Pats fans with a massive inferiority complex

 

[Nipsey]

I've always spoken the truth....always have, always will. Sadly, my truths get under the skin of insecure Pats fans with a massive inferiority complex

I used to tell you you had an inferiority complex. Get your own material.

 

[Nipsey]

I've always spoken the truth....always have, always will. Sadly, my truths get under the skin of insecure Pats fans with a massive inferiority complex

See? He thinks he's not trolling. Until he's made to look stupid -- then it's "you took the bait, derp!"

 

[ChicagoIrish]

13 Manning might top them all.

Was going to post that.

So was I.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

I used to tell you you had an inferiority complex. Get your own material.

So are you denying that Tom Brady was the ultimate stat padder in 2007?

 

[JDM]

So are you denying that Tom Brady was the ultimate stat padder in 2007?

Yes. The team was incapable of closing games on the ground and had no choice but to keep passing.