3 yr 105 million for Geno

[eaglesnut]

I don't know. He had two games against the Niners and one against KC and averaged 10 points a game against those three.

It's amazing how fast a team can ruin their advantage like they received in the Russell Wilson trade.

 

[Anointed One]

good find

That was credit to @flyerhawk

 

[eaglesnut]

Hahaha, post deleted because a mod can't handle being called out for his ridiculous whining.

Harold, which 32 QBs are better than Geno Smith right now?

Add in the draft and a few that just retired and it's 52.

 

[Anointed One]

It's amazing how fast a team can ruin their advantage like they received in the Russell Wilson trade.

Ruin our advantage? LOL... You mean drafting a great LT in Cross and RB Kenneth Walker with Denver's pick's last year? Oh yeah we have their #5 overall in the 1st round and their #37 overall in the 2nd round in this years 2023 draft... A bit premature to say we, "ruin their advantage"... 25 million a year for Geno is not that expensive for a starting QB...

 

[eaglesnut]

He has a higher ceiling than Carr, but also a lower floor. I'm not surprised to see him offered more per year but with 1 less year in total and/or guaranteed.

No.

Carr and Geno were drafted by trash franchises. Geno got to a semi-decent one and suddenly looked playable. Carr was already playable in a dumpster fire situation and he was looking good in Jon Gruden's offense. It's crazy to look at Geno as anything other than a guy that has had a decent 6-10 game stretch among a career of trash.

 

[shopson67]

Guaranteed money is the only number that matters.

$30M guaranteed and $40M in incentives per Spotrac, but they don't have details yet.

 

[eaglesnut]

Daniel Jones likes this

Giants will say "Seahawks are dumb go ask them what they'll pay you."

 

[eaglesnut]

Ruin our advantage? LOL... You mean drafting a great LT in Cross and RB Kenneth Walker with Denver's pick's last year? Oh yeah we have their #5 overall in the 1st round and their #37 overall in the 2nd round in this years 2023 draft... A bit premature to say we, "ruin their advantage"... 25 million a year for Geno is not that expensive for a starting QB...

That's what I mean. You waste all those elite talents when you pair them with a bum like Geno. They'll build up the team and it will be held back by the most important player.

The Seahawks have dominated the Eagles and now they won't. I love it. It was looking iffy for a minute there with all those extra resources and the potential for a top young QB too.

 

[PDay8810]

That was credit to @flyerhawk

so noted.

 

[PDay8810]

$30M guaranteed and $40M in incentives per Spotrac, but they don't have details yet.

Thanks
Post #35 and the anointed one liked it

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

I think you will see it's a two year deal. The guaranteed money is the nut.

Only think I would fear is Seattle drafting the Florida QB at 5

I hope it's a smoke screen to get a team to take the bait and trade up to gain a future 1st.

 

[fastforward]

No.

Carr and Geno were drafted by trash franchises. Geno got to a semi-decent one and suddenly looked playable. Carr was already playable in a dumpster fire situation and he was looking good in Jon Gruden's offense. It's crazy to look at Geno as anything other than a guy that has had a decent 6-10 game stretch among a career of trash.

Agree to disagree. Smith didn't have much quality on the roster to support him in 2022. He still put up a better performance than Carr has done with 8 years of better roster support. I'll go with Pro Football Reference's Approximate Value here. Smith got a 15 rating last year. Carr's highest values were 14 and 13. Carr has been consistently mediocre.

I think most people would take Smith over Carr if they were shooting for the Super Bowl with a mediocre roster. With a championship roster Carr would be the safer bet.

 

[kcden]

That's what I mean. You waste all those elite talents when you pair them with a bum like Geno. They'll build up the team and it will be held back by the most important player.

The Seahawks have dominated the Eagles and now they won't. I love it. It was looking iffy for a minute there with all those extra resources and the potential for a top young QB too.

You say this as if... they had better options? Its a 3 year contract that is realistically only 2 years unless he outplays it, and someone needs to play QB this year.

 

[Clayton]

What Seattle says: "We're still interested in taking a QB at 5 even though we have Geno"

What Seattle is really saying: "We arent interesting in QB at all but hoping everyone will trade ahead of us so we'll get Will Anderson"

 

[sonnyblack65]

Good for Geno!

Yeah he persevered and it paid off, while Kap pouted like a bitch and took his ball home and played the race card

 

[eaglesnut]

You say this as if... they had better options? Its a 3 year contract that is realistically only 2 years unless he outplays it, and someone needs to play QB this year.

They bailed on the rebuild for geno. Geno. Now they'll be too good to get a QB. It's not as if he killed it all year. He was doing nothing baker mayfield and andy dalton weren't doing at the end of the year lol.

 

[Anointed One]

They bailed on the rebuild for geno. Geno. Now they'll be too good to get a QB. It's not as if he killed it all year. He was doing nothing baker mayfield and andy dalton weren't doing at the end of the year lol.

Look at their last 4 games of the season... Give me Geno every time if you're going to take these stats into consideration... Plus, 2 of Geno's games were against top 5 defenses over that span...

Baker:
View attachment 322748

Geno:
View attachment 322751

 

[Dude]

Yeah he persevered and it paid off, while Kap pouted like a bitch and took his ball home and played the race card

Sonny my man, where you been? Keeping @DirtDirtDirt and his accessory felons in the basement? Got to keep those dudes away from the fine vino lest they become winos.

 

[Anointed One]

eaglesnut said:

They bailed on the rebuild for geno. Geno. Now they'll be too good to get a QB. It's not as if he killed it all year. He was doing nothing baker mayfield and andy dalton weren't doing at the end of the year lol.

Look at their last 4 games of the season... Give me Geno every time if you're going to take these stats into consideration... Plus, 2 of Geno's games were against top 5 defenses over that span...

Baker:


Geno:

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

That's what I mean. You waste all those elite talents when you pair them with a bum like Geno. They'll build up the team and it will be held back by the most important player.

The Seahawks have dominated the Eagles and now they won't. I love it. It was looking iffy for a minute there with all those extra resources and the potential for a top young QB too.

I wanted to trade up for Stroud but it is what it is. Load up on defensive line, LBs and a center and see what happens. I'd give the Eagles the edge right now but we'll see what it looks like come week 1